Hindi Prachar Samiti, Assam Act 1984, fundamental rights, Article 19(1)(C), ultra vires, Writ Petition, Supreme Court India, management control, elected bodies, association rights
0  19 Sep, 1989
Listen in 01:54 mins | Read in 25:00 mins
EN
HI

Asom Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti-A Society Registered Under The Societies Registration Act, 1860 and Having Its Registered office At Hedayatpur, Gauhati-3, Represented By Its Mantri Shri Tholok Gogoi and Another Vs. State of Assam and Others

  Supreme Court Of India Writ Petition Civil /9960-61/1985
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, an institution, Asom Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti, dedicated to spreading Hindi, amended its constitution to remove the Chief Minister as its ex-officio head. Following this, the Chief ...

Bench

Applied Acts & Sections

No Acts & Articles mentioned in this case

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 12

PETITIONER:

ASOM RASHTRABHASHA PRACHAR SAMITI-A SOCIETYREGISTERED UNDER

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

STATE OF ASSAM AND OTHERS

DATE OF JUDGMENT19/09/1989

BENCH:

OZA, G.L. (J)

BENCH:

OZA, G.L. (J)

NATRAJAN, S. (J)

KULDIP SINGH (J)

CITATION:

1989 AIR 2126 1989 SCR Supl. (1) 160

1989 SCC (4) 496 JT 1989 (3) 699

1989 SCALE (2)632

ACT:

Assam Rashtrabhasha Prachar (taking over Management and

Control) Act. 1984--Section 3--Act held ultra vires--Noti-

fication nominating Board to replace Karyapalika and Byabas-

thapika Sabha-Quashed.

HEADNOTE:

For the spread of Hindi in North-Eastern part of India

an institution named Asom Hindi Prachar Samiti was formed on

3.11.38 at Gauhati. In 1948 this Samiti was renamed as Assam

Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti. The Petitioner No. 1 herein is

a registered body which claims to have a membership of about

22000 persons scattered all over the North-Eastern part of

India. This Samity has a sole constitution known as Bidhan

which is also a duly registered body. The Samiti holds

different examinations in Hindi twice a year, publishes text

books in Hindi for Primary Schools, High Schools, Higher

Secondary Schools and Colleges upto the degree standard.

Certificates issued by the Samity are recognised by the

Government of India, the Government of Assam and various

other organisations. The Samiti also imparts training and

teaching in Hindi through a number of Vidyalayas and Prama-

nita Pracharaks. The assets and properties of the Samiti at

the time of filing this Petition are stated to be worth Rs.

1,24,42,000.00.

According to the Bidhart, the management and administra-

tion of the Samiti is run by elected bodies namely Byabas-

thapika Sabha and Karyapalika, each having 5 years term from

the date of holding of its first meeting. The Karyapalika

consisted of 17 members. The Chief Minister of Assam was the

Ex-officio Adhyaksa of the Samiti but at the time of holding

of the first meeting, the State of Assam was under Presi-

dent's rule and consequently the office of Adhyaksha re-

mained vacant. Petitioner No. 2 was unanimously elected

Mantri. Petitioner No. 2 and other office bearers of the

Karyapalika held the first meeting on 19.8.1982 and the

Karyapalika was running and managing the day

161

to day affairs of the Samiti efficiently and diligently.

The Samiti in its meeting held on 17.7.83 passed a

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 12

resolution amending the Bidhan deleting the provision that

the Chief Minister of Assam shall be the ex-officio Adhyak-

sha of the Samiti. This resolution was adopted in full

compliance of Section 30 of the Bidhan and all members

present in the meeting except one supported the resolution.

After the passing of this amendment, the Respondent No. 4 as

alleged by the petitioners, passed an order dated 7.7.84 on

political considerations purportedly to act as the Ex-offi-

cio Adhyaksha of the Samiti declared a state of emergency in

the Samiti in exercise of the powers conferred under S.

16(Gha) of the Bidhan, dissolved the existing Karyapalika

and constituted an ad hoc body with himself as Chairman and

five others as members to manage the affairs of the Samiti

and asked the Petitioners to hand over the charge of the

Samiti to this Ad hoc committee. Thereupon, the petitioners

filed a suit for a declaration that the order dated 7.7.84

passed by Respondent No. 4 was void, illegal, without juris-

diction and unenforceable against the petitioner society.

The Petitioners also prayed for a permanent injunction

restraining the respondents from giving effect to the order

and also moved an application for issuance of a temporary

injunction upon which a show cause notice was issued to the

defendants who filed their objections. While the matter was

pending consideration of the question of issuing of a tempo-

rary injunction the Governor of Assam purporting to act

under clause I of Article 230 of the Constitution of India

promulgated an ordinance called the Asom Rashtrabhasha

Prachar Samiti (taking over of management and control)

Ordinance, 1984. In due course the Ordinance was replaced by

an Act passed by the Assam Legislative Assembly. Under the

Ordinance and the Act virtually the Samity which was a

public body was substituted by a Board appointed by the

Government and all the functions, properties and affairs of

the Samiti were taken over by the Board. It is this action

taken under the Ordinance and ultimately the Act which is

the subject matter of challenge in this Writ Petition. It is

contended that although the Act as its title discloses, was

a temporary measure, was continued at perpetuity and the

Samiti is being run by nominated members and the rights of

the members of the Samiti under Article 19 of the Constitu-

tion of India have not only been restricted but taken away.

Even during the hearing it was indicated that the

Government of Assam has no intention to end the temporary

arrangement of the Samiti and by this process the State

Government intends to deprive the members of the society

their rights under Article 19(1)(C) for all times to

162

come. In the Act there is no provision providing for resto-

ration of the elected bodies which shows that the use of

phrase 'temporary' was just an eye wash.

Accepting the contentions of the Petitioners, this Court

while allowing the Writ Petition.

HELD: As the Act of 1984 and the Board nominated or

appointed under Section 3 of the Act is controlling the

affairs of the Society it is not necessary to go into the

orders passed by the Chief Minister invoking the emergency

powers although the facts alleged clearly go to show that

except that the Constitution (Bidhan) was amended and the

Chief Minister was dropped from the place which he used to

enjoy before the amendment of the Bidhan, there was nothing

serious justifying all these actions starting from invoking

the emergency provisions till enacting the present Act.

[171G-H; 172A]

It is also apparent that since 1984 when this Act was

passed and a notification appointing a Board was issued, the

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 12

Government has not chosen to take any steps to restore the

Society back to its elected authorities and office bearers

and nor does it intend to do so even now. Thus this Court is

left with no option but to decide and decide upholding the

Constitution and the right of association conferred under

Article 19(1)(C) of the Constitution. [175D-E]

The Complete Control has been taken away from the Peti-

tioner Society and is given to Board nominated by the Gov-

ernment. The Board is not as an interim measure. But will

continue to control and manage the affairs of the society.

This amounts to taking away the fundamental right of the

Petitioner Society to form an Association guaranteed under

Article 19(1)(C) of the Constitution of India. [170E]

The Notification under the Act enacted by the Assam

Legislature is set aside holding that the Act itself is

ultra vires of the Constitution. The Notification issued

under Section 3 of the Act by which a Board was nominated to

replace the Karyapalika and Byabasthapika Sabha is also

quashed. [175E]

Damyanti Narang v. The Union of India and others, [1971]

3 SCR 940, referred to.

JUDGMENT:

ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (C) No. 9960-61 of

1985.

163

(Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India).

Gobind Mukhoty and S.K. Verma for the Petitioners.

Dr. Shankar Ghosh and Prabir Choudhary for the Respondents.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

OZA, J. This Writ Petition was filed challenging the

action taken by the respondent the State Government of Assam

under the Asom Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti (Taking over

management and Control) Act 1984 (Assam Act No. XXIII of

1984) which was an Act enacted by the Legislative Assembly

of Assam and received the assent by the Governor of Assam

and published in the Assam Gazette Extraordinary dated

15.12.84. It also challenged the orders contained in Notifi-

cation Nos. EPG 57/84/25/A EPG 57/84/30-A and EPG 57/84/

51-A dated 1.10.84, 10.11.84 and 19.3.85 respectively issued

by the Education (Personal) Department of the Government of

Assam.

According to the petitioner in 1929 Lahore Congress

under the leadership of Mahatma Gandhi adopted a resolution

for the spread of Hindi as the common language for the whole

of India with a view to promote national integrity and in

pursuance of this resolution institutions for the spread and

prachar of Hindi in the non-Hindi areas were established.

First of this kind was established in Madras City in the

name of Dakshin Bharat Hindi Prachar Samiti then in Wardha

for the development and spread of Hindi. in the rest of

India. Late Baba Raghab Das a devoted disciple of Gandhiji

undertook the task of spreading Hindi in the North Eastern

part of India and in 1934 eminent local leaders of this

region Late Tarun Ram Phukan, Late Nabin Chandra Bardaloi,

Late Gopinath Bardaloi, Late Krishna Nath Sarma and others

joined Baba Raghab Das and the first institution named Asom

Hindi Prachar Samiti was formed on 3.11.38 at Gauhati with

late Gopinath Bardaloi the first Chief Minister of Assam

under the 1935 Act as its President. In 1948 Asom Hindi

Prachar Samiti was renamed as Assam Rashtrabhasha Prachar

Samiti with its head Office at Gauhati.

It is this Assam Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti, the

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 12

petitioner No. 1, which is a registered society under the

Societies Registration Act, 1860 with its registered office

at Hedayatpur, Gauhati-3 District Kamrup. The registration

No. of the Samiti which is 18th of 1951 and according to the

petitioner this Society has a membership of about

164

22,000 persons scattered all over the States and Union

Territories of North-Eastern part of India. The Samiti has

district committees under its control. The Samiti also has

two affiliated bodies namely Manipur Hindi Prachar Sabha,

Imphal and the Asom Rashtrabhasha Sewak Sangh. This Samiti

has a sole constitution known as Bidhan which is also regis-

tered with the Registrar of Societies Assam at Gauhati. This

Samiti is a literary body and under Section 4 of the Bidban

the objects of the Samiti have been stated thus:

(a) To propogate and promote Hindi as a na-

tional language in Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram,

Nagaland, Manipur, Tripura and Arunachal

Pradesh as provided in Article 351 of the

Constitution of India.

(b) to promote efficient, educated, qualified

workers of good character to hold out the

Indian ideal before the future generations-

(c) to serve the State languages and litera-

tures together with the promotion of Hindi.

(d) to serve the tribal language and culture

through the medium of Hindi language and to

create kindness with the tribal brethren.

(e) to undertake a programme of literacy

amongst the illiterate.

This Samiti according to the petitioners discharge its

functions including the holding of examinations in Hindi in

the State of Assam, Meghalaya and the Union Territory (as

they were then) of Mizoram and also production and publica-

tion of prescribed text books in Hindi for Primary Schools,

High School, Higher Secondary schools and the Colleges upto

the degree standard. The Samiti holds different examinations

twice in a year in which about 60,000 candidates at the time

of the filing of this petition on an average used to appear.

The successful candidates are issued certificates which are

recognised by the Government of India and the Government of

Assam and various All India Organisation. The Samiti also

imparts training and teaching in Hindi through a large

number of Vidyalayas numbering about 400 and through Prama-

nita Pracharaks i.e. authorised propagators numbering about

5000 scattered all over in the North-Eastern part of India.

It is also alleged that the Samiti from the very inception

had acquired assets

165

and properties and the assets and properties at the time of

the filing of the petition were stated to be:

1. Buildings -- Rs.70,64,000.00

2. Printing Press with Machines -- Rs.15,00,000.00

and accessories

3. Furniture Fixture -- Rs. 3,00,000.00

4. Two portraits -- Rs. 10,000.00

5. Vehicle -- Rs. 35,000.00

6. Typewriting Schools including -- Rs. 60,000.00

machines and furnitures

7. Iron Safe -- Rs. 30,000.00

8. Compound fixing (leasedias) -- Rs. 30,000.00

9. Bank Deposits -- Rs. 3,43,000.00

10. Security Deposit with Ashok -- Rs. 30,000.00

Paper Mill Ltd.

11. Shares of Assam Coop-apex -- Rs. 5,000.00

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 5 of 12

Bank Ltd.

12. Stock of printing papers -- Rs. 50,000.00

and stationaries

13. Stock of text books -- Rs.22,00,000.00

14. Misc. articles including -- Rs.50,00,000.00

utensils

15. Building Materials -- Rs.25,00,000.00

16. Central Library -- Rs.10,00,000.00

17. Value of the old books -- Rs. 3,00,000.00

TOTAL -- Rs. 124,42,000.00

According to the Bidhan of the Samiti the management and

administration of the Samiti is run by elected bodies namely

Byabasthapika Sabha (meaning the General Council) and the

Karyapalika (meaning the Executive Committee), the term of

each body is 5 years from the date of holding of their first

meeting. Accordingly the term of

166

the Byabasthapika Sabha was to expire on 9.8.87 (five years

from the date of holding the first meeting) which was held

on 10.8.82 and the term of Karyapalika was to expire on

18.8.87 (five years from the date of the first meeting which

was 19.8.82).

That under Section 10 of the Bidhan the Karyapalika of

the Samiti consisted of 17 members with the following of-

fice-bearers:

(i) Adhyakasha (President)

(ii) Karyadhakshya (Working President)

(iii) Upadhakshya (Vice President)

(iv) Mantri (General Secretary)

(v) Koshadhyaksha (Treasurer)

(vi) Six members elected by the Byabasthapika Sabha

(vii) The Education Secretary to the Government of Assam or

a member nominated by him.

(viii) Five members of the Byabasthapika Sabha nominated by

the Adhyaksha, and

(ix) Pradhan Sachib (Chief Secretary) and other departmental

secretaries of the Samiti.

According to the petitioner the first meeting of this

last Byabasthapika Sabha was held on 10.8.82 wherein peti-

tioner No. 2 was elected unanimously as its Mantri (General

Secretary) besides other office bearers. According to the

Bidhan of the Samiti as it stood in 1982, the Chief Minister

of Assam was the Ex-Officio Adhyaksha of the Samiti but as

at the time of holding of the first meeting the State of

Assam was under President's rule, consequently the' office

of Adhyaksha of the Samiti remained vacant as then there was

no Chief Minister of Assam. Petitioner No. 2 and other

office bearers of the Karyapalika of the Samiti held the

first meeting of the Karyapalika on 19.8.82 and the Karyapa-

lika was running the day-to-day administration and was

managing the affairs of the Samiti according to the Peti-

tioner very efficiently and diligently.

It is alleged that in early part of 1983 President's

rule was lifted from Assam and a Ministry headed by Shri

Hiteswar Saikia was installed in power in Assam. But in the

meantime the Samiti-in its meeting of the Byabasthapika

Sabha held on 17.7.83 passed a resolution for

167

amendment of the provisions of the Bidhan in the following

manner:

"That the words contained in Section 16 at

page 21 of the Bidhan to the effect that the

Chief Minister of Assam shall be the Ex-offi-

cio Adhyaksha of the Samiti be deleted. All

other such references contained in the Bidhan

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 6 of 12

be also accordingly amended. This amendment

shall come into force from today the 17.7.83."

That the said resolution was adopted in full compliance of

Section 30 of the Bidhan and all members present in the

meeting except one supported the resolution. This resolution

amending Section 16 of the Bidhan was passed considering the

difficulties that arose in the working of the Samiti by

keeping Chief Minister as the Adhyaksha of the Samiti.

According to the petitioner this amendment was sought neces-

sary to keep the Samiti away from politics. According to the

petitioner this amendment was introduced in accordance with

Section 30 of the Constitution (Bidban) of the Samiti which

provided:

"The Constitution of the Samiti may be amended

as follows:

(Ka) The proposal for amendment must reach the

head office within the month of January every

year.

(Kha) The amendment proposals will be sent for

information to all the members of the Byabas-

thapika Sabha from the Office.

(Ga) The amendment will be carried out by the

2/3rd members present."

According to the petitioner the procedure stated in this

Section of the Constitution was followed and as only one

person opposed the Constitution amendment was passed. It is

further alleged by the petitioner that as this amendment was

passed on 17.7.83 from this date the Chief Minister ceased

to be the Ex-officio President and since then according to

the petitioner he had nothing to do with the Samiti. The

post of Ex-officio President was abolished.

According to the petitioner that Respondent No. 4 after

passing of this amendment of the Bidhan on political consid-

eration passed an order dated 7.7.84 contained in the noti-

fication No. CMS 202/79/319

168

dated 7.7.84 whereby respondent No. 4 purportedly to act as

the Ex-Officio Adhyaksha of the Samiti declared as a state

of emergency in the Samiti in exercise of his powers con-

ferred under section 16 (Gha) of the Bidban and dissolved

the existing Karyapalika of the Samiti with immediate effect

and also constituted an ad hoc body with himself as Chairman

and five others as members to manage the affairs of the

Samiti. The petitioner has also filed a copy of this order.

It is alleged by the petitioner that under this order peti-

tioners Nos. 1 and 2 were asked to hand over the charges of

the management of the Samiti to the Ad hoc Committee. There-

upon the petitioner filed a suit being a Title Suit No. 110

of 1984 in the Court of the Assistant District Judge No. 1,

Gauhati for a declaration that the order dated 7.7.84 passed

by Respondent No. 4 declaring a state of emergency and by

which he dissolved the existing Karyapalika of the Samiti

and constituted an Ad hoc Committee, as void, illegal and

without jurisdiction and unenforceable against the petition-

er Society. As on the day on which he passed the Order he

was no longer the Adhyaksha as the Constitution has been

amended before that day. Petitioner also prayed for perma-

nent injunction restraining the respondent No. 4 and other

members of the Ad hoc committee, their agents and servants

from giving effect to the order. The petitioners also filed

an application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 of the Code of

Civil Procedure for the issuance of a temporary injunction.

It is alleged that the Assistant District Judge No. 1,

Gauhati by his order dated 19.7.84 issued a notice to the

defendants of that suit to show cause as to why a temporary

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 7 of 12

injunction as prayed for by the petitioners should not be

granted and fixed 13.8.84 as the date for showing cause. The

defendants filed their objection on 21.8.84 and the case was

fixed on 25.10.84 for consideration of the question of

issuing a temporary injunction.

When the matter was pending in the Court for considera-

tion of the question of temporary injunction the Governor of

Assam purported to act under Clause 1 of Article 230 of the

Constitution of India promulgated an Ordinance called the

Asom Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti (taking over of Management

and Control) Ordinance, 1984 and Section 1 sub-clause (ii)

of this Ordinance provided that the Ordinance shall extend

to all areas over which the Asom Rashtrabhasha Prachar

Samiti had its jurisdiction immediately before the commence-

ment of the Ordinance by a Notification No. EPG 57/84/16

issued under the signatures of Respondent No. 3 the Governor

of Assam fixed Ist of October, 1984 as the appointed day on

which the aforesaid Ordinance

169

came into force and Section 3 of the said Ordinance provided

that the Government may constitute a Board for the purposes

of taking over the management and control of the Samiti

consisting of not more than 9 members. According to the

petitioners this Ordinance was issued at the instance of the

Chief Minister which was unnecessary, unwarranted and un-

called for and was against the law laid down by the Consti-

tution Bench of this Court. Notification was issued on

7.7.84, Preamble of which reads as under:

"Whereas the Chief Minister of Assam in his

capacity as Ex-officio Adhyakasha of the Asom

R.B.P. Samiti is satisfied that deterioration

of the financial condition of the Samiti has

resulted in financial deadlock and the group

rivalry among the members, confrontation

between the management and the employees

culminating in institution of law suits,

hunger strikes by employees and chaos in

administration matters have resulted in admin-

istration deadlock."

The petitioners contended that what is stated in the Pream-

ble is incorrect and misconceived. The financial condition

of the Samiti had never deteriorated nor there were any

adverse remark by any auditor in the regular auditing of the

accounts of the Samiti. It is alleged that even other facts

leading to the taking over are wholly incorrect and mala-

cious.

Thereafter in 1984 Assam Legislative Assembly passed an

Act i.e. Act No. XXIII of 1984 replacing the Ordinance and

this Act received the assent of the Governor of Assam on

12.8.84 and was published in the Gazette Extraordinary dated

15.12.84. Under Section 3 of this Act the Assam Rashtrabha-

sha Prachar Samiti (taking over of Management and Control)

Act, 1984, the number of members constituting the Board was

raised to 13. By the provisions of this Act virtually the

Samiti which was a public body constituted by its members

having elected Byabasthapika Sabha and Karyapalika were

substituted by Board appointed by the Government and all the

functions, properties and affairs of the Samiti were taken

over by this Board and it is this action taken under the

Ordinance and the Act and ultimately the Act which is the

subject matter of challenge in this Writ Petition. As this

infringes the fundamental rights of the members who consti-

tute the Samiti their rights under Article 19(1)(c) and by

this process of taking over the Samiti has been deprived of

its assets and properties and even as alleged by the peti-

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 8 of 12

tioners Government has gone to the

170

extent of changing the name of the institution also. It is

alleged that after the passing of this Act the notification

under section 3 was issued which was EPG 57/34/75 dated

1.10.84 by which the Rashtrabhasha Prachar Board was consti-

tuted with respondents 11, 12 and 13 as members and by this

order all persons except respondent No. 12 who was not even

the member of the Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti were nominat-

ed.

The petitioners also alleged that in fact all this

happened because when the then Chief Minister of Assam

learnt about the amendment of the Constitution carried out

by Byabasthapika Sabha learnt that under the unamended

Bidhan was the Ex-officio Adhyaksha has been dropped by the

amendment of the Constitution that with mala fide intention

he started taking action in a manner in which he could

retain the control of the institution. First,he invoked the

Constitution itself by superseding the body by invoking

emergency provisions but when that was challenged by a suit,

an ordinance was brought taking over the Samiti as a whole

specially replacing the Byabasthapika Sabha and the Karyapa-

lika and later the ordinance was replaced by the Act and it

was contended that this all was the mala fide action of the

then Chief Minister of Assam and it is further contended

that unfortunately even after the new elections and a new

Government comes in power in Assam the Act which as its

title discloses was a temporary measure was continued at

perpetuity, and the Samiti is being run by nominated members

and the rights of the members of the Samiti under Article 19

has not only been restricted but has been taken away. It was

also contended that the history of the Samiti and the manner

in which it was formed and the persons who initially consti-

tuted the Samiti is of significance because its history and

historical background touches the ideological and sentimen-

tal aspirations of the people of Assam and the infringement

of this right to form an association under Article 19(1)(c)

is challenged as mala fide action motivated with selfish

political motivation. It is also contended that by the

operation of this Act those who have nothing to do with the

Samiti or its ideals and who were not even the members of

the Samiti have been nominated as the members of the Board

and they are supposed to run the affairs of the Samiti

whereas those who have contributed their heart and soul for

the ideals of the Samiti and who have put in long years of

hard labour to build up are deprived of their right to

manage the affairs of the Samiti. It is also contended that

even the assets and the properties of the Rashtrabhasha

Prachar Samiti is being mismanaged by nominated board as it

has no moral attachment to the ideals nor aptitude with the

work of the Samiti and the assets are being neutralized.

171

It was also contended that the heading of the Act as it

disclosed "An Act to provide for temporary transfer of the

management and control of the affairs of A.R.B.P.S. from the

Byabasthapika Sabha, Karyapalika and other holders of office

of the Assam Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti to a Board". This

heading of the Act, according to the learned counsel, is

just an eye wash as this heading shows that a temporary

arrangement was made because the management of the Samiti

was not in proper hands and the temporary arrangement was

only to improve the functioning of the society and ultimate-

ly it has to be handed over back to the elected body consti-

tuted under the Bidhan (constitution of the society regis-

tered under the Societies Registration Act) but in fact

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 9 of 12

after the passing of this Act in 1984 till today the re-

spondent State had no point of time, even thought of restor-

ing the body to the normal functioning after holding elec-

tion in accordance with the constitution of the Society. In

fact even during the hearing of this Writ Petition the

counsel appearing for the State was asked to intimate the

Court if even now the State knowing that this was a tempo-

rary measure is intending to restore the society back with

elected functionaries under the constitution. It was indi-

cated that the Government of Assam has no intentions even

now to end this temporary arrangement of the Samiti. It is

plain that although the Act talks of a temporary measure but

it is only an eye wash and by this process the State Govern-

ment intends to deprive the members of the society their

rights under Article 19(1)(c) for all times to come. In the

Act there is no provision providing for restoration of the

elected bodies which shows that the use of phrase 'tempo-

rary' was just an eye wash.

Learned counsel appearing for the State attempted to

justify the action however denying that it was not because

the constitution was amended and therefore the Chief Minis-

ter was annoyed but attempted to suggest that there was some

mismanagement of the society but in any event there was no

logic which could be suggested for such a permanent taking

over of the society registered discharging functions which

could not be said to be not ideal and which had started

working on some ideals which could not be said 'not for

public good'.

It is clear that now as the Act of 1984 and a Board

nominated or appointed under Section 3 of the Act is con-

trolling the affairs of the Society it is not necessary to

go into the orders passed by the Chief Minister invoking the

emergency powers although the facts which were alleged

clearly go to show that except that constitution was amended

and the Chief Minister was dropped from the place which he

used to enjoy before the amendment of the Bidhan (Constitu-

tion). There was

172

nothing serious and the Chief Minister who in fact had

ceased to be an Adhyaksha because of the constitutional

amendment took that action only to stick to the position and

the subsequent acts even if mala fide action is not clearly

established, as was alleged, we have no hesitation in ob-

serving that there appears to be no .justification as it is

clear that if the Act was enacted to meet a temporary con-

tingency for taking over of the management temporarily it

could have provided for the restoration of the elected body

in due course. It is significant that this Act is silent and

although as quoted above it talks of being temporary act, it

continues and even as stated above there appears to be no

intention of the State Government to restore the body back

to the elected bodies under the constitution of the society

itself. In these circumstances therefore there appears to be

no justification for all these actions starting from invok-

ing the emergency provisions till enacting the present Act

i.e. Asom Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti (taking over of the

Management and Control) Act, 1984.

Except the allegations of mala fide which are not admit-

ted, rest of the facts are not in dispute. The only sugges-

tion made in the counter is that there was mismanagement,

delay in examinations and results and it was because of that

that management only under this Act was taken over. But

neither in the counter nor during the course of arguments

anything could be said on behalf of the State for a perma-

nent justification of taking over of the management of the

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 10 of 12

Samiti depriving its members the right under Article

19(1)(c) of the Constitution of India.

In the counter it was contended that the Legislature of

the State was competent under Entry 25 of the List Ill

(concurrent list) Schedule 7 of the Constitution to enact

this law. Entry 25 List III reads:

"25. Education, including technical education,

medical education and universities, subject to

the provisions of Entries 63, 64, 65 and 66 of

List I; vocational and technical training of

labour."

The mere perusal of Entry 25 will reveal as to how difficult

it will be to stretch Entry 25 to mean the authority to

deprive an association of its right under Article 19(1)(c)

of the Constitution of India. It would have been different

situation, if the state felt that it wanted to do the same

thing what this Samiti was doing and further the acts of

education and for that purpose if it had taken steps to

start similar functions at the

173

state level probably the things would have been different.

But here we are simply concerned with the taking over of the

management of a registered society having large membership

and assets and properties following programme and policies

living to the ideals which could not be in any way chal-

lenged or adversely commented. Article 19(1)(c) of the

Constitution provides:

"19. Protection of certain rights regarding

freedom of speech, etc.--(1) All citizens

shall have the right

(a) xx xx xx

(b) xx xx xx

(c) to form associations or unions;

(d) xx xx xx

(e) xx xx xx

(f) xx xx xx

(g) xx xx xx"

The Constitution Bench of this Court had an occasion to

consider exactly a similar situation when a Hindi Sahitya

Sammelan was taken over first by a State law and later by an

Act of Parliament and this Court considering the question in

Damyanti Naranga v. The Union of India and Others, [1971] 3

SCR 840, observed:

"Further, under Section 7(2) of the Act, the

Governing Body of the new Sammelan is to

consist of such number of persons, not exceed-

ing 55, as the Central Government may from

time to time determine; and out of these, a

number not exceeding 7 are to be nominated by

the Central Government from among education-

ists of repute and eminent Hindi scholars.

These 7 nominees are to be chosen by the

Central Government."

In the present case the Government has taken the power

under Section 3 to appoint a Board and the Government can

appoint any one not connected with the Society at all to be

in the Board. In the Act which was being examined by the

Constitution Bench there were some restrictions on the

nominations of persons although the persons were to be

nominated by the Central Government but in the present Act

it is left to the discretion of the Government to appoint

the whole of the Board which will take place of not only

'the Managing Committee i.e. the Karyapalika but also the

place of Byabasthapika Sabha which normally used to be an

elected body. In this view the observation of

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 11 of 12

174

the Constitution Bench in Damyanti Naranga's case goes a

long way. It is observed in this judgment:

"This is clear interference with the right to

form an association which had been exercised

by the members of the Society by informing the

Society with its Constitution, under which

they were members and future members could

only come in as a result of their choice by

being elected by their working Committee."

It is therefore clear that so far as the present case is

concerned it is not only that the new members are intro-

duced, not only that the complete control is left to the

Board to be nominated by the Government, about the persons

no norms have been laid down, the person so nominated could

be anyone and no control is kept to those who formed the

Society, those who had a right to form an association will

be kept away and the Society shall be run by group of per-

sons nominated by the Government in accordance with Section

3. It is therefore clear that what was done in the Sammelan

Acts which were under examination in the Constitution Bench

judgment referred to above, much more has been done in this

case. In this case virtually the right of association has

been taken away and not only that it is a sort of depriva-

tion for all times as it is not even provided that this

Board may be an interim Board and thereafter a proper Board

will be elected but here this Board will continue to control

and manage the affairs of the Society. In the Constitution

Bench case their Lordships considered the scope of Article

19(1)(c) in the context of what was contemplated in that Act

and observed:

"The right to form an association, in our

opinion, necessarily implies that the persons

forming the Association have also the right to

continue to be associated with only those whom

they voluntarily admit in the Association. Any

law, by which members are introduced in the

voluntary Association without any option being

given to the members to keep them out, or any

law which takes away the membership of those

who have voluntarily joined it, will be a law

violating the right to form an association. If

we were to accept the submission that the

right guaranteed by Art. 19(1)(c) is confined

to the initial stage of forming an Association

and does not protect the right to continue the

Association with the membership either chosen

by the founders or regulated by rules made by

the Association

175

itself, the right would be meaningless be-

cause, as soon as an Association is formed, a

law may be passed interfering with its compo-

sition, so that the Association formed may not

be able to function at all. The right can be

effective only if it is held to include within

it the right to continue the Association with

its composition as voluntarily agreed upon by

the persons forming the association."

It is therefore clear that even on the basis of the pro-

nouncement of the Constitution Bench, the Act and the noti-

fication issued under this Act taking over the management of

the Rashtrabhasha Prachar Samiti could not be accepted to be

in accordance with the Constitution.

Apart from this it is also clear that although when the

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 12 of 12

Act talks of a temporary measure in fact, the Act does not

provide for as to how when the temporary measures comes to

an end the elected Byabasthapika Sabha and Karyapalika would

be restored. It is not only that but it is also apparent

that since 1984 when this Act was passed and a notification

appointing a Board was issued, the Government has not chosen

to take any steps to restore the Society back to its elected

authorities and office bearers, inspite of the fact that we

indicated and asked the counsel appearing for the State to

let us know even if now the State is intending to restore it

back to the Society but unfortunately it appears that with-

out considering the question and its constitutional aspects

the reply came that the State has no desire to restore the

Samiti and therefore we are left with no option but to

decide and decide upholding the Constitution and the right

of association conferred under Article 19(1)(c) of the

Constitution. We therefore allow these writ petitions, set

aside the notification issued under the Act enacted by the

Assam Legislature holding that the Act itself is ultra vires

of the Constitution. We therefore also quash the notifica-

tion issued under Section 3 of the Act as ultra vires by

which a Board was nominated to replace the Karyapalika and

Byabasthapika Sabha.

At the time when this Board was constituted under Sec-

tion 3 the Karyapalika and Byabasthapika Sabha duly elected

were functioning and they had sufficient time to go on and

in this view of the matter we further direct that the Karya-

palika and Byabasthapika Sabha which were in existence in

1984 when initially the action under the emergency provi-

sions was taken followed by the notification under the

Ordinance and the Act shall be restored back and they shall

take over the management of the Samiti from the Board imme-

diately but it is made clear that the Karyapalika and Bya-

basthapika Sabha which were

176

functioning in 1984 and which we are restoring will within

six months from the date of this Order will hold proper

elections in accordance with the Constitution to elect a

Byabasthapika and Karyapalika. This is necessary because the

period of the Karyapalika and Byabasthapika Sabha which was

functioning in 1984 has come to an end although from 1984

till today they were not allowed to function. It is further

directed that the authorities, officers appointed by the

Board or the State Government shall restore back all assets

and properties of the Samiti to the Karyapalika which will

be restored immediately after the passing of this Order. The

petitioners shall also be entitled to costs of this peti-

tion. Costs quantified at Rs. 10,000.

R.N.J. Petition

allowed.

177

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter