Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, Registration Act, property rights, adoption deed, vested property, unregistered document, Section 12, Section 17, Section 49, Supreme Court
0  10 Nov, 1989
Listen in 01:58 mins | Read in 7:00 mins
EN
HI

Dinaji and Ors. Vs. Daddi and Ors.

  Supreme Court Of India Civil Appeal /2116/1972
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, the appellants filed a suit for injunction and possession based on a registered sale deed from a widow. The widow had previously adopted a son and ...

Bench

Applied Acts & Sections

No Acts & Articles mentioned in this case

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 4

PETITIONER:

DINAJI AND ORS.

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

DADDI AND ORS.

DATE OF JUDGMENT10/11/1989

BENCH:

OZA, G.L. (J)

BENCH:

OZA, G.L. (J)

FATHIMA BEEVI, M. (J)

CITATION:

1990 AIR 1153 1989 SCR Supl. (2) 144

1990 SCC (1) 1 JT 1989 (4) 434

1989 SCALE (2)1178

ACT:

Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956: Sections 12,

Proviso (c) and 13--Hindu Widow--Adopting son--Whether

deprived of her rights in husband's property.

Registration Act, 1908: Sections 17(1)(b) and

49---Document creating right in adopted son to immovable

property--Divesting mother of property--Whether requires

registration--Unregistered document-Admissibility of.

HEADNOTE:

In a suit for injunction and possession of the suit

property, on the basis of a registered sale deed executed by

the widow of the owner of the property, filed by the appel-

lants, the question of admissibility of an unregistered

document, said to be Deed of Adoption, by which the widow

conferred on the adopted son rights in her property and

relinquished her right to alienate any part of the property,

came up for consideration.

The trial court accepted the document only in proof of

adoption, and decreed the suit. The first appellate court

set aside the decree. On appeal. the High Court maintained

lower appellate court's judgment and held that after execut-

ing the deed of adoption, the widow had no right left in the

property and, therefore, a transfer executed by her would

not confer any title on the appellants.

Aggrieved, the appellants filed an appeal, by special

leave, in this Court contending that as the deed 'would be

hit by section 17(1)(b) read with section 49 of the Indian

Registration Act, regarding relinquishment or conferment of

right on the adopted son, the High Court was not right in

relying on this clause to come to the conclusion that the

widow had no right to transfer the property in favour of the

appellants.

Allowing the appeal, the Court,

HELD: 1. Proviso (c) Section 12 of the Hindu Adoptions

and Maintenance Act, 1956, departs from the Hindu General

Law and

145

makes it clear, that the adopted child shall not divest any

person of any estate which has vested in him or her before

the adoption.

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 4

Section 13 enacts that when the parties intend to limit

the operation of proviso (c) to Section 12, it is open to

them by an agreement to the contrary. [148C]

In the instant case, the widow was the limited owner of

the property after the death of her husband. But after Hindu

Succession Act, 1956, came into force, she has become an

absolute owner. Therefore, the property of her husband

vested in her. Merely by adopting a child, she could not be

deprived of any of her rights in the property. The adoption

would come into play and the adopted child could get the

rights for which he is entitled, after her death. [147G-H]

2. Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act, 1908 clear-

ly provides that a document, where any right in movable

property is either assigned or extinguished, will require

registration. [148D]

In the instant case, that part of the deed which refers

to creation of an immediate right in the adopted son and

divesting of the right of the adoptive mother in the proper-

ty will squarely fail within the ambit of Section 17(1)(b)

and, therefore, under Section 49 of the Registration Act,

this could not be admitted if it is not a registered docu-

ment. [148E]

JUDGMENT:

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2116 of

1972.

From the Judgment and Order dated 1.2.1971 of the Madhya

Pradesh High Court at Jabalpur in S.A. 517 of 1969.

S.P. Singh for the Appellants.

Uday U. Lalit and A.G. Ratnaparkhi for the Respondents.

The Order of the Court was delivered by

OZA, J. This appeal arises out of the Judgment dated

1.2.1971 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Second

Appeal No. 5 17/69, wherein the learned Judge of the High

Court dismissed the Second Appeal filed by the present

appellant.

146

The present appellant filed a suit for injunction and

possession on the basis of a registered sale deed dated

28.4.66 executed by Smt. Yashoda Bai in his favour with

respect to immovable property including agricultural lands

and houses.

The property originally belonged to her husband and

after his death she got it as a limited owner and by influx

of time and by coming into force of the Hindu Succession

Act, she acquired the rights of an absolute owner. On

28.4.63, she adopted respondent Nain Singh as her son and

executed a document said to be the Deed of Adoption. This

document is not a registered document and the trial court

admitted it in evidence in proof of adoption. This document,

in addition to recital of the factum of adoption in presence

of Panchayat in accordance with the custom of the Community

also contained a covenant wherein she had stated that after

this deed of adoption her adopted son will be entitled

(Hakdar) to the whole property including movable and immova-

ble and she will have no right to alienate any part of the

property after this deed of adoption.

The trial court decreed the suit. The first appellate

court dismissed the suit setting aside the decree passed by

the trial court. The learned judge of the High Court consid-

ering the impact of S. 12 of the Hindu Adoptions and Mainte-

nance Act rightly held that the adopted son, in view of the

proviso (C) to S. 12, will only be entitled to property

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 4

after the death of the adoptive mother but the learned judge

felt that the further covenant in the adoption deed deprived

her of that right and conferred that right on the adopted

son, on this basis the learned judge of the High Court came

to the conclusion that the widow after executing this deed

of adoption had no right left in the property and therefore

a transfer executed by her will not confer any title on the

plaintiff. It is on this basis that the High Court main-

tained the Judgment of the lower appellate court dismissing

the suit of the plaintiffappellant. Against this, by Special

leave, this appeal has come to this Court.

Learned counsel for the appellant contended that the

document which is described as a deed of adoption, in sub-

stance, is in two parts. One recites the facturn of adoption

and the second contains the covenant wherein she has relin-

quished her rights in the property and conferred rights on

adopted son. According to the learned Counsel, so far as it

refers to adoption, the courts below were right in admitting

the document as an evidence of adoption but so far as it

refers to a deed of relinquishment or conferment of right on

the adopted son, will be hit

147

by S. 17(1)(b) read with S. 49 of the Indian Registration

Act and, therefore, the High Court was not right in relying

on this clause to come to the conclusion that the widow Smt.

Yashoda Bai had no right to transfer the property in favour

of plaintiff-appellant.

Section 12 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act

reads as follows:

"12. Effects of adoption: An adopted child

shall be deemed to be the child of his or her

adoptive father of mother for all purposes

with effect from the date of the adoption and

from such date all the ties of the child in

the family of his or her birth shall be deemed

to be served and replaced by those created by

the adoption in the adoptive family:

Provided that:

(a) the child cannot marry any person whom he

or she could not have married if he or she had

continued in the family of his or her birth:

(b) any property which vested in the adopted

child before the adoption shall continue to

vest in such person subject to the obliga-

tions, if any, attaching to the ownership of

such property, including the obligation to

maintain relatives in the family of his or her

birth:

(c) the adopted child shall not divest any

person of any estate which vested in him or

her before the adoption."

Proviso (C) of this Section departs from the Hindu

General Law and makes it clear that the adopted child shall

not divest any person of any estate which has vested in him

on her before the adoption. It is clear that in the present

case, Smt. Yashoda Bai who was the limited owner of the

property after the death of her husband and after Hindu

Succession Act came into force, has become an absolute owner

and therefore the property of her husband vested in her and

therefore merely by adopting a child she could not be de-

prived of any of her rights in the property. The adoption

would come into play and the adopted child could get the

rights for which he is entitled after her

148

death as is clear from the Scheme of S. 12 proviso (C).

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 4

S. 13 of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act reads:

13. Right of adoptive parents to dispose of

their properties:

Subject to any agreement to the contrary, an

adoption does not deprive the adoptive father

or mother of the power to dispose of his or

her property by transfer inter vivos or by

will.

This Section enacts that when the parties intend to

limit the operation of proviso (C) to S. 12, it is open to

them by an agreement and it appears that what she included

in the present deed of adoption was an agreement to the

contrary as contemplated in S. 13 of the Hindu Additions and

Maintenance Act.

Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act clearly pro-

vides that such a document where any right in movable

property is either assigned or extinguished will require

registration. It could not be disputed that this part of the

deed which refers to creation of an immediate right in the

adopted son and the divesting of the right of the adoptive

mother in the property will squarely fall within the ambit

of S. 17(1)(b) and therefore under S. 49 of the Registration

Act, this could not be admitted if it is not a registered

document. Unfortunately, the Hon'ble Judge of the High Court

did not notice this aspect of the matter and felt that what

could not be done because of the proviso (c) to S. 12 has

been specifically provided in the document itself but this

part of the document could not be read in evidence as it

could not be admitted. In view of this, the appeal is al-

lowed. The Judgments of the High Court and that of the lower

appellate Court are set aside and that of the trial court is

restored. In view of these special circumstances, there is

no order as to costs.

N.P.V. Appeal allowed.

149

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter