As per case facts, the complainant invested substantial money with the petitioners, believing it was for land purchase and development promising significant returns. However, the complainant alleged that no land ...
could be inferred. It is not
alleged that the offer of distributorship was made without any intention
of conferring it or that the appellants knew, when the agreement was
drawn up or when any of the six remittances was received, that they
would not or could not supply the goods. It is not asserted that the
distributorship had already been conferred upon another or that any
representation was made as to an existing fact false to the knowledge of
the maker. Nor is it stated when, where, in whose presence and in what
terms the deceitful representation was made, or which of the five named
persons made it. The word “cheated” and the expression “I got
deceived” although appear in the information as conclusions but are
bereft of the facts from which these conclusions might be drawn and
thus the offence would not be made out.
18. As regards the offence punishable under Section 316(2) of the
BNS, the difficulty is more basic. Criminal breach of trust presupposes
entrustment, which requires that the beneficial interest in the property
remain with the person handing it over, the recipient taking no more
than custody or dominion for the benefit of another. Money paid to a
supplier as the price of goods, or in advance of their supply, passes to
the supplier as his own; he holds it as consideration under a contract,
and is neither trustee nor bailee of it. If he takes the money and does
not deliver, he is in breach of his contract but has not committed a
breach of trust, because there was no trust.
23. Taking the allegations in the first information report at their face
value and accepting them in their entirety, this Court is satisfied that the
ingredients of the offence punishable under Section 318(4) of the BNS
are not made out, no fact being alleged from which a dishonest or
fraudulent intention at the inception could be inferred; and that the
ingredients of the offence punishable under Section 316(2) BNS are not
made out, entrustment not being alleged at all. The matter falls within
the first of the categories enumerated in Bhajan Lal (supra) as stated
above. To permit the proceeding to continue would be to permit a
dispute arising from a written commercial contract, to be pursued
through the machinery of the criminal law, and that would be an abuse
of the process of the court.”
This Court, in the case of Delhi Race Club, while explaining the
difference between the offences of criminal breach of trust and
cheating, observed that to constitute the offence of cheating, it has to be
sufficiently proved that the offender fraudulently or dishonestly induced
a person by deceiving him to deliver any property and that the said
dishonest intention was from the very inception of the transaction.
Whereas, in the case of criminal breach of trust, what is to be proved is
the act of dishonest misappropriation of the property which the offender
was legally entrusted with, but illegally misappropriated or converted it
to his own use against the terms of the contract. Thus, in view of the
aforesaid fundamental distinction between the offences of criminal
breach of trust and cheating, this Court in the abovementioned case
observed that both the offences cannot co-exist simultaneously. On a
careful perusal of both the provisions as well as the aforesaid dictum of
this Court, we find that with regard to the same property and on the
same set of facts, the offences of criminal breach of trust and cheating
cannot be sustained as against the accused. We say so because, on one
hand, the prosecution alleges that the refundable security deposit was
lawfully entrusted to the accused by the complainant, which the accused
continued to retain even after the project had failed and after the
disputed property was sold by them to a third party. On the other hand,
it is also alleged that the accused cheated the complainant by inducing
him to part with Rs.3,00,00,000/- (Rupees three crore) as refundable
security based on a false representation that the disputed property was
free from all encumbrances. In other words, the allegation by the
prosecution is that the accused was entrusted with the refundable
security deposit, which he later on dishonestly misappropriated and the
allegation that the accused, with a dishonest intention, induced the
complainant to part with the refundable security deposit based on a
false representation, are not tenable on the same substratum of facts. If
there was a lawful entrustment of Rs.3,00,00,000/- (Rupees three crore)
to the accused under the Joint Development Agreement, it cannot be a
case of cheating and if so, the non-return of the amount by the accused
as the plan sanction was not granted is not a case of criminal breach of
trust. The dispute between the parties is essentially civil in nature. The
subsequent sale of the subject property by the accused to a third party
may give rise to a cause of action on the civil side to the complainant
but not a case of cheating or criminal breach of trust as the said act of
sale per se is not a criminal act.
“20. Apart from the infirmities noted in the impugned order, we are also
of the view that this is not a fit case for grant of anticipatory bail. The
allegations, as borne out from the record, pertain to an economic
offence involving a substantial amount, coupled with assertions of
deliberate and premeditated conduct on the part of Respondent No. 2
and her son in inducing the complainant to part with a significant
portion of the consideration and thereafter transferring the property to
a third party. The material on record also indicates that Respondent No.
2 and her son were not readily available during the course of
investigation and coercive steps were required to secure their presence.
Having regard to the nature of the allegations, the magnitude of the
transaction, the antecedents attributed to Respondent No. 2, and the
requirements of a fair and effective investigation, we are of the
considered view that the grant of anticipatory bail to Respondent No. 2
at this stage is not warranted.”
“12. From the aforesaid analysis of law on the subject, it is clear that
offences under Section 138 of the NI Act and Section 420 of IPC are
distinct from each other because ingredients of the two offences are
different. While in a prosecution under Section 138 of NI Act, fraudulent
or dishonest intention at the time of issuance of cheque need not be
proved but in a prosecution under Section 420 of IPC, such intention is
an important ingredient to be established. For proving offence
under Section 138 of NI Act, it has to be established that the cheque has
been issued by the accused to discharge a legally enforceable debt or
liability and the same has been dishonoured for insufficiency of funds
etc. and despite receipt of statutory notice of demand, the accused has
failed to pay the amount of cheque within the stipulated time. It is only
when accused fails to make the payment within the stipulated time upon
receipt of notice of demand that the offence under Section 138 of NI Act
is made out against an accused. In the case of prosecution for the
charge under Section 420 of IPC, these ingredients need not be proved
by the prosecution. However, it has to be proved by prosecution that at
the very inception i.e. at the time of issuance of the cheque by the
accused, he had a dishonest intention. Thus, offence under Section
420 of IPC is made out at the time of issuance of the cheque itself which
is not the case with offence under Section 138 of NI Act. Therefore, the
two offences are distinct from each other and the principle of double
jeopardy or rule of estoppel does not come into play.”
27. In the result, we hold that (i) even-after introduction of Section
138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, prosecution under Section
420 IPC is maintainable in case of dishonour of cheques or post-dated
cheques issued towards payment of price of the goods purchased or
hand loan taken, or in discharge of an antecedent debt or towards
payment of goods supplier, earlier, if the charge-sheet contains an
allegation that the accused had dishonest intention not to pay even at
the time of issuance of the cheque, and the act of issuing the cheque,
which was dishonoured, caused damage to his mind, body or
reputation, (ii) private complaint or FIR alleging offence under Section
420 IPC for dishonour of cheques or post-dated cheques cannot be
quashed under Section 482 Cr.PC if the averments in the complaint
show that the accused had, with a dishonest intention and to cause
damage to his mind, body or reputation, issued the cheque which was
not honoured. Point No.2 is answered accordingly.
The Punjab and Haryana High Court recently delivered a crucial judgment concerning Anticipatory Bail for Economic Offences in a case involving complex and Disputed Land Transactions. This significant ruling, CRM-M-51159-2026 (O&M), dated September 18, 2026, is now available on CaseOn, highlighting the court's stringent approach to pre-arrest bail applications where allegations of fraud and forgery are substantial.
The case revolves around an FIR (No.174 dated 24.08.2026) filed against Atul Mehta (petitioner No.1) and Saloni Mehta (petitioner No.2), a married couple. The complainant alleged that Atul Mehta, representing himself as a Director of AGI Infra Limited, induced him to invest substantial amounts of money for purchasing land to develop a residential colony. The promise was significant profits. The complainant transferred approximately Rs. 13.35 Crores through RTGS to the petitioners' bank accounts, believing the money would be invested in land. However, no land was ever purchased or transferred in his name. The complainant claimed a total of Rs. 16.81 Crores was due, including interest.
Crucially, the complainant alleged that the petitioners issued multiple cheques (21 by Atul Mehta, 1 for Rs. 1.50 Crore by Saloni Mehta) which bore forged or mismatched signatures compared to their bank records. When confronted, Atul Mehta reportedly re-signed some cheques with matching signatures. The police investigation revealed that Saloni Mehta's cheque for Rs. 1.50 Crore had mismatched signatures, and her account had a balance of only Rs. 60,308.38 at the time.
The petitioners, on the other hand, contended that the transactions were purely in the nature of a loan with interest, which they had been regularly paying. They presented their version of an agreement dated 27.12.2022, which they claimed supported their position. They also argued that the cheques issued were genuine post-dated instruments, and any issue with them should be addressed under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
The primary legal question before the High Court was whether the petitioners, Atul Mehta and Saloni Mehta, were entitled to anticipatory bail in a case involving serious allegations of cheating, criminal breach of trust, forgery, and criminal conspiracy, despite their claim that the dispute was civil in nature and a remedy under the Negotiable Instruments Act was available.
The Court considered the application for anticipatory bail under Section 482 of BNSS, 2023 (formerly Section 438 Cr.P.C.), for offences registered under Sections 406, 420, 120-B, 465, 467, 468, and 471 of IPC (corresponding to Sections 316(2), 318(4), 61(2), 336(2), 338, 336(3), 340(2) of BNS, 2023). Key legal principles guiding the court's decision included:
The petitioners cited Parag Kishore Satoskar and others vs. State of Jharkhand and another, G. Saminathan and another vs. The State, and Susheel Kumar vs. The State of Haryana and another to argue that their dispute was civil and lacked the ingredients for criminal offences. The complainant and State, however, distinguished these cases, arguing the presence of crucial facts establishing criminal intent.
The petitioners vehemently argued that the entire affair was a civil dispute concerning a loan transaction, where interest payments were regularly made. They presented loan agreements and bank statements to support this. They also highlighted that the cheques issued were post-dated, and the complainant had an adequate remedy under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act for any dishonoured cheques. They disputed the allegations of forgery, claiming their signatures were genuine, and asserted that the documents relied upon by the complainant were contested and their authenticity required investigation during trial.
The complainant and the State strongly opposed the anticipatory bail, emphasizing the serious nature of the allegations, which extended beyond a simple recovery of money. They pointed to the substantial amounts involved (over Rs. 13 Crores transferred), the specific purpose of purchasing land as alleged by the complainant, and the petitioners' failure to deliver on this promise. Crucially, the State presented bank opinions confirming mismatched signatures on cheques issued by both petitioners, and highlighted Saloni Mehta's extremely low bank balance against a high-value cheque. The State also brought to light Atul Mehta's prior antecedents, including multiple cases under Section 138 of the NI Act and instances of bailable warrants due to non-appearance, which raised serious questions about his bona fides. They asserted that custodial interrogation was essential to unravel the complete financial trail, determine the actual nature of the transactions, and investigate the disputed agreements and allegations of forgery.
The High Court meticulously analyzed the submissions from both sides. It noted that the dispute was far from a "simple recovery of money," involving allegations of inducement, specific purpose of funds (land purchase), and a substantial financial commitment over several years. The court observed the presence of two competing versions of a crucial agreement dated 27.12.2022, which required proper verification and could not be resolved at the anticipatory bail stage.
The allegations of mismatched signatures on cheques issued by both petitioners were deemed highly significant. The bank's opinions confirmed these discrepancies, and the fact that Atul Mehta reportedly re-signed some cheques further necessitated investigation into whether the original signatures were deliberately different and under what circumstances they were re-signed. The court reiterated that the availability of a remedy under Section 138 of the NI Act does not automatically negate criminal charges like cheating and forgery, especially when the allegations point to a dishonest intention from the very inception of the transactions.
The court found the petitioners' reliance on judgments like Parag Kishore Satoskar, G. Saminathan, and Susheel Kumar to be inapplicable, as the current FIR clearly contained facts suggesting a dishonest intention at the outset and involved allegations that went beyond mere contractual breach or civil recovery. It was highlighted that the investigation needed to delve into the actual nature of the transactions, the genuineness of the agreements, the authenticity of signatures, and the movement of funds, requiring more than just documentary evidence.
For legal professionals seeking swift insights into such nuanced rulings, CaseOn.in's 2-minute audio briefs provide an invaluable tool, allowing for quick comprehension of the court's reasoning and key takeaways from these specific judgments without sifting through lengthy texts.
Considering the seriousness of the allegations, the substantial amounts involved, the complex nature of financial dealings, the disputed documents, the allegations of forgery, and Atul Mehta's prior criminal antecedents, the Court concluded that custodial interrogation of both petitioners was indispensable for a fair and effective investigation.
Based on the thorough analysis, the Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissed the anticipatory bail petition (CRM-M-51159-2026 (O&M)). The court found that the petitioners did not deserve the extraordinary concession of anticipatory bail given the gravity of the charges and the imperative need for custodial interrogation to unearth the full truth behind the complex web of alleged fraud and forgery.
This judgment serves as a critical reminder of the High Courts' stance on granting anticipatory bail in cases involving substantial economic offences, especially where allegations of forgery and dishonest intention at the inception are present. For lawyers, it underscores the importance of a robust factual matrix and convincing arguments to establish the "civil nature" of a dispute when seeking pre-arrest bail. For law students, it provides an excellent case study on the interplay between the Indian Penal Code (now Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita - BNS) and the Negotiable Instruments Act, the principles governing anticipatory bail, and the circumstances under which courts deem custodial interrogation necessary. It highlights that the mere existence of a civil remedy does not automatically preclude criminal proceedings, particularly when criminal intent is evident.
Please note that all information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers are advised to consult with a qualified legal professional for advice pertaining to their specific circumstances.
Legal Notes
Add a Note....