Jharkhand High Court, First Appeal, divorce, cruelty, desertion, Hindu Marriage Act, family law, matrimonial dispute, Surendra Kumar Thakur, Babita Devi
 03 Nov, 2026
Listen in 01:47 mins | Read in 22:30 mins
EN
HI

Surendra Kumar Thakur Vs. Babita Devi @ Baby Devi

  Jharkhand High Court F.A. No. 23 of 2024
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, Surendra Kumar Thakur filed a First Appeal against the dismissal of his divorce petition. His marriage to Babita Devi was solemnized in 2005, and they had ...

Bench

Applied Acts & Sections

No Acts & Articles mentioned in this case

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

Page 1 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

Neutral Citation No. ( 2026:JHHC:32222-DB )

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI

First Appeal No. 23 of 2024

Surendra Kumar Thakur, Aged about 41 years, son of Dasrath Thakur,

Resident of Village Old Cinema Hall, Palihari, Gurudih, P.O. & P.S.

Gomia, District Bokaro. …. ... Appellant

Versus

1. Babita Devi @ Baby Devi, Aged about 31 years, wife of Surendra

Kumar Thakur, Daughter of Gaur Thakur, Resident of Village Old

Cinema Hall, Palihari, Gurudih, P.O. & P.S. Gomia, District-Bokaro,

At present resident of Village Dumra (Jamua Tand, P.O. Dumra, P.S.

Baghmara, District Dhanbad.

2. General Manager, Indian Explosive. Pvt. Ltd., At + P.O. IEL Gomia,

P.S. IEL, District Bokaro, PIN 829112, Jharkhand.

…. ... Respondents

---------

CORAM: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ PRASAD

---------

For the Appellant : Mr Atanu Banerjee, Advocate

For the Respondent No.1 : Mr Ranjan Kumar, Advocate

For the Respondent No.2 : Mr Ashwini Bhushan, AC to Sr.SC-II

---------

Reserved on: 07/10/2026 Pronounced on:03/11/2026

Per: Manoj Prasad, J.

1. Heard Mr Atanu Banerjee, learned counsel appearing on behalf of

the appellant-husband; Mr Ranjan Kumar, learned counsel appearing

on behalf of the respondent No.1-wife; and Mr Ashwini Bhushan,

learned AC to Sr.SC-II, appearing on behalf of the respondent No.2-

State.

2. The present First Appeal has been filed by the appellant-husband

under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, impleading the

wife as respondent No.1 and respondent No.2 (IEL), who has been

made a party to this proceeding under the orders of the court. This

Page 2 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

appeal challenges the judgment dated 30.11.2023 and the decree

dated 07.12.2023 passed by the learned Additional Principal Judge,

Additional Family Court, Bermo at Tenughat, Bokaro, in Original

Suit No.132 of 2021, whereby the petition for dissolution of

marriage by a decree of divorce under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act,

1955”) was dismissed.

3. The brief facts of the case are that the marriage between the parties

was solemnised on 30.04.2005 in accordance with Hindu rituals.

After marriage, they lived together as husband and wife in village

Gomia, District Bokaro, and had two children out of wedlock,

namely one son and one daughter. It is stated that after marriage, the

respondent-wife came to her matrimonial home but never sought to

establish a marital relationship with the petitioner and always kept

her distance from her husband, stating that she did not like him.

However, through the efforts of the present appellant, the marital

relationship somehow continued between the parties. It is alleged

that the respondent-wife tried to create disturbances in the

matrimonial life and also disregarded her in-laws. Thus, the

appellant was tortured both physically and mentally on account of

the ill-behaviour and short temper of the respondent-wife, who used

to talk continuously on her husband’s mobile phone with some other

male person, resulting in disputes and quarrels between the parties.

It is alleged that the respondent was a lady of suspicious character. It

Page 3 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

is further alleged that on 15.04.2015, the respondent left the house of

the appellant without informing her in-laws and went to her parental

home at Jamua Tand, P.S. Baghmara, District Dhanbad, and since

then she has been residing with her parents. The appellant went

several times to her in-laws’ house to get the matter settled and for

restitution of conjugal rights, but to no effect. Hence, a prayer has

been made for dissolution of marriage by decree of divorce.

4. After appearance, the respondent filed a show cause-cum-written

statement before the learned Trial Court, stating that the parties were

legally married husband and wife, and that the marriage was

solemnised on 30.04.2005. The marriage was also consummated,

and a son and a daughter were born out of wedlock. The respondent

further stated that she fully co-operated in maintaining the conjugal

relationship. However, the respondent was tortured by the appellant,

and demands for dowry were made. Her dignity and honour were

compromised. Allegations of an extra-marital relationship were

made against her, whereas the real fact was that the appellant had

established an extra-marital relationship with a lady working with

him. The respondent returned to her parents’ house on account of the

physical and mental torture and the illegal demand for dowry made

by her husband and in-laws. Despite returning to her parents’ house,

the appellant never tried to restore conjugal life and never made any

effort to bring her back to her matrimonial home. All efforts were

unilaterally made by the present respondent, who also filed a

Page 4 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

complaint under the provisions of the Dowry Act and Section 498-A

of the Indian Penal Code, which was compromised with the intent to

restore conjugal life. The respondent still expressed her desire to

restore conjugal life, subject to the condition that she is given due

respect and honour at her matrimonial home. She has not even been

allowed to meet her children during this period.

5. Based on the pleadings, the learned Trial Court formulated the

following issues for adjudication: -

(I). Whether the Suit is maintainable in its present form?

(II). Whether the petitioner has valid cause of action for the suit?

(III). Whether after marriage the respondent (wife) subjected the

petitioner (husband) to cruelty?

(IV). Whether the petitioner is entitled to get a Decree of dissolution

of marriage on the basis of Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage

Act, 1955 and petitioner is entitled to get the relief as prayed for?

Whether the respondent (wife) deserted her husband (petitioner)

since last two years prior to filing of the suit?

6. After framing of issues, four witnesses were examined on behalf of

the appellant-petitioner, namely, Binod Rawani as P.W.-1, who is a

neighbor of the appellant and working with ‘ORIKA Company’ at

Indian Explosive Limited (IEL), Bhim Prasad as P.W.-2, who is

another friend of the appellant working in ‘ORIKA Company’ IEL,

Smita Kumari, as P.W.-3, daughter of the parties, who on the date of

deposition before the learned Trial Court was aged about 11 years

and a student of Class-VI and the last witness is the present

appellant himself Surendra Kumar Thakur as P.W.-4.

7. On behalf of the respondent, three witnesses, namely Ravi Thakur as

D.W.-1 (the respondent's brother), Jitendra Mahto as D.W.-2, and

Page 5 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

the respondent herself as D.W.-3, have been examined. Certain

documents have been marked as the X series. A photocopy of the

joint compromise petition dated 15.04.2015 is marked as Exhibit-X;

photocopies of handwritten letters are marked as Exhibit-X/1 to X/6;

a photocopy of the notice relating to O.S. Case No. 245 of 2022 is

marked as X/7; a photocopy of the order dated 01.05.2015 passed by

the Hon'ble High Court in Cr.M.P. No. 867 of 2015 is marked as

X/8; a photocopy of the order dated 24.03.2015 passed by the

Hon'ble High Court in A.B.A. No. 2795 of 2014 is marked as X/9; a

photocopy of the petition for permission to compromise the case

relating to Baghmara P.S. Case No. 109/14 is marked as X/10; a

photocopy of the compromise agreement prepared during

'Panchayati' is marked as X/11; a photocopy of the petition dated

11.05.2013 given to Dhanbad Mahila Police by the respondent is

marked as X/12; and a photocopy of the petition dated 16.11.2013

given to Dhanbad Mahila Police is marked as X/13.

Findings of the Trial Court

8. The learned Trial Court, after considering the oral and documentary

evidence of the parties, held that the factum of marriage between the

parties was not in dispute, that the marriage was solemnised in the

year 2005, and, as such, that the suit as instituted was maintainable

and that the appellant had a valid cause of action. However, the

dominant issues for consideration, i.e. Issue Nos. III and IV, were

decided against the appellant and in favour of the respondent. It is

Page 6 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

stated that, although P.W.-2 had stated that a case for restitution of

conjugal rights was filed in the year 2016, no document to that effect

was produced on record. The learned Trial Court, by referring to a

judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Samar Ghose Vs. Jaya

Ghose in Civil Appeal No.151 of 2004, decided on 26.03.2007, at

paragraph 15, has held as under:

“Mere trivial irritations, quarrels, normal wear and tear of the

married life which happens in day-to-day life would not be adequate

for grant of divorce on the ground of mental cruelty. The married

life should be reviewed as a whole and a few isolated instances over

a period of years will not amount to cruelty. The ill-conduct must be

persistent for a fairly lengthy period, where the relationship has

deteriorated to an extent that because of the acts and behavior of a

spouse, the wronged party finds it extremely difficult to live with the

other party any longer, may amount to mental cruelty. Where there

has been a long period of continuous separation, it may fairly be

concluded that the matrimonial bond is beyond repair. The marriage

becomes a fiction though supported by a legal tie.”

9. Considering the mandate of the law, the facts of the present case,

and the evidence of P.W.-3, the daughter of the parties, who at the

time was about 11 years old, but in her cross-examination stated that

her evidence was prepared at her father's dictation, and hence much

weight was not given to such evidence, the Court found that the

allegation of cruelty as made by the appellant against the respondent

was not proved. The documents brought on record by the

respondent, though marked as Exhibit X series for identification,

were never disputed, i.e., a compromise between the parties at the

intervention of the High Court and the filing of a complaint

regarding the demand for dowry, etc. Finally, the Court concluded

that the decree of divorce on the ground of cruelty and desertion

Page 7 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

could not be passed, and accordingly, the suit of the appellant-

husband was dismissed.

ARGUMENTS

10. Mr. Atanu Banerjee, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the

appellant, submits that although the suit was instituted in 2021, there

has been no restitution of conjugal life since 2015, as the respondent

left her matrimonial home. It is also stated that it is not in dispute

that two children are living with the present appellant. All efforts at

settlement have failed. It is further submitted that the witnesses

examined on behalf of the appellant have categorically supported the

appellant's case. It is also stated that an application under Section 24

of the Act, 1955 was filed, and an order was passed on the said

petition in the present Original Suit No.132 of 2021, which was

challenged by the present appellant before this Court by filing

C.M.P. No.960 of 2022, which was dismissed by a Co-ordinate

Bench of this Court vide order dated 04.08.2023. It is further argued

that the daughter of the parties came to the Court to support the

appellant's case that her mother frequently quarrelled with her father

and her grandmother, which categorically establishes the appellant's

case and was not considered by the learned Trial Court. The facts of

the present case clearly establish cruelty, both physical and mental,

and the parties have lived separately for more than six years prior to

the institution of the suit without any valid cause and without any

efforts for reconciliation, amounting to mental cruelty on the

Page 8 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

husband. These aspects of the case were not considered. It was also

not considered that the marriage in the present case had become only

a formality, with the actual relationship between the parties non-

existent, and the marital relationship recognised only as per law,

which did not require any further continuance.

11. Learned counsel for the appellant has also submitted that, although

the application for dissolution of marriage was filed under Section

13(1)(i-a) of the Act, 1955, it was also a case under Section 13(1)(i-

b) of the Act, 1955, i.e., desertion by the wife-respondent of the

present appellant without any valid cause. There was a specific

pleading to that effect, and even the issue was framed, but the

learned Trial Court did not consider this issue while deciding the

case. Without passing any speaking order on the point of desertion,

the issue was decided against the present appellant. The filing of

criminal cases against the present appellant, with the conclusion of

no guilt in such cases, also amounts to cruelty, which was not

considered by the learned Trial Court. On all these facts, a prayer

has been made to allow the present appeal, set aside the judgment

and decree, and pass an order for dissolution of marriage between

the parties under Section 13 of the Act, 1955, on both the grounds of

cruelty and desertion.

12. Per contra, Mr. Ranjan Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf

of the respondent-wife, has submitted that the impugned judgment

and decree do not warrant any interference. The fact that the

Page 9 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

respondent has been living separately since 2015 is not in dispute,

but the reason for her ouster has been categorically stated to be that

her dignity was compromised, an allegation of an extramarital

relationship was made against her, and she was tortured for illegal

demands for dowry. The respondent, in her written statement, had

categorically stated that she was ready to restore conjugal life and,

even during mediation before this Court, had made efforts for the

restitution of conjugal life, but to no effect.

13. Learned counsel for the respondent-wife draws this Court’s attention

to the order dated 05.05.2026 passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of this

Court, wherein it has been recorded that the respondent-wife,

refuting the allegations made by the appellant-husband, stated that

she was willing to live together so that she might also experience the

role of mother to both children, but even then the appellant-husband

remained adamant in his refusal to cohabit. Resultantly, the Co-

ordinate Bench of this Court, in terms of the judgment of the

Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Rajnesh Vs. Neha &

Another, reported in (2021) 2 SCC 324, directed the parties to file

affidavits of their movable and immovable property for

consideration of the case of interim maintenance/alimony, and this

Court also impleaded the Indian Explosive Pvt. Ltd., Gomia,

through its General Manager, as a party to the proceedings to obtain

details of the present appellant’s salary. Several efforts at mediation

were made, which failed. On the merits, learned counsel submits

Page 10 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

that cruelty by the wife on the husband was not proved, and no case

of desertion is made, as the wife still intends to restore conjugal life

with her husband. Therefore, the animus deserendi was completely

absent. The husband, not being ready to cohabit, cannot take the plea

of desertion, as he cannot be rewarded for his own wrongs. On these

aspects of the case, the prayer is to dismiss the appeal.

FINDINGS

14. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the material

available on record, including the Trial Court records. The points for

determination, which arise for consideration before us, considering

the rival contentions raised by the parties, are hereunder: -

i) Whether the appellant was successful in establishing a

case that the respondent had committed acts of cruelty on

him is sufficient for grant of a decree of divorce in terms

of Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Act, 1955.

ii) The second point for determination is whether a decree

for divorce could have been granted in terms of Section

13(1)(i-b) of the Act, 1955 i.e. on the ground of desertion

by the wife-respondent on the husband-appellant.

15. The two points above for determination will put the lis at rest.

Before coming to the factual aspects of the case, we would like to

observe that, though cruelty has not been defined under the

provisions of the Act, 1955, for the purpose of divorce it should be

Page 11 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

such that matrimonial life becomes incompatible and conjugal life

cannot be restored on account of such behaviour by either spouse.

16. Cruelty can be either physical or mental, or both. In the present case,

although there are allegations of physical cruelty, namely that the

respondent frequently quarrelled with her husband, i.e. the appellant,

and the mother-in-law, the appellant has brought three witnesses,

apart from himself, and examined them in Court to support this

contention. Two of them appear to be his colleagues and friends,

who are not family members. Their evidence, therefore, cannot be

accepted without an element of suspicion. Evidence from a family

member, particularly the mother, who is also alleged by the

respondent to be a victim of such quarrels, would have corroborated

the present appellant’s case, but such evidence has not been brought

on record. The daughter, who has been examined in this case as a

witness, was about 11 years old. It can always be considered that

when a minor child is residing with only one of her parents, the

possibility of poisoning of mind against the other spouse/parent

cannot be ruled out. Even in her cross-examination, P.W.-3 has

admitted that her entire evidence was prepared under the dictation of

her father. Under such circumstances, and in the absence of

sufficient evidence showing her (P.W.-3, the daughter of the parties)

competence and neutrality in deposing before the Court, and also in

view of her own statements made in course of cross-examination,

the evidence of the minor child cannot be read into in order to

Page 12 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

conclude the allegations of cruelty made by the respondent against

the appellant.

17. So far as the evidence of the appellant is concerned, although he has

stated that he was subjected to both physical and mental cruelty, that

statement is not corroborated by any credible evidence. No

complaint was made before any competent authority, nor was any

effort made towards reconciliation at any time. These facts lead to

the conclusion that the allegations of cruelty were not proved by the

present appellant.

18. Coming to the second dimension of cruelty, i.e. mental cruelty,

which centres on an allegation that the wife is alleged to have had an

extramarital relationship. Such allegations, if proved, may amount to

mental cruelty in appropriate cases, but in the present case there are

allegations and counter-allegations. The husband’s allegations begin

with an assertion that his wife had an extramarital relationship,

including statements that she used to talk to an unknown male over

the husband’s own mobile phone. To our considered view, such

allegations are typical gender-based stereotypes, where, if a woman

talks to a man, even if he is a friend, charges of adultery or of an

extramarital relationship are levelled. We are, therefore, of the

considered view that such allegations amount to cruelty towards the

wife. Counter-allegations by the wife of an extramarital relationship

against her husband, without appropriate proof, may also amount to

cruelty. However, in this case, the allegations were made by the

Page 13 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

husband against his wife. Thus, we are of the considered view that

no case of mental cruelty is made out.

19. So far as the allegation of desertion is concerned, although no case

under Section 13(1)(i-b) of the Act, 1955 was instituted, the

pleadings do refer to desertion, and an issue on the point of desertion

has also been framed. The law is settled that merely not referring to

any specific provision of law will not be fatal to a party's case if the

pleadings are to that effect and the provision of law also allows such

pleading. In the present case, not only are there pleadings, but the

issue has also been framed.

20. As already referred to, an order passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of

this Court records that the wife expressed her desire to restore

conjugal life, which was refused by the present appellant. Such a

statement sufficiently establishes the absence of animus deserendi,

thereby establishing the element of desertion for the purpose of

divorce. Certain documents, marked as the Exhibit-X series, which

have not been disputed by the parties during the course of the

hearing, also show that even in the year 2015 there was a

compromise. However, it appears that the compromise was entered

into only for the purpose of settling the criminal case, as despite the

terms of the compromise requiring the parties to live together, the

same appears not to have been complied with.

21. A maintenance case was filed by the wife, and even in an order

passed under Section 24 of the Act, 1955, where interim

Page 14 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

maintenance of just Rs.3000/- was ordered, the husband challenged

the same by filing a C.M.P. before this Court, which, though

dismissed, speaks volumes about the conduct of the present

appellant. The order dated 01.05.2015 passed in Cr.M.P. No.867 of

2015 shows that, in terms of a compromise between the parties, they

were living together. An application was filed by the present

respondent for permission to compound the said case in the year

2015 itself, as the parties had restored conjugal life, as is apparent

from the documents, which is permission to compromise the case

relating to Baghmara P.S. Case No.109 of 2014, which is marked as

Exhibit-X/10. These entire documents, the oral evidence produced

by the parties, and the other preceding discussions clearly establish

that the case of desertion was also not established.

22. Having considered the matter, we are of the considered view that the

points for determination formulated by us must be decided against

the appellant and in favour of the respondent, holding that the

appellant failed to make out a case of cruelty or desertion under

Section 13(1)(i-a) or (i-b) of the Act, 1955, for dissolution of

marriage by a decree of divorce.

23. Since an order under Section 24 of the Act, 1955, was passed,

which was challenged before this Court and the same was affirmed.

We, therefore, do not want to pass any separate order on the said

aspect of interim maintenance. However, the respondent is always at

liberty to move the appropriate application for modification of the

Page 15 of 15 F.A. No. 23 of 2024

order in view of any changed circumstance, if she so desires, which

may be decided by the court of competent jurisdiction following the

principles of law after giving an opportunity of hearing to both the

parties.

24. With the above observations, the present First Appeal is

accordingly dismissed without any order as to costs.

25. Pending Interlocutory Application(s), if any, do not survive and

stand disposed of.

(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)

(Manoj Prasad, J.)

November 3

rd

, 2026

N.A.F.R.

Madhav/-

Uploaded on: 03/11/2026

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter