Preventive Detention; Gujarat Anti-Social Activities Act; Judicial Review; Right to Bail; Public Order; Procedural Guarantees; Detention Grounds; Supreme Court
0  19 Sep, 1989
Listen in 01:28 mins | Read in 15:00 mins
EN
HI

Ahmedhussain Shaikhhussain © Ahmed Kalio Vs. Commissioner of Police, Ahmedabad & Anr.

  Supreme Court Of India Writ PetitionCriminal /54/1989
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, the petitioner was detained under the Gujarat Prevention of Anti-social Activities Act, 1985, for allegedly conducting illegal liquor activities and disturbing public order by creating fear. ...

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 8

PETITIONER:

AHMEDHUSSAIN SHAIKHHUSSAIN (C) AHMED KALIO

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE, AHMEDABAD & ANR.

DATE OF JUDGMENT19/09/1989

BENCH:

MISRA RANGNATH

BENCH:

MISRA RANGNATH

OZA, G.L. (J)

CITATION:

1989 AIR 2274 1989 SCR Supl. (1) 177

1989 SCC (4) 751 JT 1989 (3) 689

1989 SCALE (2)545

CITATOR INFO :

D 1992 SC 979 (10A)

ACT:

Gujarat Prevention of Anti-Social Activities Act, 1985:

Sections 3 and 9--Detention Order--Satisfaction of detaining

authority--Not open to judicial review--Disclosure of ade-

quate facts to enable full and adequate

representation--Necessity for.

HEADNOTE:

The petitioner was directed to be detained under section

3(2) of the Gujarat Prevention of Anti-social Activities

Act, 1985. In the grounds of detention it was alleged that

the petitioner was conducting anti-social activities of

illegally storing indigenous and foreign liquor in his

possession and selling it by himself and through his men and

that he and his men beat innocent citizens thereby creating

an atmosphere of fear and terror and he had thus become

obstructionist in the maintenance of public order. Reference

was made to a previous order of detention which had been set

aside by the High Court, and to the fact that notwithstand-

ing the previous detention, the petitioner continued to

carry on his criminal and anti-social activities affecting

maintenance of public order. It was further stated in the

grounds that the detaining authority had considered taking

action against the petitioner u/s. 93 of the Prohibition Act

for good conduct, and under sections 56B and 57(c) of the

Bombay Police Act for his externment, but all these steps

were either found not feasible or adequate. It was then

stated that there was a possibility of the petitioner, who

was in jail, being released on bail and continuing his

criminal activities, and to prevent the same there was no

other alternative except to pass the order of detention.

Allowing the writ petition and quashing the order of

detention this Court,

HELD: (1) The satisfaction of the detaining authority is

not open to judicial review but a citizen is entitled to

protection within the meaning of Article 22(5) of the Con-

stitution of the procedural guarantees envisaged by law, and

the Court frowns upon any deviation or infraction of the

procedural requirements. [184A-B]

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 8

(2) The fact that the detenu was in jail at the time the

order of

178

detention was made and the possibility of his release from

jail being made a ground of detention is not approved of by

this Court. [184C]

Ramesh Yadav v. District Magistrate, Etah, [1985] 4 SCC

232; Binod Singh v. District Magistrate, Dhanbad, Bihar &

Ors., [1986] 4 SCC 416 and Smt. Shashi Aggarwal v. State of

U.P., A.I.R. 1988 SC 596, referred to.

(3) The detaining authority must disclose in a case

where the detenu is already in jail that there is cogent and

relevant material constituting fresh facts to necessitate

making of an order of detention. [184F]

Abdul Razak Abdul Wahib Sheikh v. Shri S.N. Sinha,

Commissioner of Police, Ahmedabad & Anr.,, J.T. 1989 1 SC

478 and Ramesh v. State of Gujarat, J.T. 1989 3 SC 279,

referred to.

(4) There is a wide gap between law and order and public

order. The criminal offence may relate to the field of law

and order but such an offence would not necessarily give

rise to a situation of public order. Depending upon peculiar

situations, an act which may otherwise have been overlooked

as innocuous might constitute a problem of public order.

Selling of liquor by the petitioner would certainly amount

to an offence under the Prohibition Act but without some-

thing more would not give rise to a problem of public order.

Similarly commission of any other criminal offence--even

assault or threat Of assault--would not bring the matter

within the ambit of public order. [185B-C]

(5) Disclosure of adequate facts to enable a full and

adequate representation to the Preventive Detention Board is

one of the positive guarantees within the scope of Article

22(5) of the Constitution. In the present case the grounds

of detention show that the allegations are more or less

vague and have the effect of making it difficult for the

petitioner to make an adequate representation. [185D-E]

A.K. Roy's case, [1982] 1 SCC 272, referred to.

(6) The grounds of detention show how helpless the

authorities feel in the matter of enforcing prohibition

within the State. [186B]

(7) It is perhaps necessary to indicate that the provi-

sions of the Prohibition Act of 1949 or the Bombay Police

Act should be suitably amended to meet the requirements of

society. Even if the provisions under those Acts are made

stringent the person proceeded against has the benefit of a

trial or a regular hearing and pursuing an appeal

179

against adverse orders, but in a case of preventive deten-

tion trial is avoided and liberty is taken away without

providing a right to defend himself. [185H; 186A]

JUDGMENT:

CRIMINAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Writ Petition

(Crl.)No. 54 of 1989.

(Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India).

T.U. Mehta and S.C. Patel for the Petitioner.

S.K. Dholakia, M.N. Shroof and Ms. Hemantika Wahi for

the Respondents.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

RANGANATH MISRA, J. The Commissioner of Police,

Ahmedabad by his order dated 26.12.1988, directed the deten-

tion of the petitioner under section 3(2) of the Gujarat

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 8

Prevention of AntiSocial Activities Act, 1985 (hereinafter

referred to as 'the Act'). The petitioner was taken into

custody under the order on that very day.

The material portion of the order of detention

stated:

"WHEREAS, I.S.N. Sinha, Commissioner of

Police, Ahmedabad City, am empowered in this

behalf by the Government of Gujarat by its

order, Home Department No. G.G./155/SB-

IV/PASA/1085/1191 dated 28.5.1985 under sub-

section (2) of section 3 of the Gujarat Pre-

vention of Anti-Social Activities Act, 1985.

AND WHEREAS, I am satisfied with

respect to person known as Shri Ahmed-hussain

@ Kalio Shaikhhussain Shaikh resident of

Dariyapur, Bukhari Mohallo, Ahmedabad City,

that with a view to preventing him from acting

in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance

of public order in the area of Ahmedabad City,

it is necessary to make an order directing

that the said Shri Ahmedhussain @ Shaikhhus-

sain Shaikh be detained.

NOW, THEREAFTER, in exercise of the

powers conferred by sub-section (1) of section

3 of the Gujarat Prevention of Anti-Social

Activities Act, 1985, I, S.N.

180

Sinha, Commissioner of Police, Ahmedabad City

hereby direct that the said Shri Ahmedhussain

@ Kalio Shaikhhussain Shaikh be detained."

The grounds communicated to the petitioner under section

9(1) of the Act alleged that the petitioner was conducting

anti-social activities of illegally storing indigenous and

foreign liquor in his possession and was selling it by

himself and through his men in the area of Dariyapur and

three prosecutions had been launched against him under the

Bombay Prohibition Act of 1949. From the particulars it

appeared that one case was pending in court while the other

two were under investigation. The detaining authority there-

after stated:

"Thus on careful study of the above-said

complaints and entire papers with the propos-

al, it is found that you are a prohibition

'bootlegger' and are conducting anti-social

activities of selling indigenous and foreign

liquor illegally. You and your companions beat

the innocent citizens of the above-stated area

in public and create an atmosphere of fear and

terror for continuing your criminal anti-

social activities. Moreover, you and your

companions are creating atmosphere of fear by

beating the innocent citizens, threaten them

to kill while passing through that area by

showing dangerous weapons suspecting them to

be the informants of the police. The customers

of your adda in drunken condition play mis-

chief, and beat the persons in open; people

residing there have fear and terror is spread

in the said area. Moreover, you beat those who

oppose your bringing the quantity of wine and

you threaten to kill and you create an atmos-

phere of fear and terror. Because of such

activities, the citizens residing in the

above-stated area have fear of damage to their

property and the safety for themselves. Thus

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 8

you become an obstructionist in the mainte-

nance of public order.

The citizens residing or doing their

trade in the said area have stated the facts

corroborating your above-stated criminal

anti-social activities as a result of which

you become obstructionist in the maintenance

of public order. Such incidents have been

stated in detail. The copies of the statements

thereof are given to you herewith".

Reference was made to a previous order of detention of July

12, 1987,

181

which was set aside by the High Court on 3.12.1987 and to

the fact that notwithstanding the previous detention, the

petitioner continued to carry on his criminal and anti-

social activities affecting maintenance of public order.

In the grounds it was further stated:

"I had also considered to prevent your anti-

social activities of selling wine by taking

action u/s 93 of the Prohibition Act. But

according to the provision of section 93, only

surety for good conduct can be taken. I am

fully satisfied that even if you give the

surety for good conduct, you will not obey the

same. Looking to your activities uptil now, I

feel that you will not obey the same. So I do

not think it possible to prevent your such

anti-social activities immediately by taking

action against you under section 93 of the

Prohibition Act.

I had considered to take action

against you u/s 57(c) of the Bombay Police Act

for your externment. But under the provision

of section 57(c), three convictions within a

period of three years under the Prohibition

Act are necessary. In your case, of the cases

which are registered against you under the

Prohibition Act, one is pending in the Court

and two cases are pending for police investi-

gation. In your case there is no such convic-

tion; so it is not possible under the law to

take action against you u/s 57(c) for extern-

ment.

I had also considered to take pro-

ceeding against you u/s 56B of the Bombay

Police Act for externment: but if the proceed-

ings u/s 56B of the Bombay Police Act are

taken against you, first of all show cause

notice is required to be given to you u/s

59(1) of the Bombay Police Act. Then such

order can be passed only after giving you full

opportunity to defend by examining your de-

fence witnesses. Even if such order is passed

against you, you can go in appeal against the

externment u/s 60 of the said Act and the

possibility of granting stay to you cannot be

avoided. So a long time is taken in the pro-

ceedings of externment u/s 56B and during this

period you may continue your anti-social

activities and there are all chances that you

become obstructionist in the maintenance of

public order; so it is not possible to prevent

your anti-social activities immedia-

182

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 5 of 8

tely by taking action u/s 56B and I do not

think proper to take action against you u/s

56B.

You and your companions of

Dariyapur--Kalupur are keeping dangerous

weapons and making conspiracy to beat the

innocent persons and because of your activi-

ties an atmosphere of fear and terror is

spread in the said area and people have fear

of safety for themselves and damage to their

property. Because of your such activities you

have become obstructionist to the maintenance

of public order and because of your such

activities the atmosphere of public order has

been disturbed. Thus considering all the above

facts, I am fully satisfied that you are a

prohibition boot-legger and you are conducting

anti-social activities of selling indigenous

and foreign liquor and you are creating an

atmosphere of fear and terror by beating

innocent persons in public and threaten them

to kill by keeping dangerous weapons in the

above-stated area and you are conducting

activity of selling the wine in person or

through your persons. Action under the ordi-

nary law has been taken for preventing your

such activities. At present you are in jail

under the Prohibition Act ....... There is

every possibility that you will be bailed out

by giving surety by the Court because this

offence is bailable. It is quite possible that

you may continue your criminal anti-social

activities after release on bail from

court ....... As it has become necessary to

prevent your anti-social activities to prevent

the same as there is no other alternative and

as the last alternate I pass the order to take

you in detention under the said Act."

A list of documents relied upon by the detaining author-

ity was appended to the grounds and the said list is Annex-

ure-D to the petition.

The detaining authority has filed his affidavit in

support of the order of detention. In paragraph 7 of such

affidavit the deponent has stated:

"With reference to paragraph 7 of the peti-

tion, I submit that the averments made therein

are absolutely wrong in view of the fact that

the petitioner has not 'been wrongly involved

by me under the P.A.S.A. Act. It is only on

183

perusal of the relevant record which has been

supplied to the petitioner and after consider-

ing the prognosis about the futuristic activi-

ties of the petitioner, I was subjectively

satisfied that it is necessary to detain the

petitioner preventively under the provisions

of the P.A.S.A. Act with a view to preventing

him from indulging in like activities and,

therefore, the impugned order was passed by

me".

In paragraph 8(c)of the counter-affidavit the

detaining authority has further stated:

"I further submit that so far as the petition-

er's detention in the year 1987 is concerned,

it is true that the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 6 of 8

had directed the authorities to release the

petitioner and the said fact has already been

clearly mentioned in the grounds of detention.

I further submit that since the Hon'ble Guja-

rat High Court had passed the order, the order

being judicial one, I have nothing to comment

on it. However, I submit that there is no

nexus between the order of the Hon'ble High

Court in that petition and the facts of the

present case and, therefore, the judicial

pronouncement by the Hon'ble Gujarat High

Court has no application whatsoever to the

facts of the present case. Since the present

order is passed on totally fresh grounds which

are sufficient enough to give subjective

satisfaction to me for the purpose of passing

the order of detention ........ I further

submit that the fact that the petitioner was

earlier detained and the fact that the order

of detention was quashed by the Hon'ble Guja-

rat High Court was considered by me and that

has also been mentioned in the grounds of

detention ........ "

The Bombay Prohibition Act of 1949 is in force in the

State of Gujarat and prohibition is in force in this State.

We have extracted a substantial portion of the grounds

of detention communicated to the petitioner to show how

helpless the authorities feel in the matter of enforcing

prohibition within the State. Obviously neither the Prohibi-

tion Act nor the other statutes referred to by the detaining

authority could be called in aid to meet the requirements of

the situation. On his own showing, afraid of the petitioner

being released on bail and resorting to anti-social activi-

ties, and with a view to ensuring his detention in jail the

impugned order has been made.

184

The satisfaction of the detaining authority is not open

to judicial review but as has been pointed out by several

Constitution Bench decisions of this Court a citizen is

entitled to protection within the meaning of Article 22(5)

of the Constitution of the procedural guarantees envisaged

by law. The Court frowns upon any deviation or infraction of

the procedural requirements. That in fact is the only guar-

antee to the citizen against the State's action of preven-

tive detention.

The fact that the detenu was in jail at the time the

order of detention was made and the possibility of his

release from jail being made a ground of detention was not

approved of by this Court in Rarnesh Yadav v. District

Magistrate, Etah & Ors., [1985] 4 SCC 232 and Binod Singh v.

District Magistrate, Dhanbad, Bihar & Ors., [1986] 4 SCC

416. In Smt. Shashi Aggarwal v. State of U.P. & Ors., A.I.R.

1988 SC 596, this Court pointed out:

"Every citizen in this country has the right

to have recourse to law. He has the right to

move the court for bail when he is arrested

under the ordinary law of the land. If the

State thinks that he does not deserve bail the

State could oppose the grant of bail. He

cannot, however, be interdicted from moving

the court for bail by clamping an order of

detention. The possibility of the court grant-

ing bail may not be sufficient. Nor a bald

statement that the person would repeat his

criminal activities would be enough. There

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 7 of 8

must also be credible information or cogent

reasons apparent on the record that the dete-

nu, if enlarged on bail, would act prejudi-

cially to the interest of public order."

We may now refer to two decisions of this Court under

the present Act. In the case of Abdul Razak Abdul. Wahib

Sheikh v. Shri S.N. Sinha, 'Commissioner of Police, Ahmeda-

bad & Anr., J.T. 1989 1 SC 478 it has been held that the

detaining authority must disclose in a case where the detenu

is already in jail that there is cogent and relevant materi-

al constituting fresh facts to necessitate making of an

order of detention. In that case, as here, the detenu was in

jail in connection with a criminal case and the order of

detention was served on him in jail. The detenu's mere

complicity in earlier incidents was not considered adequate

and the detention under the Act was set aside. In the case

of Ramesh v. State of Gujarat & Ors., J.T. 1989 3 SC 279, an

order of detention under the Act was under challenge. The

Court found that referring to incident which constituted the

subject-matter of an earlier

185

order of detention vitiated the impugned order.

Apart from these, in the instant case, the material

disclosed is quite vague with reference to the persons

affected or victimised as also the time and place of such

victimisation. This Court has on several occasions indicated

that there is a wide gap between law and order and public

order. The criminal offence may relate to the filed of law

and order but such an offence would not necessarily give

rise to a situation Of public order. Depending upon peculiar

situations an act which may otherwise have been overlooked

as innocuous might constitute a problem of public order.

Selling of liquor by the petitioner would certainly amount

to an offence under the Prohibition Act but without some-

thing more would not give rise to problem of public order.

Similarly commission of any other criminal offence--even

assault or threat of assaUlt-would not bring the matter

within the ambit of public order.

Disclosure of adequate facts to enable a full and ade-

quate representation to the Preventive Detention Board is

one of the positive guarantees within the scope of Article

22(5) of the Constitution. In A.K. Roy's case, [1982] 1 SCC

272 a Constitution Bench of this Court indicated that full-

est disclosure of material should be made to enable the

representation to be effective. In the present case the

grounds which we have extracted show that the allegations

are more or less vague and have the effect of making it

difficult for the petitioner to make an adequate representa-

tion.

Four witnesses had deposed against the petitioner. Their

statements were supplied to the petitioner without disclos-

ing their names. It is the stand of the respondent that if

the names were disclosed the witnesses were likely to be

bodily injured or even eliminated. There may be certain

situations where the disclosure has to be with-held but in

view of the infirmities already indicated it is not neces-

sary for us to examine whether in the facts of the present

case such withholding would not by itself vitiate the order

of detention.

We are satisfied that the impugned order cannot be

sustained. Accordingly, we quash the order and direct that

the petitioner be set at liberty forthwith.

It is perhaps necessary to indicate that the provisions

of the Prohibition Act of 1949 or the Bombay Police Act

should be suitably amended to meet the requirements of

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 8 of 8

society. Even if the provisions under those Acts are made

stringent the person proceeded against has

186

the benefit of a trial or a regular hearing and pursuing an

appeal against adverse orders, but in a case of preventive

detention trial is avoided and liberty of a citizen is taken

away without providing a right to defend himself. The

grounds provided by the detaining authority have clearly

exhibited a sense of helplessness to meet the requirement of

the situation; that, however, is a matter for the Legisla-

ture and the Administration to consider but the Court has to

zealously guard enchroachments on the liberty of the citi-

zen.

R.S.S. Petition

allowed.

187

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter