excise duty, Ashvagandharist, Ayurvedic preparation, patent medicine, proprietary medicine, Medicinal and Toilet Preparations Act, Finance Act 1962, self-generated alcohol, tax exemption, Supreme Court India
0  19 Sep, 1989
Listen in 01:42 mins | Read in 36:00 mins
EN
HI

Aphali Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors.

  Supreme Court Of India Civil Appeal /1845 N/1974
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, the appellant manufactured an Ayurvedic preparation called "Ashvagandharist" with self-generated alcohol, which was not suitable for ordinary alcoholic consumption. This product was initially exempt from excise ...

Bench

Applied Acts & Sections

No Acts & Articles mentioned in this case

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 18

PETITIONER:

APHALI PHARMACEUTICALS LTD.

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

STATE OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS.

DATE OF JUDGMENT19/09/1989

BENCH:

SAIKIA, K.N. (J)

BENCH:

SAIKIA, K.N. (J)

OZA, G.L. (J)

CITATION:

1989 AIR 2227 1989 SCR Supl. (1) 129

1989 SCC (4) 378 JT 1989 (3) 720

1989 SCALE (2)617

ACT:

Medicinal and Toilet Preparations (Excise Duties) Act

1955-Amendment Act 19 of 1961--Finance Act 1962--Section 18

thereof-Levy of excise duty on the product "Ashvagandharist"

manufactured by the appellant--Whether permissible under the

schedule to the Act as amended--Effect and Interpretation of

Explanation I added to the Schedule of the Act by Finance

Act 1962--Circular dated May 31, 1962 issued by the Govern-

ment of Maharashtra----Whether in conformity with the provi-

sions of the Act and Explanation I of the Schedule.

Medicinal and Toilet Preparation (Excise Duties) Rules

1956-Rules 64 to 66 whether consistent with the schedule and

the circular dated 31.5.1962.

HEADNOTE:

The appellant is a company having its registered office

at Ahmednagar in Maharashtra. It carries on business as

manufacturers of Ayurvedic preparations including "Asvas"

and "Aristhas". At the material time the appellant was

manufacturing and selling an Ayurvedic product, "Ashvagand-

harist" which is a medicinal preparation containing self-

generated alcohol but not capable of being consumed as

ordinary alcoholic beverages.

Medicinal and Toilet Preparations (Excise Duties) Act

1955 came into force on 1.4.1957. The schedule to the said

Act contained two items specifying "medicinal and toilet

preparations containing alcohol" which are prepared by

distillation or to which alcohol has been added and which

are capable of being consumed as ordinary "alcoholic bever-

age" and "medicinal and toilet preparations not otherwise

specified containing alcohol" as the commodities excisable

under the provisions of the Act. The said "Ashvagandharist"

was treated and accepted by the Excise Authorities as being

exempt from the payment of excise duty upon the basis and

footing that the same was an Ayurvedic preparation contain-

ing self-generated alcohol which was not capable of being

consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverage and which fell under

item 2(i) of the schedule in respect of which, the rate of

excise duty prescribed in the schedule was "Nil".

130

The Act was amended by Amendment Act 19 of 1961 whereby

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 18

concept of "patent and proprietary" medicine was introduced

in the schedule. The Amendment Act, by an Explanation intro-

duced in the schedule the definition of "patent and proprie-

tary" medicine contained in the Drugs Act 1940. Despite the

said amendment in the schedule the appellants' product

continued to be treated as exempt from the liability to pay

excise duty on the ground that it was covered under item

2(i) of the schedule which item was re-numbered as item 3(i)

of the schedule. Thereafter by section 18 of the Finance Act

1962, the Act was further amended by substitution of Expla-

nation I to the schedule of the Act. By the said explana-

tion, a "patent and proprietary" medicine was defined as a

medicinal preparation of the description and the type speci-

fied in the Explanation. The said Explanation was given

retrospective effect from April 23, 1962. In pursuance of

the said Explanation I brought by the Finance Act, Director

of Prohibition and Central Excise, Govt. of Maharashtra,

Bombay issued a circular dated May 31, 1962, which inter

alia directed that the medicinal preparations containing

self-generated alcohol but not capable of being consumed as

alcoholic beverage were to be treated as products falling

under Item No. I and not Item 3 of the schedule. As a result

of that circular, the Respondents levied excise duty on the

appellants' product amounting to Rs.2, 18,282.16p. and

realized the same from the appellant. The appellant paid the

amount "under protest".

With a view to recover the aforesaid amount, which

according to the appellant, was illegally recovered by the

Respondents, the appellant filed a suit, being special suit

No. 23 of 1965 in the Court of Civil Judge Sr. Division,

Ahmednagar.

The Civil Judge by his order dated 27.3.69 decreed the

appellantplaintiff's suit with interest at 6% per annum from

the date of the suit till realisation.

The Respondents appealed to the High Court against the

Order of the Civil Judge and the High Court allowed the

appeal, reversed the Judgment and decree passed by the Civil

Judge and dismissed the appellant's suit. Hence this appeal

by the plaintiff-appellant by special leave.

Allowing the appeal, this Court,

HELD: From Explanation I of the Schedule of the Act as

substituted by Act 5 of 1964 it is clear that patent or

proprietary medicine

131

means any medicinal preparation which is not specified in a

monograph in a Pharmacopoeia, Formulary or other publica-

tions notified in this behalf by the Central Government in

the Official Gazette. [144C]

To be a patent medicine one would be required to have a

patent. A patented article means an article in respect of

which a patent is in force, [144D]

A patent medicine will, therefore, mean medicine in

respect of which a patent is in force. [144E]

Patent means a grant of some privilege property, or

authority, made by the Government or sovereign of a country

to one or more individuals. A proprietor is one who has the

legal right or exclusive title to anything. It is synonymous

with owner. A person entitled to a trade mark or a design

under the Acts for the registration or patenting of trade

mark or design is called a proprietor of the trade mark or

design. [144E-F]

A Schedule in an Act of Parliament is a mere question of

drafting. It is the legislative intent that is material. An

Explanation to the Schedule amounts to an Explanation in the

Act itself. [147F]

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 18

The Schedule may be used in construing provisions in the

body of the Act. It is as much an Act of the Legislature as

the Act itself and it must be read together with the Act for

all purposes of construction. Expressions in the Schedule

cannot control or prevail against express enactment and in

case of any inconsistency between the schedule and the

enactment, the enactment is to prevail and if any part of

the schedule cannot be made to correspond it must yield to

the Act. [147H; 148A-B]

An explanation is different in nature form a proviso,

for a proviso excepts, excludes or restricts while an expla-

nation explains or clarifies. Such explanation or clarifica-

tion may be in respect of matters whose meaning is implicit

and not explicit in the main section itself. [149F]

Bihta Marketing Union v. Bank of Bihar, AIR 1967 SC 389:

[1967] 1 SCR 848; State of Bombay v. United Motors, AIR 1953

SC 252: [1953] SCR 1069; Collector of Customs v. G. Dass &

Co., AIR 1966 SC 1577; Burmah Shell Oil Ltd. v. Commercial

Tax Officer, AIR 1961 SC 315: [1961] 1 SCR 902; Dattatraya

Govind Mahajan v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1977 SC 915

(928): [1977] 2 SCR 790 and Hiralal

132

Ratanlal v. State of U. P., [1973] 1 SCC 216.

Ex praecedentibus et consequentibus optima fit interpre-

tatio. The best interpretation is made from the context.

Injustum est nisi tota lege inspecta, de una aliqua ejus

particula proposita judicare Vel respondere. It is unjust to

decide or respond as to any particular part of a law without

examining the whole of the law. Interpretare et concordare

leges ligibus, est optimus interpretendi modus. To interpret

and in such a way as to harmonize laws with laws, is the

best mode of interpretation. [151G-H]

Jura eodem modo distituentur quo constitutuntur. Laws

are abrogated by the same means (authority) by which they

are made. [152A]

Every word in a Statute is to be given a meaning. A

construction which would leave without effect any part of

the language of a statute will normally be rejected. Every

clause of a statute is to be construed with reference to the

context and other clauses of the Act so as to make, as far

as possible, a consistent enactment of the whole statute.

[152B]

A specific provision to include Ayurvedic preparations

containing self-generated alcohol which are not capable of

being consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverages was neces-

sary. That having not been done by the Explanation itself,

it was not permissible to include it by the Circular. The

Explanation I could not have been in conflict with the

provisions of the Act and the Circular could not have been

in conflict with the Explanation, the Schedule, the Rules

and the Act. [152E-F]

The Court set aside the order of the High Court and

restored that of the Civil Judge decreeing the suit. [152G]

Inland Revenue Commissioners v. Gittus, [1920] I KB 563;

Baidyanath Ayurved Bhawan Pvt. Ltd. v. The Excise Commis-

sioner, U.P., [1971] 2 SCR 590; Mohanlal Maganlal Bhavsar v.

Union of India, [1986] 1 SCC 122; Commissioner of Sales Tax

v. The Modi Sugar Mills Ltd., [1961] 2 SCR 189 and Cape

Brandy Syndicate v. Commissioners of Inland Revenue, [1921]

1 KB 64, referred to.

JUDGMENT:

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 1845 (N)

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 18

of 1974.

From the Judgment and Decree dated 6/7.3.1974 of the

Bombay High Court in First Appeal No. 586 of 1969.

133

S.K. Dholakia and H.S. Parihar for the Appellant.

A.K. Ganguli, A.M. Khanwilkar, A. Subba Rao, C.V. Subba

Rao and A.S. Bhasme for the Respondents.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

SAIKIA, J- This plaintiff's appeal by special leave is

from the Appellate Judgment and Decree of the High Court of

Judicature at Bombay reversing those of the trial court and

dismissing plaintiff's special suit.

The appellant is a Limited Company registered under the

Companies Act having its registered office situate at Ahmed-

nagar within the State of Maharashtra. The appellant carries

on business, inter alia, as manufacturers of Ayurvedic

preparations including "Asavas", "Aristhas". At all times

material to this appeal, the appellant was manufacturing and

selling an Ayurvedic product called "Ashvagandhaarist" which

is a medicinal preparation containing self-generated alcohol

but not capable of being consumed as ordinary alcoholic

beverage.

Under the provisions of the Medicinal and Toilet Prepara-

tions . (Excise Duties) Act, 1955, hereinafter referred to

as "the Act", which came into force on 1st April, 1957,

excise duties were levied on medicinal and toilet prepara-

tions specified in the Schedule to the Act, hereinafter

referred to as "the Schedule". The Act, as originally stood

in 1955, inter alia, contained two items in the Schedule

respectively specifying "medicinal and toilet preparations

containing alcohol which are prepared by distillation or to

which alcohol has been added and which are capable of being

consumed as ordinary "alcoholic beverage" and "medicinal and

toilet preparations not otherwise specified containing

alcohol", being the commodities excisable under the provi-

sions of the Act. The said "Ashvagandhaarist" was treated

and accepted by the Excise Authorities as being exempt from

the payment of any excise duty upon the basis and the foot-

ing that the same was an Ayurvedic preparation containing

self-generated alcohol which was not capable of being con-

sumed as ordinary alcoholic beverage, and which fell under

item 2(i) Of the Schedule in respect of which the rate of

excise duty postulated in the Schedule was "Nil".

The Act was amended by the Amendment Act 19 of 1961.

The amendment, inter alia, introduced the concept of "patent

and pro-

134

prietary medicine" in the Schedule. The amendment Act,

however, by an Explanation, introduced in the Schedule the

definition of the "patent and proprietary medicine" con-

tained in the Drugs Act, 1940. Even after the introduction

of the said amendment, the appellant's aforesaid product

continued to be treated as exempt from the liability to pay

any excise duty on the self-same ground, namely, that it was

covered under item 2(i) of the Schedule which item 2(i) was

renumbered as item 3(i) of the Schedule as amended by the

Amendment Act of 1961.

By Section 18 of the Finance Act, 1962, the Act was

further amended by substitution of an Explanation No. 1 to

the Schedule of the Act. By virtue of and under the said

Explanation, a patent and proprietary medicine was defined

as a medicinal preparation of the description and the type

specified in the Explanation. The Explanation which was

brought in by the Finance Act was given retrospective effect

from April 23, 1962.

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 5 of 18

In purported pursuance of the said Explanation and/or

upon the basis thereof, a circular dated May 31, 1962 was

issued by the then Director of Prohibition and Central

Excise, Government of Maharashtra, Bombay which, inter alia,

directed that the medicinal preparations containing self-

generated alcohol but not capable of being consumed as

alcoholic beverage were to be treated as products falling

under item 1 and not item 3 of the Schedule. consequent

thereupon, the respondents levied and recovered from the

appellant diverse sums aggregating to Rs.2, 18,282.16 being

the alleged amount of the excise duty payable in respect of

the product "Ashvagandharist". The amounts were paid by the

appellant "under protest".

With a view to enforcing their rights in respect thereof

and/or recovering the said amount illegally recovered by the

respondents, on July 14, 1965, the appellant filed a suit,

being Special Suit No. 23 of 1965 in the Court of Civil

Judge, Senior Division, Ahmednagar.

On March 4, 1966, the respondent No. 4 filed its written

statement and similarly on the 4th April, 1966 the respond-

ent Nos. 1 to 3 filed written statements. In the written

statements, filed on behalf of the respondents it was, inter

alia, contended that the said product of the appellant was

"the unrestricted ayurvedic preparations" manufactured by

the plaintiff (appellant) labelled and marked by the

135

plaintiff (appellant) under their brand name and trade mark.

This, therefore, fell within the scope of patent or proprie-

tary medicine as given in Explanation 1 below the Schedule

annexed to the Act, as inserted from April 23, 1962 by

Finance Act (No. 2) 1962.

By his Judgment and Decree dated March 27, 1969, the

learned Civil Judge was pleased to decree the appellant's

suit for Rs.2,22,582.07 together with future interest at 6

per cent per annum from the date of the suit till realisa-

tion.

Aggrieved by the Judgment and Order dated March 27,

1969, the respondents (being the defendants therein) pre-

ferred an appeal to the High Court of Judicature at Bombay,

which was registered as First Appeal No. 586 of 1969. The

said appeal was heard by the High Court alongwith other

appeals being First Appeals Nos. 136 of 1968 and 93 of 1970

as also suits being Suit Nos. 230 of 1965 and 319 of 1965.

The appeals and the suits were heard together having regard

to the common questions of law involved therein. By its

judgment and decree the High Court was pleased to allow the

said first appeal of the respondents, reversing the judgment

and decree of the Trial Court and to dismiss the appellant's

special suit. Hence this appeal by special leave.

Mr. S.K. Dholakia, the learned counsel for the appellant

submits, inter alia, that the findings of the High Court are

repugnant to the relevant provisions of the Act and/or the

rules framed thereunder and/or the scheme, intendments and

purposes thereof. It is contended that the appellant's

product "Ashvagandhaarist" fell squarely within item 3(i) of

the Schedule and as such wholly exempt from the payment of

excise duty; that in view of the admitted position that

until 1962 "Ashvagandhaarist" was exempt from the payment of

excise duty as being a commodity falling under item No. 2(i)

of the Schedule, simply by reason of the Explanation which

was introduced in the Act by the Finance Act of 1962, as the

explanation could never be considered to be or, in any

event, in the scheme of the provision of the Act, was not a

substantive provision of the Act and the explanation was not

intended to and it did not seek to disturb the enumeration

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 6 of 18

of the categories or the respective fields assigned to the

various items of the schedule in existence prior thereto. It

is submitted that item 3 of the amended Schedule was a

specific item and enumerated categories of Ayurvedic medici-

nal preparations covered thereby and that being so, all

commodities answering description set out therein fell

within the

136

ambit thereof and was excluded from the purview of the other

items contained in the said schedule and that the express

language of item 3(i), namely, of "Ayurvedic preparations

containing self-generated alcohol which were not capable of

being consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverages" were exempt-

ed and that the appellant's product "Ashvagandhaarist" was

admittedly and obviously an Ayurvedic preparation containing

self-generated alcohol which was not capable of being con-

sumed as ordinary alcoholic beverage and as such it could

not be made excisable on the ground that it fell within any

other item of the schedule but it constituted residuary

clause of the schedule in so far as the medicinal and toilet

preparations containing alcohol were concerned. Counsel

further submits that the expression "not otherwise speci-

fied" occurring in item 3 of the schedule did not restrict

the scope of the enumerated categories under item 3 but was

merely a marginal note showing that the said item 3 was

residuary item and comprised of three sub-groups of commodi-

ties specified therein; and that item No. 1 was not a speci-

fied item. Mr. Dholakia further submits that the interpreta-

tion that "ashvagandhaarist" fell within item No. 1 rendered

the provisions of item No. 3 wholly nugatory inasmuch as if

an Ayurvedic preparation containing self-generated alcohol

but incapable of being used as ordinary alcoholic beverage,

is treated as failing under item 1 there would be no

Ayurvedic medicine which would factually fail under item 3

of the schedule and that the Explanation newly introduced by

the Finance Act, 1962 could not add to, amend or alter or

vary the classification of the goods existing prior thereto

as covered by the various items of the said schedule; nor

could it otherwise nullify or add to, amend or alter or vary

the substantive provisions of the schedule and it could not

be considered to be a substantive provision of the Act nor

could it be allowed to abrogate the substantive provisions

of the Act. In other words, the submission is that in view

of the fact that the product of the appellant was exempt

from payment of duty because the duty against item No. 3(i)

in the amended Schedule of 1961 was mentioned to be 'nil'

the High Court ought to have held that the said legal and

factual position could not be transformed to the detriment

of the appellant by shifting the said commodity from the

field covered by item 3(i) to that covered by item 1 of the

Act merely on the basis of the Explanation which was intro-

duced by the Finance Act of 1962. Counsel argues that this

was more so because "ashvagandhaarist" was not a name within

the contemplation of the explanation but was merely a de-

scriptive appellation of the medicine manufactured and sold

by the appellant and it being a standard preparation accord-

ing to the Ayurvedic system could be manufactured by any one

conversant with the said system, and it did

137

not have a brand name in the hands of the appellant and the

High Court's interpretation that a mere description is a

name is inconsistent with the scheme of the definition of

"patent and proprietary medicines" in the Explanation. This

was the reason, it is argued, why Asavas and Aristhas were

expressly made non-dutiable after 25.9.6,4. by subsequent

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 7 of 18

amendment by the Government.

Mr. A.K. Ganguli, learned counsel appearing for the

respondents, demurring, submits that there can be no doubt

that "Asavas" and "Aristhas" fall under item 1 of the sched-

ule to the Act as substituted by Finance Act 2 of 1962 and

hence taxable at 10% ad valorem; and those being Ayurvedic

preparations are specified preparations and they could never

fail under item 3 or any part thereof which deals with

medicinal preparations not otherwise specified containing

alcohol. Item 1, Mr. Ganguli submits, specifically describes

that medicinal and toilet preparation which has alcoholic

contents and which alcohol comes to be present in those

medicines by use of one of the two methods described in that

item. First of such methods contemplates alcohol contents in

the medicine which is prepared by distillation and the

second method is addition of alcohol to the medicine. The

medicinal preparation which is prepared by distillation and

which contains alcohol and other medicinal preparations to

which alcohol is added fall in category I and such medicines

would cover medicinal preparations belonging either to

Allopathic or Ayurvedic system or I any other system of

medicines. For every system of medicines, counsel argues,

item No. 1 is not general item but it is a specific item in

the sense it covers only those medicines which are prepared

by distillation and contain alcohol and others to which

alcohol has been added. According to counsel, such medicines

belonging to any system whether indigenous or foreign are

covered by item 1 and would be taxable as per that item and

the disputed goods are undoubtedly medicinal preparations

and they are also patent and proprietary medicines in view

of the Explanation 1 and these Ayurvedic preparations are

medicinal preparations being patent or proprietary medicines

containing alcohol which are not capable of being consumed

as alcoholic beverages and as such they squarely fall under

item 1 of the Schedule, and the main Act and the Explanation

is a self-contained provision which eliminates the reference

either to Drugs Act or to the Rules made under the Act; and

one has to read only the provision of the Schedule as a

whole including the Explanation, and their meaning being

simple and plain, they must be given their full effect.

138

To appreciate the rival contentions we can appropriately

refer to the provisions and the Schedule of the Act and the

legislative changes thereof. The Act was meant to provide

for the levy and collection of duty of excise on medicinal

and toilet preparations containing alcohol, opium, Indian

hemp or other narcotic drug or narcotic. The statement of

objects and reasons as notified in Gazette of India of

16.9.1954, Part II, S. 2, Ext., page 596 said that by virtue

of entry 40 in List II in the Seventh Schedule to the Gov-

ernment of India Act, 1935, medicinal and toilet prepara-

tions containing alcohol, etc., were subjected to Provincial

excise duties. In order to secure uniformity the entry

relating to excise duty on medicinal and toilet preparations

containing alcohol, etc. were transferred under the Consti-

tution from the State list to the Union List. The Act was

intended to implement this provision in the Constitution and

proposed uniform rates of excise duty and a uniform proce-

dure for the collection thereof. The Act came in force on

1.4.57.

The Act in Section 2(a) defined "alcohol" to mean "ethyl

alcohol of any strength and purity having the chemical

composition C2H5OH"; and it defined "medicinal preparation"

in Section 2(g) to include "all drugs which are a remedy or

prescription prepared for internal or external use of human

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 8 of 18

beings or animals and all substances intended to be used for

or in the treatment, mitigation or prevention of disease in

human beings or animals". It did not define "drug". The

Drugs Act, 1940, as it was substituted by the Drugs (Amend-

ment) Act, 1955 (16.4.55) had defined "drug" in Section 2(b)

to include "(i) all medicines for internal or external use

of human beings or animals and all substances intended to be

used for or in the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or

prevention of disease in human beings or animals other than

medicines and substances exclusively used or prepared for

use in accordance with the Ayurvedic or Unani systems of

medicine; and (ii) such substances (other than food) intend-

ed to affect the structure or any function of the human body

or intended to be used for the destruction of vermins or

insects which cause disease in human beings or animals, as

may be specified from time to time by the Central Government

by notification in the Official Gazette."

(Emphasis supplied)

Section 3(i) of the Act provides that "there shall be

levied duties of excise, at the rates specified in the

Schedule, on all dutiable goods manufactured in India."

The original Schedule to the Act in 1955 read:

139

THE SCHEDULE

(See section 3)

Item Description of dutiable Rate of

No. goods. duty.

1. Medicinal and toilet preparations, Rupees seven-

containing alcohol, which are prepared and annas eig-

which are prepared by distilation or ht per gallon

to which alcohol has been added, and of strength

which are capable of being consumed as of London

ordinary alcoholic beverages. proof spirit.

2. Medicinal and toilet preparations not

otherwise specified containing alcohol

(i) Ayurvedic preparations containing Nil

self-generated alcohol, which are

not capable of being consumed as

ordinary alcoholic beverages.

(ii) Ayurvedic preparations containing Rupees three

self-generated alcohol, which are per gallon.

capable of being consumed as

ordinary alcoholic beverages.

(iii) All others. Rupees five

per

gallon of the

strength of

London proof

spirit

3. Medical and toilet preparations, Nil

not containing alcohol, but containing

opium, Indian hemp, or other

narcotic drug or narcotic.

It would thus be clear that medicinal and toilet prepara-

tions were classified into those which were capable of being

consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverages and those which

were not capable of being consumed as ordinary alcoholic

beverages. Again, medicinal and toilet preparations contain-

ing alcohol prepared by distillation or adding alcohol is

differentiated from medicinal and toilet preparations 'not

otherwise specified containing alcohol'. Further, under this

'not

140

otherwise specified' category Ayurvedic preparations have

been classified into three groups, namely, Ayurvedic prepa-

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 9 of 18

rations containing self-generated alcohol not capable of

being consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverages, those capa-

ble of being consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverages; and

others. These three divisions were not drugs as defined in

Drugs Act then. The first category of Ayurvedic preparations

had not been subjected to duty while the other two catego-

ries had been.

Admittedly, under the above Schedule the product of the

appellant 'ashvagandhaarist' was not dutiable which meant

that it was included in item 2(i). It would also be clear

that 'Ayurvedic preparations containing self-generated

alcohol which were capable of being consumed as ordinary

alcoholic beverages' were dutiable at the rate of Rupees 3

per gallon and the third category of others was also dutia-

ble at the rate of Rupees 5 per gallon on the strength of

London proof spirit. Alcohol and self-generated alcohol were

treated differently.

The Schedule was amended by the Amending Act No. 19 of

1961 and the amended Schedule stood as follows:

Item No. Description of dutiable goods Rate of

duty

1. Medicinal preparations, being patent Ten per cent

or proprietary medicines, contain- ad valorem.

ing alcohol and which are not

capable of being consumed as

ordinary alcoholic beverages.

2. Medicinal preparations, containing Rupees three

alcohol, which are and eight

prepared by distillation or to which five naye

alcohol has been added, paise per

and which are capable of being litre of

consumed as ordinary alcoholic the streng-

beverages. th of Londo-

n proof spi-

rit.

3. Medicinal preparations not otherwise

specified containing alcohol-

(i) Ayurvedic preparations containing Nil

self'generated alcohol which are

not capable of being consumed as

ordinary alcoholic beverages.

141

(ii) Ayurvedic preparations, contain- Thirty eight

ing self-generated alcohol, which naye paise per

are capable of being consumed as litre.

ordinary alcoholic beverages.

(iii) All others. Rupee one and

ten naye paise

per litre of

the strength

of London proof

spirit.

Explanation I: "Patent or proprietary medicines" has the

same meaning as in clause (h) of Section 3 of the Drugs Act,

1940 (23 of 1940).

The statement of objects and reasons of the Amendment Bill,

as published in Gazette of India, 8.3.1961, Pt. II, S. 2,

Ext., page 106, said:

"Consequent on the decision to adopt metric

units from the 1st April, 1961, in the sale of

alcohol and collection of duty thereon, it is

proposed to provide for the levy and collec-

tion of excise duty on medicinal and toilet

preparations in terms of metric units.

............................................

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 10 of 18

Under existing item 2(ii) of the

Schedule to the Act, Ayurvedic preparations

containing self-generated alcohol which are

capable of being consumed as ordinary alcohol-

ic beverages are subjected to duty at the rate

of Rs.3 per gallon. However, by virtue of the

provision contained in section 19(2)(xix) of

the Act, read with Rule 8 of the Medicinal and

Toilet Preparations (Excise Duties) Rules

1956, the rate of duty with respect to such

preparations has been reduced to Rs. 1.75 per

gallon with effect from the 10th September,

1960, and it is this reduced rate that is,

proposed to be expressed in terms of metric

units in the Bill."

It would thus be clear that the main purpose was the

levy and collection of excise duty on medicinal and toilet

preparations in terms of metric unit. while there was refer-

ence to them existing item 2(ii) of the Schedule of the Act,

namely, Ayurvedic preparations containing

142

self-generated alcohol which were capable of being consumed

as ordinary alcoholic beverages the duty whereof was reduced

to Rs. 1.75 per gallon from Rs.3 per gallon, there was no

mention that item No. 2(i) of the Schedule, namely, Ayurved-

ic preparations containing self-generated alcohol which were

not capable of being consumed as ordinary alcoholic bever-

ages was subjected to tax. The statement of object and

reasons was silent about item No. 2(i).

In the amended Schedule we find that item 1 for the

first time mentioned medicinal preparations being patent or

proprietary medicines, containing alcohol and which are not

capable of being consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverages

and the earlier item No. 1 has been re-numbered as item No.

2 and the earlier item No. 2(i), (ii) and (iii) remained as

they were as 3(i), 3(ii) and 3(iii). As regards levy of duty

item 2(i) of the old Schedule was kept duty free in item

3(i) of the Schedule. Thus, there has been no fresh charging

of duty on what was 2(i) and is now 3(i) under which catego-

ry the appellant's product 'ashvagandhaarist' was exempted

from duty before the amendment of the Schedule. There is,

therefore, no doubt that item 1 & 2(i) remained mutually

exclusive or in other words, they would not be overlapping.

Item 1 in the amended Schedule deals with medicinal prepara-

tions being patent or proprietary medicines and not medici-

nal preparations 'not otherwise specified.'

The Explanation I says that patent or proprietary medi-

cines has the same meaning as in clause (h) of Section 3 of

the Drugs Act, 1940. The High Court has found that re-num-

bered definition 3(h) was earlier 3(d) and read as follows:

"3(d) 'Patent or proprietary medicine' means a

drug which is a remedy or prescription pre-

pared for internal or external use of human

beings or animals, and which is not for the

time being recognised by the Permanent Commis-

sion on Biological Standardisation of the

World Health Organisation or in the latest

edition of the British Pharmacopoeia or the

British Pharmaceutical Codex or any other

Pharmacopoeia authorised in this behalf by the

Central Government after consultation with the

Board."

Thus, patent or proprietary medicines meant a drug which was

defined in the Drugs Act and not in the Act. The High Court

rightly held that Ayurvedic medicine was not a drug at all.

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 11 of 18

The definition of drug expressly excluded them. So the

definition of patent or proprietary medicine

143

was exclusive of Ayurvedic medicinal preparations, those

being excluded from the definition of drug. The definition

of patent and proprietary medicines till then did not apply

to Ayurvedic preparations. This position continued indeed

till the amendment of Drugs Act by the Drugs and Cosmetics

(Amendment) Act, 1964. Several amendments were effected by

that Amendment Act of 1964. Section 33A and Chapter IV A

were inserted. Section 33A said that Chapter IV was not to

apply to Ayurvedic (including Siddha) or Unani drugs. "Save

as otherwise provided in this Act, nothing contained in this

Chapter shall apply to Ayurvedic (including Siddha) or Unani

drugs". Chapter IVA made.provisions relating to Ayurvedic

(including Siddha) and Unani drugs. This shows that prior to

this amendment of 1964 Ayurvedic preparations were expressly

not drugs under the Drugs Act.

The Drugs and Cosmetics Act in the amendment First

Schedule after the amendment Act of 1964 included Ayurvedic

(including Siddha) and Unani system drugs prepared under

Section 3(a) which contains the definition: "Ayurvedic

(including Siddha) or Unani drugs includes all medicines

intended for internal or external use of human beings or

animals and all substances intended to be used for or in the

diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of disease in

human beings and animals, mentioned and process and manufac-

ture exclusively in accordance with the formula prescribed

in the authoritative book on Ayurvedic (Siddha) Unani system

of medicines specified in the first schedule." This defini-

tion was also inserted by Drugs and Cosmetics (Amendment)

Act, 1964 (13 of 1964) Section 2(a)(i) with effect from

15.9.1964.

The same exclusion remained in the related Central Acts.

For example, the Drugs Control Act, 1950 (Act 26 of 1950)

replaced the Drugs Control Ordinance, 1949 (6 of 1949) which

was promulgated on 3.10. 1949 in order to ensure that cer-

tain essential imported drugs and medicines were sold in the

reasonable price in the Chief Commissioner's provinces.

Similar ordinances were issued by all the provinces. The

necessity for continuing price control of these essential

drugs continued. That was an Act to provide for the control

of sale, supply and distribution of drugs. Drug meant any

drug as defined in clause (b) of Section 3 of Drugs Act,

1940, in respect of which a declaration had been made under

Section 3 which defined drug. It may be noted that Pharmaco-

poeia authorised for the purpose of Section 3(h) of the

Drugs Act, 1940, were: The Indian Pharmacopoeia, the Pharma-

copoeia of the United States, the National formulary of the

United States, the International Pharmacopoeia and the State

Pharmacopoeia

144

of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, vide S.O. 701

Gazette of India, 1961, Pt. II, S. 3(ii), p. 725. There was

thus no Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia prescribed for the purpose

of that Act. Pharmacopoeia is a book containing the list of

drugs with directions for use. The fact that no Ayurvedic

Pharmacopoeia had been notified at the relevant time was

because Ayurvedic preparations were not drugs for the pur-

pose of Drugs Act and, for that matter, of Medicinal and

Toilet Preparations (Excise Duties) Act, at the relevant

time. It could be for this reason that in the original

Schedule the expression medicinal and toilet preparations

'not otherwise specified' was used and Ayurvedic prepara-

tions of different categories were put under item 2. In the

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 12 of 18

Schedule as amended by the 1962 Act, this expression contin-

ued in item 3, The same definition of 'drug' also continued

in the Drugs Act.

From the Explanation I of the Schedule of the Act as

substituted by Act 5 of 1964 also it is clear that patent or

proprietary medicine means any medicinal preparation which

is not specified in a monograph in a Pharmacopoeia, Formu-

lary or other publications notified in this behalf by the

Central Government in the Official Gazette.

To be a patent medicine one would be required to have a

patent. A patented article means an article in respect of

which a patent is in force. "Patent" means a patent granted

under the Indian Patent and Designs Act, 1911, and now the

Patent Act, 1970. A patent medicine will, therefore, mean

medicine in respect of which a patent is in force. "Proprie-

tary" means of a proprietor, that is, holding proprietary

rights. Patent means a grant of some privilege, property, or

authority, made by the Government or sovereign of a country

to one or more individuals. A proprietor is one who has the

legal right or exclusive title to anything. It is synonymous

with owner. A person entitled to a trade mark or a design

under the acts for the registration or patenting of trade

mark or design is called a proprietor of the trade mark or

design. Under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958,

"trade mark" means:

"(i) in relation to Chapter X (other than

section 81), a registered trade mark or a mark

used in relation to goods for the purpose of

indicating or so as to indicate a connection

in the course of trade between the goods and

some person having the right as proprietor to

use the mark; and

(ii) in relation to the other provisions of

this Act, a mark used or proposed to be used

in relation to goods for the

145

purpose of indicating or so as to indicate a

connection in the course of trade between the

goods and some person having the right, either

as proprietor or as registered user, to use

the mark whether with or without any indica-

tion of the identity of that person, and

includes a certification trade mark

registered as such under the provisions of

Chap. VIII."

As defined in s. 2(a), registered proprietor in relation to

a trade-mark means a person for a time being entered in the

register as proprietor of the trade-mark. A registered

trade-mark means a trade-mark which is actually on the

register.

By s. 18 of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 1962, the Schedule

to the Act was further amended substituting the Explanation

1 by the following:

"Explanation 1: "Patent or proprietary medi-

cines" means any medicinal preparation which

bears either on itself or on its container or

both a name which is not specified in a mono-

graph in a Pharmacopoeia, Formulary or other

Publications notified in this behalf by the

Central Government in the Official Gazette, or

which is a brand name, that is a name or a

registered trade mark under the Trade and

Merchandise Mark Act, 1958 (43 of 1958), or

any other mark such as a symbol, monogram,

label, signature or invented words or any

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 13 of 18

writing which is used m relation to that

medicinal preparation for the purpose of

indicating or so as to indicate a connection

in the course of trade between as preparation

and some person having the right either as

proprietor or otherwise to use the name or

mark with or without any indication of the

identity of that person."

This amendment of the Explanation came into force in June,

1962 with retrospective effect from 23rd April, 1962.

The Director of Prohibition and Excise, for Maharashtra

State, Bombay, thereafter issued the circular dated 31.5.

1962 (Ext. 44). It said that the patent or proprietary

medicines as defined in clause (d) of s. 3 of the Drugs Act

of 1940 (23 of 1940) and falling under items No. 1 and No. 4

of the Act as substituted by the Amendment Act, 1961 were,

prior to 23rd April, 1962, subject to levy of duty at 10 per

cent ad

146

valorem by virtue of the Explanation I below the Schedule to

the Act which has now been deleted from 23rd April, 1962.

According to new definition of 'Patent and Proprietary

Medicines' as given in the new Explanation as amended by

Finance (No. 2) Act, 1962 medicinal preparations containing

alcohol, opium, Indian hemp or other narcotic drugs or

narcotic falling under item 3(i), 3(iii) and 3(v) of the

said Schedule, were with effect from 23rd April, 1962 liable

to duty not under the said items but under item No. 1 or

item No. 4 of the said Schedule at 10 per cent ad valorem,

if such preparations are "patent or proprietary medicines"

as defined in the Explanation. Excise duty on all 'patent or

proprietary medicinal preparations' (Alopathic, Ayurvedic,

Unani and Homoeopathic preparations) containing alcohol,

opium, Indian hemp or other narcotic drug or narcotic, which

fall within the purview of the new definition of 'patent or

proprietary medicines' given in the Explanation, should

therefore, be recovered at the rate of 10 per cent ad valo-

rem from the holders of the licences granted under the said

Act and the rules thereunder in accordance with the instruc-

tions contained in their Circular No. DQ 64-31/61 dated 22nd

July, 1961. A note received from the Government of India,

explaining the scope of the new definition of 'patent or

proprietary medicines' was also enclosed along with the

circular.

It is in evidence in the instant case that two bottles

containing Asavas were produced in the Court as Exhibit 42/1

and Exhibit 42/2. Both the bottles contained the same kind

of Asavas. The ingredients of the two were the same and the

preparation of the two was also the same. When the Asavas

were sold during the period beginning from June, 1962 to

February, 1964, no excise duty was levied because on the

label there was no trade mark of patent and proprietary

right printed. If the Asavas were sold in the bottle having

a label with no trade mark as at Exhibit 42/1, no duty was

recovered from the plaintiff. These Asavas were supplied to

Employees' State Insurance as per their tender without the

trade mark on the label to see that the plaintiffcompany

were not taxed the excise duty which would have been charged

had they put the patent mark on the label. But in order to

fight for blemish of cheating, the plaintiff thought it

necessary to have the trade mark on such bottles without any

difference. As soon as the goods were sought to be sold in

the above manner the excise duty was levied and was sought

to be recovered from the plaintiff's fund. No excise duty

was recovered after February, 1964 even though Asavas were

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 14 of 18

sold with their trade mark. It is also in evidence that

there were two sub-groups in the group of Asavas and Aris-

thas known as 'restricted' and 'unrestricted'. Restricted

means preparations which

147

could be used as alcoholic beverages. In this case the

period from 26.7.62 to 29.2.64 is alone material inasmuch as

by the Finance Act of 1964 with reference to item No. 1, the

Ayurvedic and Unani medicines containing self-generated

alcohol and which were not capable of being consumed as

ordinary alcoholic beverages were exempted from the levy of

excise duty. In other words, the position prior to Finance

Act of 1962 was continued and thereafter the medicinal

preparations, namely, Asavas and Aristhas ceased to be taxed

from 1964.

It would be noted that the Explanation itself did not

specifically mention "Allopathic, Ayurvedic, Unani and

Homoeopathic preparations" as was done in the Director's

Circular. On a comparison of the earlier Explanation and the

substituted Explanation one would notice that earlier

"patent and proprietary medicines" meant a drug. In the

substituted Explanation it means any medicinal preparation.

However, it can not be lost sight of that the words "medici-

nal preparation" as continued to be defined in s. 2(g) of

the Act "includes all drugs which are a remedy or prescrip-

tion prepared for internal or external use of human beings

or animals and all substances intended to be used for or in

treatment, mitigation or prevention of diseases in human

beings or animals." We have already noticed that the Drugs

Act continued to exclude Ayurvedic preparations till its

amendment in 1964. It has been stated that even after amend-

ment of the Schedule after 1961 amendment the appellant's

product was exempted from duty, till the Director's Circular

disturbed the position.

This brings us to the question of interpretation of the

Act and the Schedule with the Explanation. in view of the

submission that the Explanation could not have rendered item

3(i) of the Schedule redundant. Was there any change of

intention of the Legislature in this regard?

A Schedule in an Act of Parliament is a mere question of

drafting. It is the legislative intent that is material. An

Explanation to the Schedule amounts to an Explanation in the

Act itself. As we read in Halsbury's Laws of England, Third

Edition, Vol. 36, para 551: "To simplify the presentation of

statutes, it is the practice for their subject matter to be

divided, where appropriate, between sections and schedules,

the former setting out matters of principle, and introducing

the latter, and the latter containing all matters of detail.

This is purely a matter of arrangement, and a schedule is as

much a part of the statute, and as much an enactment, as is

the section by which it is introduced." The schedule may be

used in construing provisions in the

148

body of the Act. It is as much an act of Legislature as the

Act itself and it must be read together with the Act for all

purposes of construction. Expressions in the Schedule cannot

control or prevail against the express enactment and in case

of any inconsistency between the schedule and the enactment

the enactment is to prevail and if any part of the schedule

cannot be made to correspond it must yield to the Act. Lord

Sterndale, in Inland Revenue Commissioners v. Gittus, [1920]

1 K.B. 563 said:

"It seems to me there are two principles of

rules of interpretation which ought to be

applied to the combination of Act and Sched-

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 15 of 18

ule. If the Act says that the Schedule is to

be used for a certain purpose and the heading

of the part of the Schedule in question shows

that it is prima facie at any rate devoted to

that purpose, then you must read the Act and

the Schedule as though the Schedule were

operating for the purpose, and if you can

satisfy the language of the section without

extending it beyond that purpose you ought to

do it. But if in spite of that you find in the

language of the Schedule words and terms that

go clearly outside that purpose, then you must

give effect to them and you must not consider

them as limited by the heading of that part of

the Schedule or by the purpose mentioned in

the Act for which the Schedule is prima facie

to be used. You cannot refuse to give effect

to clear words simply because prima facie they

seem to be limited by the heading of the

Schedule and the definition of the purpose of

the Schedule contained in the Act."

The above observation was not disapproved in appeal

(1921) 2 A.C. 81. However, the basic principle is that in

case of a conflict between the body of the Act and the

Schedule, the former prevails. In the instant case we do not

find any such conflict.

An Explanation, as was found in Bihta Marketing Union

v. Bank of Bihar, AIR 1967 SC 389: (1967) 1 SCR 848, may

only explain and may not expand or add to the scope of the

original section. In State of Bombay v. United Motors, AIR

1953 SC 252: (1953) SCR 1069,it was found that an Explana-

tion could introduce, a finction or settle a matter of

controversy. Explanation may not be made to operate as

"exception" or "proviso". The construction of an Explana-

tion, as was held in Collector of Customs v. G. Dass & Co.,

AIR 1966 SC 1577, must depend upon its terms and no theory

of its purpose can be entertained

149

unless it is to be inferred from the language used. It was

said in Burmah Shell Oil Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, AIR

1961 SC 3 15: (1961) 1 SCR 902, that the explanation was

meant to explain the Article and must be interpreted accord-

ing to its own tenor and it was an error to explain the

Explanation with the aid of the Article to which it was

annexed. We have to remember what was held in Dattatraya

Govind Mahajan v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1977 SC 915

(928): (1977) 2 SCR 790, that mere description of a certain

provision, such as "Explanation" is not decisive of its true

meaning. It is true that the orthodox function of an expla-

nation is to explain the meaning and effect of the main

provision to which it is an explanation and to clear up any

doubt or ambiguity in it, but ultimately it is the intention

of the legislature which is paramount and mere use of a

label cannot control or deflect such intention. State of

Bombay v. United Motors, (supra) laid down that the inter-

pretation must obviously depend upon the words used therein,

but this must be borne in mind that when the provision is

capable of two interpretations, that should be adopted which

fits the description. An explanation is different in nature

from a proviso for a proviso excepts, excludes or restricts

while an explanation explains or clarifies. Such explanation

or clarification may be in respect of matters whose meaning

is implicit and not explicit in the main section itself. In

Hiralal Ratanlal v. State of U.P., [1973] 1 SCC 216 (225),

it was ruled that if on a true reading of an Explanation it

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 16 of 18

appears that it has widened the scope of the main section,

effect be given to legislative intent notwithstanding the

fact that the Legislature named that provision as an Expla-

nation. In all these matters courts have to find out the

true intention of the Legislature. In D.G. Mahajan v. State

of Maharashtra, (supra) xx this Court said that legislature

has different ways of expressing itself and in the last

analysis the words used alone are repository of legislative

intent and that if necessary an Explanation must be con-

strued according to its plain language and 'not on any a

priori consideration'.

Applying the above principles we do not find any differ-

ence between the Schedule and the Explanation I; the latter

has not amended the Schedule by either deleting item 3(i) or

by adding or including Ayurvedic preparations in item 1. No

change of legislative intent is indicated.

In the Medicinal and Toilet Preparations (Excise Duties)

Rules, 1956 Section C Medicinal and Toilet preparations,

Allopathic preparations, Homoeopathic preparations and

Ayurvedic preparations are dealt with separately. So far as

Ayurvedic preparations are concerned,

150

Rule 64 dealing with types of preparations said: "Asavas and

Aristhas are the principal types of Ayurvedic preparations

in which alcoholic content is self-generated and not added

as such." Rule 65 on Pharmacopoeia for Ayurvedic prepara-

tions said: "Until a standard Ayurvedic pharmacopoeia has

been evolved by the Central Government, the pharmacopoeias

that are in vogue in the various States shall be recognised

as standard Ayurvedic pharmacopoeias." Rule 66 classified

the preparations containing self-generated alcohol for

purposes of levy of duty. It said: "No duty shall be levied

on Ayurvedic preparations containing self-generated alcohol

in which the alcohol content does not exceed 2 per cent.

Where the percentage of proof spirit is in excess of 2 per

cent, duty will be leviable under item 2(ii) or 2(i) of the

Schedule to Act the according as the preparations are capa-

ble of being consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverage or

not." Thus Ayurvedic preparations containing self-generated

alcohol which are not capable of being used as alcoholic

beverages fall under original 2(i) and now 3(i).

The above Rules, which have not been shown to have been

amended clearly say that where the percentage of proof

spirit is in excess of 2% the preparation would be dutiable

under item 2 which became item No. 3 in the amended Sched-

ule. This Rule is consistent with the Schedule but is wholly

inconsistent with the Director's circular.

Mr. Ganguli relies on (1971) 2 SCR 590: (1971) 1 SCC 4

Baidyanath Ayurved Bhawan Pvt. Ltd. v. The Excise Commis-

sioner of U.P., The question there was whether medicinal

preparation containing tincture, spirit etc. was dutiable.

The tincture and spirit in their turn contained alcohol. It

was contended that alcohol was not directly added but was

component of the tincture or spirit. It was, however conced-

ed that the preparations were medicinal preparations and

that tincture was a component of that preparation and alco-

hol was a component of tincture. Therefore, this Court held

that it was difficult to see how it could be urged that the

preparation did not contain alcohol. All that the plain

language of the provision required was that the preparation

should contain alcohol. The question whether Ayurvedic

preparation was a drug to be included in the definition of

medicinal preparation was not involved. Whether self-gener-

ated alcohol was to be treated differently was also not

there.

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 17 of 18

In Mohanlal Maganlal Bhavsar v. Union of India. [1986] 1

SCC 122 it was held that before a medicinal preparation can

fall under Item

151

1 of the Schedule three conditions are required to be satis-

fied: (A) the preparation must be a patent or proprietary

medicine; (2) it must contain alcohol; and (3) it must not

be capable of being consumed as an ordinary alcoholic bever-

age. The fact that ointments and liniments were medicinal

preparations containing alcohol in semi-liquid form did not

make any difference. However it was not in dispute that the

articles were medicinal preparations for the purposes of the

Act and that they were patent and proprietary medicines. In

the instant case the question is whether Ayurvedic prepara-

tions, in view of the definition of medicinal preparations

in the Act, could be regarded as drugs and could be dutiable

under Item 3 and not Item 1. In Commissioner of Sales Tax v.

The Modi Sugar Mills Ltd., [1961] 2 SCR 189 it was held that

a taxing statute must be interpreted in the light of what is

clearly expressed therein and nothing can be implied nor can

provisions be imported into them so as to supply an assumed

deficiency. In Baidyanath Ayurved Bhawan (supra) this Court

quoted the observation of Rowlatt, J. in Cape Brandy Syndi-

cate v. Commissioners of Inland Revenue, [1921] 1 K.B. 64

that "in a taxing Act one has to look at what is clearly

said. There is no room for any intendment. There is no

equity about a tax. There is no presumption as to tax.

Nothing is to be read in, nothing is to be implied. One can

only look fairly at the language used." The question in the

instant case, however, is whether the appellant's product

being an Ayurvedic preparation could be a drug for being

included in the definition of medicinal preparation for the

purpose of the Act. This question was not raised in the

above cases.

As Mr. Dholakia points out, the Circular would render

item 3(i) of the Schedule wholly redundant. It has been the

consistent policy of legislature to exempt item 3(i) hither-

to 2(i), from duty. The legislature has not in any way

changed it. The Explanation has not in any way altered the

classification in the Schedule. The substituted Explanation

no doubt stressed on patents and trade marks. But it has not

expressly envisaged in item I, patented trade marked

Ayurvedic preparations contrary to the classification in the

Schedule. Ex praecedentibus et consequentibus optima fit

interpretatio. The best interpretation is made from the

context. Injustum est nisi tota lege inspecta, de una aliqua

ejus particula proposita judicare Vel respondere. It is

unjust to decide or respond as to any particular part of a

law without examining the whole of the law. Interpretare et

concordare leges legibus, est optimus interpretendi modus.

To interpret and in such a way as to harmonize laws with

laws, is the best mode of interpretation. In the instant

case the Director's Circular is not in harmony with item

3(i) or with the classifi-

152

cation of Ayurvedic preparations in separate item 3. It

would not be in conformity with definition of medicinal

preparation' in s. 2(g) of the Act. Jura eodern modo dislit-

uentur quo constitutuntur. Laws are abrogated by the same

means (authority) by which they are made. The Director's

Circular is not shown to have been a piece of delegated

legislation. The Explanation on its tenor does not amend the

Schedule. No part of a Statute is to be taken as superfluous

or redundant. Every word in a Statute is to be given a

meaning. A construction which would leave without effect any

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 18 of 18

part of the language of a statute will normally be rejected.

Every clause of a statute is to be construed with reference

to the context and other clauses of the Act so as to make,

as far as possible, a consistent enactment of the whole

Statute.

The High Court accepted the submission that it provided

a selfcontained definition of 'patent and proprietary medi-

cines' for the purpose of the main Act and severed the

connection between the provisions of the Drugs Act as was

contemplated in earlier Explanation I, and consequently one

need not look to the Drugs Act at all for its interpretation

and the Schedule was thence to be interpreted as it existed

along with that self-containing definition in Explanation I.

In doing so, the position that "Patent and Proprietary

medicines" means "any medicinal preparation" which very

"Medicinal preparation" includes all drugs which are a

remedy or prescription etc. as defined in s. 2(g) of the

Act. So a reference to the Drugs Act was still necessary. No

doubt this is an inclusive definition. To enlarge its deno-

tation a specific provision to include Ayurvedic prepara-

tions containing selfgenerated alcohol which are not capable

of being consumed as ordinary alcoholic beverages was neces-

sary. That having not been done by the Explanation itself,

it was not permissible to include it by the Circular. The

Explanation I could not have been in conflict with the

provisions of the Act and the Circular could not have been

in conflict with the Explanation, the Schedule, the Rules

and the Act.

In the result, we set aside the judgment and decree of

the High Court and restore those of the Civil Judge decree-

ing the suit. We leave the parties to bear their own costs.

Y. Lal Appeal

allowed.

153

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter