service law, recruitment, promotion
0  23 Mar, 1990
Listen in 01:30 mins | Read in 9:00 mins
EN
HI

Rajendra Singh Yadav and Ors. Vs. State of U.P. and Ors.

  Supreme Court Of India Civil Appeal /1815/1982
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, Lekhpals' services were terminated, leading them to file Writ Petitions in the High Court. The High Court, however, refused to entertain these petitions, citing the availability ...

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 4

PETITIONER:

RAJENDRA SINGH YADAV AND ORS.

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

STATE OF U.P. AND ORS.

DATE OF JUDGMENT23/03/1990

BENCH:

MISRA RANGNATH

BENCH:

MISRA RANGNATH

PUNCHHI, M.M.

RAMASWAMY, K.

CITATION:

1990 SCR (2) 171 1990 SCC (2) 763

JT 1990 (2) 438 1990 SCALE (1)651

ACT:

Uttar Pradesh Services Tribunal Act. 1970: State

Services Tribunal--Substitution of--By Tribunal under the

Central Administrative Tribunals Act. 1985--Manning of

Services Tribunal by adequate number of Judges of appropri-

ate level--Increase in number of Benches--Setting up of

Branches in different parts of State-- Directions issued.

HEADNOTE:

The appellants/petitioners filed Writ Petitions before

the High Court against the termination of their services as

Lekhpals in the State of Uttar Pradesh. The High Court did

not entertain the petitions on the ground that alternate

relief was available before the U.P. Public Services Tribu-

nals set up under U.P. Act 17 of 1976. Hence, the appeals,

by special leave/Writ Petitions.

Disposing of the appeals/petitions, this Court,

HELD: 1.1 The Services Tribunal set up under the U.P.

Act No. 17/76 should be withdrawn and an appropriate tribu-

nal under the Central Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985

should be set up. Such a Tribunal is deemed to be one in

terms of Article 323A of the Constitution. When set up, it

would take away High Court's jurisdiction in regard to

service disputes, and function as its substitute. It would

have plenary powers to deal with every aspect of the dis-

pute. This would be in accord with the current thinking on

this subject-matter at different levels. [173E; F-G]

1.2 A cursory analysis of year wise institution, penden-

cy and disposal of cases between 1977 and 1984 before the

Public Services Tribunal shows that while institutions have

sizeably fallen or remained more or less constant, there has

been rapid fall in the disposal of cases, even though there

has been increase in strength of Tribunals, and only 50 to

60% of the institutions are being attended to, which cer-

tainly would lead accumulation to mount up. These aspects

require to be noticed seriously. [174F-H]

172

1.3 Since the disputes require judicial handling, and

the adjudication being essentially judicial in character, an

adequate number of judges of the appropriate level should

man the Services Tribunals. This would create appropriate

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 4

temper and generate atmosphere suitable in n adjudicatory

Tribunal and the institution as well would command he requi-

site confidence of the disputants. [175B-C]

S.P. Sampath Kumar v. Union of India & Ors., [1987] 1

SCC 24, referred to.

1.4 State of Uttar Pradesh territorially is the second

largest State India, but populationwise comes first. Almost

every part of the State well advanced and service litigation

in such setting is likely to arise everywhere. Therefore to

locate the seat of the Tribunals at the State capital is not

appropriate. Keeping in view the accepted philosophy that

justice should be taken to everyone's doors, State Govern-

ment would consider increasing the number of Benches and

locating them at various sectors or depending upon the

number of institution of disputes and pendency at the level

of independent Commissionerate or by clubing two or three of

them together. The location of Benches would inquire further

examination at administrative level. but definitely, the

tribunals should be available in different parts of the

State and all the benches of the Tribunal should not be

located at one place. [175E-H; 176A]

The decision of the High Court in each of the cases is

set aside and e dispute transferred to the Services Tribunal

for disposal within six months. [173C-D]

JUDGMENT:

CIVIL APPELLATE/ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Civil appeals

No. 18 15 of 1982 etc.

From the Judgment and Order dated the 20.1.1982 of the

Allahabad High Court in C.W.P. No. 2701 of 1981.

Shankar Ghosh, R.K. Jain, R.B. Mehrotra, Ms. Abha Sharma,

Sangira Tripathi Mandal, R.P. Singh, Harish N. Salve, D.K.

trg, Gopal Subramanium, Mrs. Shobha Dikshit, C.P. Pandey,

S.K pharwal, M.P. Sarawala, R.S. Sodhi, D.D. Gupta, Shakil

Ahmed ed, K.R.R. Pillai, M.A. Firoz, R.D. Upadhyay, U.S.

Prasad and VI. Nayar for the appearing parties.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

173

RANGANATH MISRA, J. Special leave granted.

This bunch of cases either by special leave or under

Article 32 of the Constitution is by a set of Lekhpals

serving in the State of Uttar Pradesh whose services have

been terminated. Their Writ Petitions to the High Court have

not been entertained on the ground that alternate relief is

available before the U.P. Public Services Tribunal set up

under U.P. Act No. 17 of 1976. In the Civil Appeal arising

out of Special Leave Petition No. 8826 of 1982 the High

Court examined the question at length as to whether the

jurisdiction of the High Court has been taken away by the

setting up of the Services Tribunal under the U.P. Act. We

have heard counsel for the parties at some length as apart

from this group of cases, some other cases involving the

same question have also been heard and those matters have

been disposed of excepting this bunch. On merit, we are of

the view that the decisions of the High Court should be

vacated and in each case the dispute shall stand transferred

to the Services Tribunal for disposal in accordance with

law. The Tribunal shall dispose of these cases within six

months from the date of the receipt of this order.

We are at the view, as we have already indicated else-

where, that the 'Services Tribunal set up under the U.P. Act

No. 17/76 should be withdrawn and an appropriate tribunal

under the Central Administrative Tribunals Act of 1985

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 4

should be set up. Such a Tribunal if constituted would be in

accord with the service jurisprudence which is developing.

Several States have already constituted such Tribunals under

the Central Act.

The Tribunal set up under the Central Act is deemed to

be one in terms of Article 323A of the Constitution. When

such a Tribunal is set up the High Court's jurisdiction in

regard to service disputes is taken away and the Tribunal

functions as a substitute of the High Court. More or less

this service jurisprudence has almost gained ground and

there is no justification as to why the Services Tribunal of

a different pattern should operate in the State of Uttar

Pradesh with inadequate powers to deal with every situation

arising before it. A Tribunal set up under the Central

Administrative Tribunals Act would have plenary powers to

deal with every aspect of the dispute and would be in accord

with the current thinking on this subject-matter at differ-

ent levels. We are, therefore, of the view that the U.P.

Services Tribunal should be substituted by a Tribunal under

the Central Administrative Tribunals Act as early as possi-

ble in order that there may be uniformity of functioning and

the High Court may be relieved of the

174

burden of dealing with the service disputes as is the situa-

tion at present.

In course of the hearing, a statement showing yearwise

institution, disposal and pendency before the Public Serv-

ices Tribunals has been placed before us and we extract the

same for convenience:

STATEMENT SHOWING THE YEARWISE DISPOSAL,

FILING AND PENDING CASES BEFORE THE PUBLIC

SERVICE TRIBUNALS

Year No.of Opening Cases filed Total Disposal Closing

Tribunals Balance during the during Balance

year year

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

1977 Two 2568 2156 4724 1744 2980

1978 Three 3700 6834 10534 4761 5773

1979 Four 5773 2710 8483 2826 5657

1980 Five 5657 2690 8347 2689 5658

1981 Five 5658 3192 8651 2290 6561

1982 Five 6561 3072 9633 1718 7915

1983 Five 7915 2206 10121 1988 8133

1984 Five 8133 2461 10594 1178 9416

A cursory analysis would show that while in 1977 two Tribu-

nals only were functioning, in 1984 as many as five Tribu-

nals came to be set up. The chart indicates that while

institutions have sizeably fallen or remained more or less

constant, there has been rapid fall in the disposal of

cases. For instance, while in 1978, 4,761 cases have been

disposed of, in the years 1982 and 1984 the numbers have

been 1,7 18 and 1,178 respectively. Even five Tribunals in

place of two have obviously not been meeting the mounting

challenge of institutions. Learned counsel for the State of

Uttar Pradesh was not able to indicate any specific reason

as to why while the strength of Tribunals went up there was

a proportionate fall in the disposals. Again we find that 50

to 60% of the institutions are being attended to which

certainly would lead accumulation to mount up. These aspects

require to be noticed seriously and the State Government

should have applied its mind if

175

any system of review was in force. Apparently, the perform-

ance was not being reviewed either by the Tribunal itself or

by any other agency.

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 4

We have been told that the Services Tribunal mostly

consists of Administrative Officers and the judicial element

in the manning part of the Tribunal is very small. As was

pointed out by us in S.P. Sam path Kurnar v. Union of India

& Ors., [1987] 1 SCC 124, the disputes require judicial

handling and the adjudication being essentially judicial in

character it is necessary that an adequate number of Judges

of the appropriate level should man the Services Tribunals.

This would create the appropriate temper and generate the

atmosphere suitable in an adjudicatory Tribunal and the

institution as well would command the requisite confidence

of the disputants. We have indicated in the connected matter

that steps should be taken to replace the Services Tribunals

by Tribunals under the Central Administrative Tribunals Act

of 1985. That would give the Tribunal the necessary colour

in terms of Article 323A of the Constitution. As a conse-

quence of setting up of such Tribunals, the jurisdiction of

the High Court would be taken away and the Tribunals can

with plenary powers function appropriately. The disputes

which have arisen on account of the Services Tribunals not

having complete jurisdiction to deal with every situation

arising before it would then not arise.

We have pointed out that notice has been issued in a

later case for the State's response to the question of

Tribunals to be located at different parts of the State.

State of Uttar Pradesh territorially is the second largest

State in India but considering the population it comes

first. Almost every part of the State is well advanced and

service litigation in such setting is likely to arise every-

where. To locate the seat of the Tribunals at the State

capital in such a situation is not appropriate. The accepted

philosophy relevant to the question today is that justice

should be taken to everyone's doors. This, of course, is not

a statement which should be taken literally but undoubtedly

the redressal forum should be available nearabout so that

litigation may be cheap and the forum of ventillating griev-

ance may not be difficult to approach. Keeping that in view

which is a legitimate consideration it would be appropriate

for the State Government to consider, firstly, increase in

the number of Benches of the Tribunal and secondly, to

locate them not at the same station but at various sectors

or depending upon the number of institution of disputes and

pendency at the level of independent Commissionerate or by

clubbing two or three of them together. This, of course, is

a matter which would require further

176

examination at the administrative level and, therefore, we

express no opinion regarding location of such Tribunal

although we are of the definite view that there should be

Tribunals available in different parts of the State and all

the Benches of the Tribunal should not be located at one

place.

The writ Petitions and the civil appeals are disposed of

with these directions.,

N.P.V. Petition & Appeals disposed of.

177

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter