service law, administrative review, Uttar Pradesh
0  23 Mar, 1990
Listen in 01:28 mins | Read in 4:00 mins
EN
HI

Krishna Sahai & Ors. Vs. State of U.P. & Ors.

  Supreme Court Of India Civil Appeal /6729/1983
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, appellants filed writ petitions in the High Court, which the State resisted citing an alternative remedy before the U.P. Public Services Tribunal (under U.P. Act 17 ...

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 3

PETITIONER:

KRISHNA SAHAI & ORS.

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

STATE OF U.P. & ORS.

DATE OF JUDGMENT23/03/1990

BENCH:

MISRA RANGNATH

BENCH:

MISRA RANGNATH

PUNCHHI, M.M.

RAMASWAMY, K.

CITATION:

1990 AIR 1137 1990 SCR (2) 168

1990 SCC (2) 673 JT 1990 (2) 172

1990 SCALE (1)802

ACT:

U.P. Public Services Tribunal Act, 1976.' Remedy before

Services Tribunal not availed--Writ petition before High

Court--Whether maintainable--Desirability of setting up

Tribunal under the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 ex-

pressed.

HEADNOTE:

The writ petitions preferred by the appellants before

the High Court were sought to be resisted by the State on

the preliminary objection that they had an alternative

remedy available before the Public Services Tribunal set up

under the U.P. Act 17 of 1976. The appellants took the plea

that filing of a claim in the Tribunal was not an adequate

alternate relief inasmuch as it did not have power to make

any interim order. The High Court declined to exercise its

power under Art. 226 of the Constitution.

Remitting the case to the Public Services Tribunal for

disposal on merits, the Court,

HELD: 1. The Uttar Pradesh Public Services Tribunal

which functions under a State Act does not have power to

make any interim order. Under the Administrative Tribunals

Act, 1985. which is a legislation in terms of Art. 323-A of

the Constitution, the jurisdiction of the High Court in

regard to service matter is intended to be taken away and

vested in the Tribunal. It is open to the State to also set

up Tribunals for adjudication of service disputes in regard

to its employees. Several States have already set up their

own Tribunals under that Act. [170B, 169H, 170C]

S.P. Sampath Kumar v. Union of India & Ors., [1987] 1

SCC 124, referred to.

2. It is commended to the State to consider the feasi-

bility of setting up of an appropriate tribunal under the

Central Act in place of the Services Tribunal so that apart

from the fact that there would be uniformity in the matter

of adjudication the High Court would not be burdened with

service litigations and the Tribunal with plenary powers

169

can function to the satisfaction of everyone. [1701)]

3. In case the existing Services Tribunal is continued

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 3

the State should change its manning so that a sufficient

number of people qualified in Law could be on the Tribunal

to ensure adequate dispensation of justice, and plan out

diversification of the location of the Benches for the

Tribunal. [170E-G]

JUDGMENT:

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 6729 of

1983.

From the Judgment and Order dated 22.3.1983 of the

Allahabad High Court in C.M.W.P. No. 7787 of 1979.

Shankar Ghosh, R.K. Jain, R.B. Mehrotra, Ms. Abha Shar-

ma, Ms. Sangita Tripathi Mandal, R.P. Singh, Harish N.

Salve, D.K. Garg, Gopal Subramanium, Mrs. Shobha Dikshit,

C.P. Pandey, S.K. Sabharwal, M.P. Sarawala, R.S. Sodhi, D.D.

Gupta, Shakil Ahmed Syed, K.R.R. Pillai, M.A. Firoz, R.D.

Upadhyay, U.S. Prasad and C.M. Nayar for the appearing

parties.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

RANGANATH MISRA, J. This appeal by special leave was

heard along with Civil Appeals Nos. 776 of 1984 and 4356 of

1986. Those two appeals were disposed of by a common judg-

ment dated March 1, 1990, by remitting the dispute forming

the subject-matter of those appeals to the U.P. Public

Services Tribunal for disposal on merit and judgment was

reserved in this appeal as we were of the view that certain

relevant aspects required notice and we should commend to

the U.P. State to bring its Services Tribunal at par with

the State Administrative Tribunals set up under the Central

Administrative Tribunals Act of 1985.

So far as the merits of the case go, we are of the view

that it should also be remitted for disposal by the Services

Tribunal and we direct that the Tribunal shall dispose of

the matter in accordance with its rules by the end of Sep-

tember, 1990.

The Administrative Tribunals Act of 1985 is a legisla-

tion in terms of Art. 323A of the Constitution. By setting

up a Tribunal under that Act for resolution of service

disputes, the jurisdiction of the High Court in regard to

such matters is intended to be taken away and under

170

the scheme of that Act, the jurisdiction of the High Court

in regard to service disputes is intended to be vested in

the Tribunal. That is the view expressed by the Constitution

Bench of this Court in S.P. Sampath Kurnar v. Union of India

& Ors., [1987] 1 SCC 124.

The Uttar Pradesh Public Services Tribunal which func-

tions under a different State Act does not have power to

make any interim order. In fact, exercise of that power is

denied to the Tribunal by specific provision. That is why

the appellants had taken up the plea before the High Court

that filing of a claim in the Tribunal was not an adequate

alternate relief. In such setting it had been canvassed that

the High Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution was not

debarred from entertaining writ petitions. Under the Admin-

istrative Tribunals Act, it is open to the State to also set

up Tribunals for adjudication of service disputes in regard

to employees of the State. Several States have already set

up their own Tribunals. We commend to the State of Uttar

Pradesh to consider the feasibility of setting up of an

appropriate tribunal under the Central Act in place of the

Services Tribunal functioning at present so that apart from

the fact that there would be uniformity in the matter of

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 3

adjudication of service disputes, the High Court would not

be burdened with service litigations and the Tribunal with

plenary powers can function to the satisfaction of everyone.

case the Uttar Pradesh Services Tribunal set up under the

U.P. No. 17 of 1976 is continued, it would be appropriate

for the State of Uttar Pradesh to change its manning and a

sufficient number of people qualified in Law should be on

the Tribunal to ensure adequate dispensation of justice and

to maintain judicial temper in the functioning of the Tribu-

nal. We find that in Writ Petition No. 373 of 1989 relating

to the self-same question a Bench of this Court has issued

notice wherein the proposal for additional Benches at places

like Allahabad, Meerut and Agra apart from the seat at

Lucknow have been asked to be considered. We are of the view

that if the Services Tribunal is to continue, it is neces-

sary that the State of Uttar Pradesh should plan out immedi-

ately diversification of the location of the Benches for the

Tribunal so that service disputes from all over the State

are not required to be filed only at Lucknow and on account

of a single tribunal disputes would not pile up without

disposal.

There would be no order as to costs.

P.S.S. Appeal disposed of.

171

Reference cases

Description

Supreme Court on Service Tribunals: Navigating Remedies Under the U.P. Public Services Tribunal Act and Administrative Tribunals Act 1985

The landmark decision in Krishna Sahai & Ors. v. State of U.P. & Ors., which critically examined the efficacy of the U.P. Public Services Tribunal Act, 1976, versus the robust framework of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, stands as a pivotal ruling in Indian administrative law. This significant judgment, delivered on March 23, 1990, by a bench comprising Justices Ranganath Misra, M.M. Punchhi, and K. Ramaswamy, continues to be a crucial reference point for understanding the jurisdiction of service tribunals and is readily available for analysis on CaseOn.in.

Case Background

The case originated from writ petitions filed by the appellants in the High Court. These petitions challenged certain service-related matters. The State of Uttar Pradesh, however, raised a preliminary objection, arguing that the appellants had an alternative remedy available through the Public Services Tribunal established under the U.P. Act 17 of 1976. The appellants countered this by asserting that filing a claim before the State Tribunal was not an adequate alternative, primarily because it lacked the power to issue interim orders. The High Court ultimately declined to exercise its extraordinary powers under Article 226 of the Constitution, directing the petitioners to exhaust the alternative remedy.

The Core Issue: Alternative Remedy vs. Tribunal Powers

The primary issues before the Supreme Court were:

  • Whether a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is maintainable when an alternative remedy exists before a State-specific Service Tribunal (like the one under the U.P. Public Services Tribunal Act, 1976) that lacks the power to grant interim orders.
  • What is the recommended legal and administrative framework for adjudicating service disputes for state employees, particularly in light of the central Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985?

Legal Framework and Key Rulings

The Supreme Court deliberated on the interplay between the U.P. Public Services Tribunal Act, 1976, and the central Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985.

U.P. Public Services Tribunal Act, 1976

This State Act established tribunals to resolve service disputes involving Uttar Pradesh government employees. However, a critical deficiency identified by the appellants, and later acknowledged by the Supreme Court, was its inability to issue interim orders, which is often crucial for protecting litigants' interests during the pendency of a case.

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985

Enacted under Article 323A of the Constitution, this Central Act aimed to provide a comprehensive framework for adjudicating service disputes, effectively transferring the jurisdiction over such matters from High Courts to specialized tribunals. The Supreme Court referenced its earlier Constitution Bench decision in S.P. Sampath Kumar v. Union of India & Ors., [1987] 1 SCC 124, which affirmed this legislative intent, highlighting that tribunals under this Act are intended to possess plenary powers, thereby alleviating the High Courts' burden.

For legal professionals analyzing complex rulings like Krishna Sahai, CaseOn.in’s 2-minute audio briefs offer an invaluable resource, allowing for quick comprehension of the core arguments and the Supreme Court’s rationale in these specific service law judgments.

Supreme Court's Analysis and Recommendations

The Supreme Court, while remitting the specific case back to the U.P. Public Services Tribunal for disposal on merits, provided significant observations and recommendations:

Deficiency of the State Tribunal

The Court concurred with the appellants that the U.P. Public Services Tribunal, operating under the State Act, did not possess the power to make interim orders. This lack of essential power made it an inadequate alternative remedy in many situations, potentially necessitating High Court intervention.

Commendation for a Central Act Framework

The Supreme Court strongly commended the State of Uttar Pradesh to consider establishing an appropriate tribunal under the central Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, in place of its existing Services Tribunal. The rationale for this recommendation was multi-faceted:

  • Uniformity: Adjudication of service disputes would achieve greater uniformity across the country.
  • Reduced Burden on High Courts: The High Courts would be relieved of the heavy burden of service litigations.
  • Plenary Powers: Tribunals under the Central Act are vested with plenary powers, including the ability to grant interim relief, ensuring more effective and satisfactory dispute resolution for all parties.

Improvements if the State Tribunal Continues

Should Uttar Pradesh decide to continue with its existing Public Services Tribunal under the 1976 Act, the Supreme Court stipulated crucial improvements:

  • Enhanced Manning: The State should ensure a sufficient number of legally qualified individuals are appointed to the Tribunal to guarantee adequate dispensation of justice and maintain judicial temper.
  • Diversification of Benches: To prevent the burdening of a single location (like Lucknow) and ensure accessibility for litigants across the State, the Court suggested planning for additional benches in other cities such as Allahabad, Meerut, and Agra.

Conclusion of the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court ultimately remitted the specific appeal to the U.P. Public Services Tribunal for disposal on its merits, setting a deadline for September 1990. However, the broader impact of this judgment lies in its strong recommendations to the State of Uttar Pradesh to align its service dispute resolution mechanism with the more comprehensive and empowered framework of the central Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985. The Court underscored that for a tribunal to be an effective alternative to the High Court, it must possess adequate powers, including the ability to issue interim orders.

Why This Judgment Matters for Legal Professionals

The Krishna Sahai judgment remains an essential read for lawyers, legal students, and government departments for several reasons:

  • Alternative Remedies: It clarifies the Supreme Court's stance on the adequacy of alternative remedies, particularly when a tribunal lacks crucial powers like issuing interim orders.
  • Administrative Law: It offers deep insights into the legislative intent behind the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, and its role in streamlining service dispute adjudication.
  • State vs. Central Legislation: The case highlights the preferred alignment of state-level service tribunals with the central framework for efficiency and comprehensive justice.
  • Tribunal Functioning: It provides guidance on the essential components of a well-functioning tribunal, emphasizing qualified personnel and accessible benches.
  • Precedent for Reforms: Lawyers advising state governments or challenging the efficacy of state tribunals can refer to this judgment to advocate for reforms and improvements in the justice delivery system.

Disclaimer

All information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult with a qualified legal professional for advice on specific legal issues.

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter