Motor Accident Claim; APSRTC; Compensation; Permanent Disability; High Court Appeal; M.V.O.P.; Rash and Negligent Driving; Just Compensation; Pecuniary Damages; Non-Pecuniary Damages
 02 Nov, 2026
Listen in 01:51 mins | Read in 24:00 mins
EN
HI

APSRTC Vs. Gadi Rama Lakshmi Another

  Andhra Pradesh High Court MACMA.No.2817 of 2017
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, the appellant, APSRTC, filed an appeal against the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal's award for compensation to a petitioner who suffered multiple grievous injuries and permanent disability, ...

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

Date of reserved for orders : 11.09.2026

Date of pronouncement : 02.11.2026

Date of uploading : 02.11.2026

APHC010892062017

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH

AT AMARAVATI

(Special Original Jurisdiction)

[3604]

MONDAY, THE 2

ND

DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026

PRESENT

THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM

MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2817/2017

Between:

1. APSRTC, REP. BY ITS VICE CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING

DIRECTOR OWNER OF APSRTC BUS BEARING NO. AP -11Z-2500

OF ELURU DEPOT , MUSHEERABAD, HYDERABAD. NOW AT

VIJAYAWADA

...APPELLANT

AND

1. GADI RAMA LAKSHMI ANOTHER, W/O SAMBASIVA RAO AGED

ABOUT 54 YEARS, OCC:HOUSE WIFE RESIDENT OF D.NO. 206 -6-

84/2 ANKANAVARI STREET, GANDHI NAGAR ELURU, WEST

GODAVARI DISTRICT

2. RAMISETTY PRABHAKARA RAO, S/O RAMA RAO DRIVER OF

APSRTC BUS BEARING NO. NO,. AP -11-Z-2500 SRIRAMA NAGAR,

C/O SRI VENKATA SAI FANCY & KIRANA 5TN ROAD, ELURU, WEST

GODAVARI DISTRICT

...RESPONDENT(S):

Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtto allow the

appeal by setting aside the judgment and decree passed by Motor Accidents

Claims Tribunal-cum-VW Additional District and Sessions Judge, West

Godavari at Eluru passed in M.V.O.P No. 639 OF 2013 dated 26.09.2016 and

pass

2

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

IA NO: 1 OF 2017(MACMAMP 4982 OF 2017

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated

in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased

IA NO: 2 OF 2017(MACMAMP 4983 OF 2017

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated

in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased

Counsel for the Appellant:

1. K SRINIVASA PRASAD SC For APSRTC

Counsel for the Respondent(S):

1. N SRIHARI

The Court made the following:

3

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM

MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2817 OF 2017

JUDGMENT:

Assailing the award and decree dated 26.09.2016 in M.V.O.P.No.639 of

2013 passed by the Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-VIII

Additional District and Sessions Judge, West Godavari, respondent

No.2/APSRTC preferred the instant appeal for granting an amount of

Rs.15,75,960/- towards compensation.

2. The parties are being referred to as „petitioner‟ and „respondents‟ as

arrayed in the petition before the Tribunal, for the sake of convenience and

clarity.

3. Case of the petitioner is thus:

On 18.03.2012, while the petitioner along with others were travelling in

the APSRTC bus bearing No.AP11-Z-2500 from Eluru to Chintalapudi to

attend her personal work and when they reached near T.T.D. Kalyana

Mandapam, Chintalapudi at 9.45 P.M, driver of the bus drove the same in a

rash and negligent manner and dashed against the road side tree, bus turned

turtle and as a result of which, petitioner and others sustained grievous

injuries. Immediately after the accident, all the injured were shifted to the

government hospital, Chintalapudi. Petitioner took treatment in the

Government Headquarters Hospital, Eluru, Government General Hospital,

Guntur and private hospital for better treatment. A case in crime No.43 of

2012 is registered of the offences under Sections 337 and 338 of Indian Penal

Code (hereinafter referred to as „the Code‟) and against the driver of the bus

as the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of driver of the

bus and as such, both the respondents are liable to pay compensation.

4

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

4. Respondent No.2 filed counter refuting the averments made in the

petition, wherein, inter alia contended that the petitioner claimed excessive

compensation and interest, petitioner was not a passenger of the bus, and

with other formal denials, prayed to dismiss the petition.

5. Taking into consideration of the aforementioned pleadings, the learned

Tribunal settled the following issues:

1) Whether the claimant sustained injuries due to rash and

negligent driving of APSRTC Bus bearing No.AP11Z 2500 on

18.03.2012 at about 9.45 A.M, near T.T.D. Kalyana Mandapam,

Chintalapudi, West Godavari District by the driver/1

st

respondent?

2) Whether the driver/R1 possessed a valid driving license at the

time of accident?

3) Whether the accident resulted in permanent disablement of the

injured/victim?

4) Whether the claimant is entitled to claim compensation? If so,

to what relief?

6. During trial, petitioner examined herself as PW.1 and she has got

examined PW Nos.2 to 4, and filed Exs.A1 to A16, X1 and X2 documents. As

against the said evidence, respondents have not adduced either oral or

documentary evidence. At the culmination of trial, learned Tribunal allowed

the petition granting compensation of Rs.15,75,960/- with interest at 7.5% per

annum. Feeling aggrieved by the said award and decree dated 26.09.2016,

respondent No.2 preferred the instant appeal urging the following grounds:

(i) The Award and decree of the learned Tribunal is illegal, arbitrary,

unjust and contrary to law.

(ii) The learned Tribunal has not properly considered the oral and

documentary evidence to decide the issues.

(iii) The learned Tribunal ought to have appreciated the fact that the

petitioner failed to establish the rash and negligent driving of the

driver of the bus.

5

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

(iv) The learned Tribunal erred in not considering the fact that

petitioner has not produced bus ticket to prove that she was

travelling in the bus.

(v) The learned Tribunal erred in considering the age of the petitioner

as 50 years without any valid proof and erroneously applied

multiplier „13‟.

(vi) The learned Tribunal erred in awarding compensation of

Rs.6,87,960/- towards 98% disability without any valid certificate

from the competent authority.

(vii) The learned Tribunal erred in awarding compensation of

Rs.60,000/- towards medical expenses, Rs.30,000/- towards

transportation, Rs.4,00,000/- towards pain and suffering,

Rs.1,00,000/- towards loss of earnings, Rs.48,000/- towards extra

nourishment and Rs.2,00,000/- towards loss of amenities.

(viii) The learned Tribunal erroneously awarded excessive

compensation than the compensation claimed by the petitioner,

and with other grounds, prayed to allow the appeal.

7. Heard both sides.

8. On hearing both sides and upon perusing the material available on

record, the points that would arise for consideration are:

1. Whether the accident dated 18.03.2012 occurred due to the rash

and negligent driving of APSRTC bus bearing No.AP11 Z 2500?

2. Whether the petitioner is entitled for compensation? If so, to what

amount?

3. Whether the Award and decree dated 26.09.2016 passed by the

learned Tribunal are sustainable in facts and law?

4. To what relief?

6

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

9. Admittedly, petitioner has not preferred any appeal challenging the

findings of the learned Tribunal, however, being the first appellate court and

final fact finding court, this court has to re-examine and re-appreciate the

entire oral as well as documentary evidence on record.

10. Point No.1:

(a) To prove the contentions, petitioner examined herself as PW.1, filed

examination in chief affidavit in lieu of his chief examination reiterating the

averments made in the petition. PW.1 testified that on 18.03.2012, at about

09.45 A.M, while herself and others were going in the APSRTC bus bearing

No.AP11-Z-2500 from Eluru to Chintalapudi and when the bus reached near

T.T.D. Kalyana Mandapam, driver of the APSRTC bus drove the same in a

rash and negligent manner and dashed against the road side tree and as a

result, herself and other passengers sustained multiple grievous injuries and

since the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of driver of

the bus, a case in crime No.43 of 2012 is registered of the offence under

Sections 337 and 338 of the Code, against the driver. Nothing useful material

is elicited in the cross examination of PW 1.

(b) Further, as seen from Ex.A1/First information report, a case in crime

No.43 of 2012 is registered of the offences stated supra against the driver of

the bus i.e. respondent No.1 and after completion of investigation, police

found fault with the driver and laid Ex.A5/Charge sheet alleging that the

accident occurred due to his rash and negligent driving. So, Exs.A1 and A5

supports the evidence of PW.1 and no rebuttal evidence is adduced by the

respondents on this aspect. Added to it, respondent No.2 failed to examine its

driver, who is the best person to speak about the accident and his non

examination is fatal to the case of the respondents. So, in the absence of any

rebuttal evidence, the evidence of PW.1, which is buttressed by EXs.A1 & A5,

clinchingly proves that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent

driving of driver of the bus bearing No.AP 11Z 2500 by its driver. As seen

7

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

from EX.A3/Motor Vehicle Inspector Report, the accident was not occurred

due to any mechanical defects. Learned counsel for the respondent No.2

contended that petitioner had not travelled in the bus. But, as seen from

Ex.A4/Wound certificate, on 18.03.2012 petitioner took treatment in the

Government hospital, Chintalapudi and in EX.A5/Charge sheet, petitioner is

cited as one of the injured persons. As per the material brought on to the

record, this court came to conclusion that the accident occurred due to the

rash and negligent driving of the bus bearing No.AP 11Z 2500 by its driver

and the petitioner sustained injuries in the said accident. Hence, this point is

accordingly answered in favour of the petitioner.

11. Point No.2:

(a) As per the version of the petitioner, she was hale and healthy, was aged

about 50 years, working as coolie and was earning Rs.6000/- per month, on

18.03.2012, she sustained multiple grievous injuries, immediately after the

accident, she was shifted to the Government Hospital, Chintalapudi, from

there, shifted to the Government Headquarters Hospital, Eluru, Government

General Hospital, Guntur and private hospital for better treatment, took

treatment for more than 50 days, underwent surgeries, both legs below the

knees were amputated, suffered loss of income and permanent disability, and

filed Exs.A4/Wound certificate and A6/Disability certificate, EX.X1 and

X2/Case sheets.

(b) To prove her injuries and treatment, petitioner has got examined two

doctors as PWs.3 and 4. P.W.4 who is Civil Assistant Surgeon testified that on

18.3.2012 at 04.00 P.M., the petitioner was referred from community health

centre, Chintalapudi, he examined P.W.1 and found injuries of avulsion of

Heel upto middle of left foot with partial degloving of dorsal skin and crush

injury of right foot and on 21.3.2012, she was referred to higher centre and

admitted EX.X.2/Case sheet and Ex.A.4/Wound certificate, and further stated

that both the injuries are grievous in nature.

8

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

(c) P.W.3 testified that on 22.3.2012 the petitioner was admitted in

Government General Hospital, Guntur and on the same day, below knee

guillitone amputation of both lower limbs is done, on 09.4.2012, conducted

surgery to the right lower limb with knee disarticulation closure of the stump,

on 23.4.2012, conducted another surgery to the left lower limb with revision

below knee amputation of left lower limb and on 04.05.2012, the petitioner

was discharged with an advice to get follow up treatment and the petitioner

cannot perform her activities independently, and P.W.3 admitted EX.X1/Case

sheet.

(d) So far as disability of the petitioner is concerned, P.W.2/ Civil Assistant

Surgeon testified that on 03.08.2012, the petitioner approached Medical

Board, Eluru, Dr. M.V.G.Tilak, Civil Assistant Surgeon-Cum-Member of

Medical Board examined the petitioner and issued disability certificate by

assessing the disability at 98% which is permanent in nature, the said doctor

is no more and he identified signature of the said doctor on EX.A6/Disability

certificate and the petitioner. It is his further evidence that without the help of

a female assistant, the petitioner cannot move from the bed to attend her

routine activities permanently.

(e) Having considered the injuries and treatment taken by the petitioner

coupled with medical record, the learned Tribunal had considered the

functional disability at 98%. However, in view of the amputation of both legs,

functional disability of the petitioner can be assessed as 100%.

(f) Insofar as age of the petitioner is concerned, as seen from EX.X1/Case

sheet and EX.A5/Charge sheet, petitioner was aged about 50 years, as on the

date of accident. There is no contra evidence to that effect. So, it can safely

be concluded that the petitioner was aged about 50 years, as on the date of

the accident. Insofar as income of the petitioner is concerned, she has not

filed any documents to prove her monthly income. In the given facts and

circumstances coupled with the fact that the accident occurred in the year

9

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

2012 and on a reasonable hypothesis, monthly earnings of the petitioner have

to be considered at (150x30) Rs.4,500/-.

(g) Admittedly, the petitioner has not filed any appeal for enhancement of

compensation, however, learned counsel for the petitioners would argue that

though they have not filed any appeal or cross objections seeking

enhancement of compensation, just and fair compensation may be awarded.

Learned counsel for the respondents argued that the accident occurred in the

year 2011 and as such, the present principles of law shall not be applied to

the facts of the case at hand. It is settled principle of law that the petitioners

are entitled for just and fair compensation and further, in exercise of the

appellate powers under Order 41 Rule 33, this court can enhance the amount

of compensation even in the absence of appeal or cross objections. In this

regard, it is to be noted that in Sharanamma & Others v. Divisional

Controller, North-East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation

1

, Hon‟ble

Apex Court held thus:

“10. When an appeal is filed under Section 173 of the

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, before the High Court, the normal

rules which apply to appeals before the High Court, are

applicable to such an appeal also. Even otherwise, it is well

settled position of law that when an appeal is provided for, the

whole case is open before the appellate court and by necessary

implication, it can exercise all powers incidental thereto in order

to exercise that power effectively. A bare reading of Section

173 of the Act also reflects that there is no curtailment or

limitations on the powers of the appellate court to consider the

entire case on facts and law”.

(h) Further, in National Insurance Company Limited rep. By its Branch

Manager v. Susheelamma and Others

2

, having considered the

aforementioned principle, Division Bench of this Court has held that to the

appeal under Section 173 of the M.V. Act to the High Court, in the absence of

a different procedure having been provided, either under the M.V. Act or the

1

2013 (11) SCC 517

2

2023 SCC Online AP 1725

10

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

A.P.M.V. Rules, 1989, and the applicability of Order 41 C.P.C also not having

been excluded, the normal rules which apply to appeals before the High

Court, are applicable and further held that for doing justice and to award just

compensation, the provisions of Order 41 Rule 33 are to be invoked.

(i) And, in Surekha v. Santhosh

3

, having agreed with the stand of the

claimants that just compensation amount ought to be awarded, High Court of

Judicature at Bombay declined to grant enhancement merely on the ground

that the claimants failed to file cross appeal and in such circumstances,

Hon‟ble Apex Court held that it is well settled that in the matter of insurance

claim compensation in reference to the motor accident, the court should not

take hyper technical approach and ensure that just compensation is awarded

to the affected person or the claimants. So, in the absence of any appeal or

cross objections in respect of quantum of compensation, this Court is under

obligation to award just and fair compensation.

(j) So, as per the evidence of PWs 1 to 4 coupled with Exs.A4 to A6, X1

and X2, petitioner sustained grievous injuries to her both legs, underwent

three surgeries, took treatment for more than 50 days, her both legs below the

knees were amputated, incurred expenses towards treatment, lost income

during the period of treatment and also suffered disability and the details of

compensation under each head are as follows:

I. Pecuniary Damages:

i) Loss of earnings due to disability and future prospects:

(a) Having considered the amputations of both legs of the petitioner below

the knees, this court assessed the functional disability of the petitioner at

100%. In Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation

4

, Hon‟ble Apex Court

held thus:

3

(2021) 16 SCC 467

4

(2009) 6 SCC 121

11

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

“It is necessary to reiterate that the multiplier method is logically sound and legally

well established. There are some cases which have proceeded to determine the

compensation on the basis of aggregating the entire future earnings for over the

period the life expectancy was lost, deducted a percentage therefrom towards

uncertainties of future life and award the resulting sum as compensation. This is

clearly unscientific. For instance, if the deceased was, say 25 years of age at the time

of death and the life expectancy is 70 years, this method would multiply the loss of

dependency for 45 years virtually adopting a multiplier of 45 and even if ─ ─ one-third

or one-fourth is deducted therefrom towards the uncertainties of future life and for

immediate lump sum payment, the effective multiplier would be between 30 and 34.

This is wholly impermissible.”

(b) This principle applies to the permanent disability cases also. So, the

loss of future earnings have to be calculated by applying the multiplier

method. It is evident from the record that the petitioner was aged about 50

years, as on the date of accident and the relevant multiplier is „13‟. Further, in

National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi

5

, the Hon‟ble Apex

Court considered the claim for future prospects of a victim, a carpenter, who

had suffered permanent disability. Since, the petitioner was aged about 50

years, 25% of the future prospects have to be taken into consideration.

ii) Loss of earnings (Past):

The shock, pain and suffering at the time of accident, pain discomfort

and inconvenience during the period of treatment, hospitalization and bed rest

can be visualized. It is common knowledge that without a reasonable physical

fitness one cannot do any work and in the light of the documents on record

and considering the nature of injuries sustained and treatment received by

PW. 1, it is reasonable to accept that the injured was out of work for at least

one year. So, loss of earnings (past) are determined at Rs.56,000/-

(Rs.4,500x12).

iii) Medical Expenses: Petitioner has not filed any medical bills showing

actual expenditure. In this regard, it is to be noted that in Managing Director,

Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation Vs. Kathavath

Gopal

6

, coordinate bench of erstwhile High Court held that compensation

5

2017 (16) SCC 680

6

2003 (5) ALD 198

12

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

towards the expenditure incurred and transportation cannot be denied even

though treatment was given in the Government Hospital and one cannot be

expected to produce evidence proving the actual expenditure and hence,

some reasonable hypothesis cannot be ruled out. Learned Tribunal rightly

considered medical expenses at Rs.60,000/- and the same shall be taken into

consideration.

iv) Attendant Charges: In view of the judgment of Hon‟ble Apex Court in

R.D.Hattangadi Vs M/s. Pest Control (India) Private Limited and Others

7

,

the Court need not be mathematical in calculating expenses towards home

attendant, but ought to look upon the circumstances prevailing in the society

to decide the amount and in the present case at hand, the petitioner took

treatment and underwent surgeries, was advised bed rest and also follow up

treatment, and as such, he is entitled to attendant charges for 12 months,

which is assessed at Rs.12,000/-.

v) Loss of Conveyance: In Sidram Vs. The Divisional Manager, United

India Insurance Company Limited and another

8

(Supra), the Hon‟ble Apex

Court held at para No.89 as follows:

“89. Hence, we may grant the appellant loss of conveyance and special diet

up to Rs.50,000/- considering that after the accident at Kulgod-Gokak Road,

the appellant was shifted to Lake view Hospital Belgaum wherein he was

admitted as an indoor patient from 18.07.2012 to 06.08.2012 for 19 days, and

took treatment for the injuries suffered by him, and continued to take the

treatment after getting discharged from the Hospital as well.”

In view of the injuries sustained by the petitioner and period of treatment

taken by her, an amount of Rs.20,000/- is awarded towards conveyance.

II) Non-Pecuniary Damages:

7

1995 1 SCC 551

8

(2022) 8 SCR 403

13

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

(i) Pain and Suffering:

The Divisional Controller, KSRTC v. Mahadeva Shetty and

Another

9

, the Hon‟ble Apex Court held thus:

“A person not only suffers injuries on account of accident but also

suffers in mind and body on account of the accident throughout his life

and a feeling is developed that he is no more a normal man and cannot

enjoy the amenities of life as another normal person can. While fixing

compensation for pain and suffering as also for loss of amenities of life

the features like his age, marital status and unusual deprivation he has

undertaken in his life has to be reckoned”.

In view of the injuries and permanent disability sustained by the

petitioner and the period of treatment taken by her, an amount of

Rs.4,00,000/- is awarded towards pain and suffering.

(ii) Loss of Amenities:

In Pappu Deo Yadav Vs. Naresh Kumar and others

10

, the Hon‟ble

Apex Court held thus:

“The principle consistently followed by this court in assessing motor

vehicle compensation claims, is to place the victim in as near a position as

she or he was in before the accident, with other compensatory directions

for loss of amenities and other payments. These general principles have

been stated and reiterated in several decisions (Govind Yadav Vs. New

India Insurance Co Limited, (2011) 10 SCC 683.”

Having regard to the injuries and treatment, an amount of Rs.1,00,000/-

is awarded towards loss of amenities.

Further, in Govind Yadav Vs. New India Insurance Co Limited

11

,

Hon‟ble Apex Court held thus:

“18. In our view, the principles laid down in Aravind Kumar Mishra Vs. New

India Assurance Company Limited (2010) 10 SCC 264 and Raj Kumar Vs.

Ajay Kumar must be followed by all the Tribunals and the High Courts in

determining the quantum of compensation payable to the victims of

9

2003 (7) SCC 197

10

AIR 2020 SCC 4421

11

(2011) 10 SCC 683

14

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

accident, who are disabled either permanently or temporarily . If the victim

of the accident suffers permanent disability, then efforts should always be

made to award adequate compensation not only for the physical injury and

treatment, but also for the loss earning and his inability to lead a normal life

and enjoy amenities, which he would have enjoyed but for the disability

caused due to the accused”.

(k) So, in all, the petitioner is entitled to the compensation as follows:

S.No. HEADS CALCULATION

I Pecuniary damages:

i) Loss of earnings due to disability (4,500 X

12 X 13 X100/100) (future)

Rs. 7,02,000.00

ii) Future Prospects (7,02,000X 25/100) Rs. 1,75,500.00

iii) Loss of earnings (past) Rs. 56,000.00

iv) Medical expenses Rs. 60,000.00

v) Attendant charges Rs. 12,000.00

vi) Conveyance Rs. 20,000.00

vii) Future medical expenses or artificial limbs Rs. 75,000

Total 11,00,500.00

II Non Pecuniary expenses:

vii) Pain and suffering Rs. 4,00,000.00

viii) Loss of amenities Rs. 1,00,000.00

Total 5,00,000.00

TOTAL (pecuniary+non-pecuniary damages)

(11,00,500+5,00,000)

Rs. 16,00,500.00

(l) In this court‟s well considered view that in accordance with the

propositions of law laid down by the Hon‟ble Apex Court, the compensation of

Rs.16,00,500.00/- is just and reasonable. It is needless to say that though the

petitioner claimed compensation of Rs.12,00,000/-, in view of the settled

principles of law, just and fair compensation is to be awarded to the petitioner.

(m) So far as the liability of the respondents is concerned, it is to be noted

that a finding is already recorded in issue No.1, holding that driver of bus

bearing No.AP 11 Z 2500 was solely responsible for the accident and

15

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

respondent No.2/APSRTC is vicariously liable to indemnify the liability of

respondent No.1/driver. Hence, this issue is answered, holding that the

respondent Nos.1 and 2 are jointly and severally liable to pay compensation.

12. Point No.3:

Upon reappraisal of the evidence on record, and for the foregoing

reasons, this court came to the conclusion that the learned Tribunal erred in

assessing the quantum of compensation and as such, the same is liable to be

modified. Hence, this point is answered accordingly.

13. Point No.4:

(i) In the result, this Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is

dismissed, while modifying the order of the learned Tribunal by enhancing the

compensation from Rs.15,75,960/- (Rupees Fifteen Lakhs Seventy Five

Thousand Nine Hundred and Sixty Only) to Rs.16,00,500.00/- (Rupees

Sixteen Lakhs Five hundred only) together with interest at the same rate as

awarded by the Tribunal, from the date of the claim petition till the date of

realization, subject to payment of additional court fee on Rs.4,00,500/-

(Rupees Four Lakhs Five Hundred Only) by the petitioner before the

Registry within thirty (30) days from today.

(ii) Time for deposit, as aforesaid, with interest, excluding the amount, if

any, already deposited, is one (1) month from the date of receipt of a copy of

this judgment.

(iii) On such deposit, the petitioner is permitted to withdraw the

compensation as awarded supra along with accrued interest thereon,

excluding the amount, already paid.

(iv) There shall be no order as to costs.

16

SUN, J

MACMA.No.2817 of 2017

As a sequel thereto, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand

closed.

________________________

SUNITHA GANDHAM, J

Dt: 02.11.2026

Vns

Whether the order is :

✓

Speaking Yes/No / Reasoned Yes/No

✓

Reportable Yes/No / Non-Reportable Yes/No

Reference cases

Description

The recent ruling in Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No: 2817/2017 by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati, presided over by Smt Justice Sunitha Gandham, stands as a crucial precedent in Motor Accident Compensation cases, particularly concerning APSRTC Liability. This significant judgment, pronounced on November 2, 2026, and uploaded on the same day, addresses the principles of just compensation and the appellate court's powers in motor accident claims. You can find the full details and status of this and other pivotal rulings on CaseOn, India's leading legal research platform.

Understanding the Case: A Tragic Accident and Compensation Claim

This case stems from a grievous motor accident that occurred on March 18, 2012. The claimant, Gadi Rama Lakshmi, was a passenger in an APSRTC bus (bearing No. AP-11Z-2500) traveling from Eluru to Chintalapudi. Near T.T.D. Kalyana Mandapam, the bus driver, Ramisetty Prabhakara Rao (Respondent No.1), drove rashly and negligently, causing the bus to collide with a roadside tree and overturn. The claimant sustained multiple severe injuries, including the amputation of both legs below the knees.

Following the accident, a criminal case (Crime No. 43 of 2012) was registered against the driver under Sections 337 and 338 of the Indian Penal Code. The claimant sought compensation from the APSRTC (Respondent No.2) and its driver. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-VIII Additional District and Sessions Judge, West Godavari, Eluru, in M.V.O.P No. 639 of 2013, dated September 26, 2016, awarded a compensation of Rs.15,75,960/-. Aggrieved by this award, APSRTC preferred an appeal to the High Court.

The Core Issues Before the High Court

The High Court meticulously examined the following issues:

  1. Whether the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the APSRTC bus driver.
  2. Whether the petitioner (claimant) was entitled to compensation, and if so, the appropriate amount.
  3. Whether the award and decree passed by the learned Tribunal were sustainable in facts and law.
  4. What relief could be granted.

Legal Principles Guiding the Decision

The High Court’s decision was rooted in several well-established legal principles concerning motor accident claims and appellate jurisdiction:

  • Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (Section 173): This section governs appeals in motor vehicle cases, emphasizing that normal rules of appeal apply, and the appellate court can exercise all incidental powers to ensure effective justice.

  • Code of Civil Procedure (Order 41 Rule 33): This crucial provision allows an appellate court to grant relief to a party even if they have not filed a cross-appeal or cross-objections, especially when it concerns awarding just and fair compensation. This principle was reinforced by precedents such as Sharanamma & Others v. Divisional Controller, North-East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation and National Insurance Company Limited v. Susheelamma and Others.

  • Just and Fair Compensation: The court reiterated the Apex Court's stance in Surekha v. Santhosh, that a hyper-technical approach should be avoided in insurance claim compensation cases, and the court is obligated to award just and fair compensation to affected persons.

  • Multiplier Method for Disability: The calculation of future earnings and loss due to permanent disability follows the multiplier method, as laid down in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation.

  • Future Prospects: In cases of permanent disability, future prospects are to be considered. For a victim aged 50 years, 25% addition for future prospects was guided by National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi.

  • Compensation for Non-Documented Expenses: Even in the absence of specific bills, compensation for medical expenses and transportation cannot be denied if treatment was received, as held in Managing Director, APSRTC v. Kathavath Gopal.

  • Attendant Charges, Conveyance, Pain and Suffering, Loss of Amenities: The court relied on various precedents, including R.D. Hattangadi v. M/s. Pest Control (India) Private Limited and Others for attendant charges, Sidram v. The Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited and another for conveyance and special diet, and The Divisional Controller, KSRTC v. Mahadeva Shetty and Another and Pappu Deo Yadav v. Naresh Kumar and others for pain, suffering, and loss of amenities.

The High Court's Detailed Analysis

The High Court thoroughly re-examined the evidence and arguments presented:

Findings on Negligence

The court affirmed the Tribunal's finding that the accident occurred solely due to the rash and negligent driving of the APSRTC bus driver. This was supported by PW.1's testimony, the First Information Report (Ex.A1), and the Charge Sheet (Ex.A5). Crucially, the APSRTC failed to provide any rebuttal evidence or examine its driver, strengthening the claimant's case. The Motor Vehicle Inspector's Report (Ex.A3) confirmed no mechanical defects in the bus.

Assessment of Injuries, Disability, Age, and Income

The claimant sustained severe injuries, leading to bilateral below-knee amputations. Medical evidence from PWs.3 and 4 (doctors) and disability certificates (Ex.A6) confirmed a 98% permanent disability. The High Court, considering the complete loss of mobility due to bilateral amputation, assessed the functional disability at 100%.

Regarding age, the court accepted the claimant's age as 50 years at the time of the accident, based on the case sheet (Ex.X1) and charge sheet (Ex.A5). As for income, since no documents were provided, the court adopted a notional monthly income of Rs.4,500/- (calculated at Rs.150x30) for an accident in 2012.

The Power to Enhance Compensation

Despite the claimant not filing an appeal for enhancement, the High Court, exercising its powers under Order 41 Rule 33 of the CPC and guided by Apex Court pronouncements, found it necessary to award just and fair compensation. This meant the court could enhance the compensation beyond what was originally claimed or awarded by the Tribunal.

To assist legal professionals in quickly grasping the nuances of such rulings, CaseOn.in offers 2-minute audio briefs. These concise summaries distill the complex legal arguments and judicial reasoning, making it significantly easier to analyze these specific rulings and integrate them into legal strategies.

Revised Compensation Calculation

Based on the functional disability (100%), age (50 years, multiplier 13), and notional income (Rs.4,500/-), the High Court recalculated the compensation as follows:

Pecuniary Damages:

  • Loss of earnings due to disability (Future): Rs.4,500 x 12 x 13 x 100/100 = Rs. 7,02,000/-
  • Future Prospects (25%): Rs.7,02,000 x 25/100 = Rs. 1,75,500/-
  • Loss of earnings (Past, for 1 year): Rs.4,500 x 12 = Rs. 56,000/-
  • Medical expenses: Rs. 60,000/-
  • Attendant charges (12 months): Rs. 12,000/-
  • Conveyance: Rs. 20,000/-
  • Future medical expenses or artificial limbs: Rs. 75,000/-
  • Total Pecuniary Damages: Rs. 11,00,500/-

Non-Pecuniary Damages:

  • Pain and suffering: Rs. 4,00,000/-
  • Loss of amenities: Rs. 1,00,000/-
  • Total Non-Pecuniary Damages: Rs. 5,00,000/-

Grand Total Compensation: Rs. 16,00,500/-

Liability

The court held that APSRTC (Respondent No.2) was vicariously liable to indemnify the liability of its driver (Respondent No.1). Therefore, both respondents were held jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation.

The Final Judgment and Outcome

In conclusion, the High Court dismissed the appeal filed by APSRTC. It modified the Tribunal's award, enhancing the compensation from Rs.15,75,960/- to Rs.16,00,500/-. The enhanced amount will carry interest at the same rate as awarded by the Tribunal, from the date of the claim petition until realization. The petitioner is required to pay an additional court fee of Rs.4,00,500/- on the enhanced amount. The court also granted one month for the deposit of the amount and allowed the petitioner to withdraw the compensation upon deposit. There was no order as to costs.

Why This Judgment is an Important Read for Lawyers and Students

This judgment is a cornerstone for legal professionals and students for several reasons:

  • Scope of Appellate Powers: It powerfully illustrates the extensive powers of an appellate court under Order 41 Rule 33 of the CPC and Section 173 of the MV Act to ensure justice, even when the aggrieved party (claimant in this case) has not sought enhancement.

  • Principles of Just Compensation: The ruling meticulously applies various Apex Court precedents on different heads of compensation, such as loss of future earnings, future prospects, medical expenses (even without bills), attendant charges, conveyance, pain, suffering, and loss of amenities. It emphasizes the holistic approach required to place the victim as close as possible to their pre-accident position.

  • Assessment of Functional Disability: The court's assessment of bilateral amputation leading to 100% functional disability provides a clear benchmark for similar severe injury cases.

  • Notional Income Determination: The method of determining notional income for self-employed or daily wage earners when documentary evidence is lacking, based on the accident year, is clearly demonstrated.

  • Vicarious Liability: It reaffirms the principle of vicarious liability of the vehicle owner (APSRTC) for the negligent acts of its driver.

  • Practical Application of Law: This case serves as an excellent practical guide on how different legal principles and judicial precedents are interwoven to arrive at a fair and equitable compensation in motor accident claims.

Disclaimer

All information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, readers are advised to consult with a qualified legal professional for advice on specific legal issues.

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter