contract law, commercial dispute, civil case
0  07 May, 1991
Listen in 01:04 mins | Read in 13:00 mins
EN
HI

Chandmal Vs. Firm Ram Chandra and Vishwanath

  Supreme Court Of India Civil Appeal /2279/1991
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, landlord Chandmal sought to evict tenant Firm Ram Chandra and Vishwanath from his shop, claiming personal use. The tenant countered by asserting a permanent tenancy right, ...

Bench

Applied Acts & Sections

No Acts & Articles mentioned in this case

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 7

PETITIONER:

CHANDMAL

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

FIRM RAM CHANDRA AND VISHWANATH

DATE OF JUDGMENT07/05/1991

BENCH:

RAY, B.C. (J)

BENCH:

RAY, B.C. (J)

VERMA, JAGDISH SARAN (J)

CITATION:

1991 AIR 1594 1991 SCR (2) 732

1991 SCC (3) 130 JT 1991 (2) 553

1991 SCALE (1)931

ACT:

Hyderabad House (Rent, Eviction and Lease) Control Act,

1954-Section 26-Revisionary jurisdiction of High Court-Scope

of.

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Section 115-Revision-

Scope of.

HEADNOTE:

The appellant-landlord filed a suit for eviction of the

respondent firm-defendant-commission agent firm, from his

shop under section 15(3)(a)(iii) of the Hyderabad House

(Rent, Eviction and Lease) Control Act, 1954 on the ground

that the appellant required the suit shop for his own

personal use as he intended to start commission agency and

other business; and that the respondent did not vacate the

premise inspite of his two notices, terminating the tenancy.

The respondent filed written statement before the

Additional Rent Controller accepting the ownership of the

appellant and tenancy of the respondent and denied the

appellant's allegation that he required the premises for his

personal use, as the appellant was a member of Hindu Joint

family comprising of his father, and his brothers, and his

brothers and appellant; the appellant as one of the partners

of registered firm runs a kirana of commission agency shop

under the name and style of M/s Rajmal Sumermal Surana and

the appellant owned many houses and shops and as such was

not entitled to an order of eviction. In the additional

written statement it was further stated that the appellant

purchased the house from one registered partnership firm and

one of the partners of the firm was occupying the house as a

permanent tenant since Samwat 2002. It was also contended

that the partners of the firm were not made parties to the

eviction proceedings and hence the suit was not tenable.

The Trial Court considering the evidence allowed the

suit holding that the appellant was entitled to evict the

respondent in view of the provisions of Section 15(2)(vi) of

the Act, though the plea of bona fide requirement was

negatived.

The tenant-respondent filed an appeal under section 25

before the

733

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 7

District Judge, which was dismissed though it was held that

the landlord failed to prove that he required the premises

for personal use.

The tenant-respondent's revision petition under section

26 to the High Court, was allowed by a Single Judge.

Allowing the landlord's appeal, this Court

HELD: 1. The jurisdiction of the High Court in revision

against the order passed on appeal by the District Judge is

a limited one and it is almost pari materia with the

provisions of Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The High Court while exercising the revisional jurisdiction

can interfere with the order passed on appeal by the

appellate authority only on three grounds, i.e. (i) where

the original or appellate authority exercised a jurisdiction

not vested in it by law, or (ii) where the original or

appellate authority failed to exercise a jurisdiction so

vested, or (iii) where in following the procedure or passing

the order, the original or appellate authority acted

illegally or with material irregularity. [738C-E]

2. The findings in any view of the matter whatsoever

cannot be held to be either without jurisdiction vested with

them, nor it can be held to be made by the original or

appellate authority illegally or with material irregularity.

[738G]

3. The revisional jurisdiction of the High Court under

Section 26 of the said Act is confined strictly to the

jurisdictional error or illegal exercise of jurisdiction.

The finding of the High Court to the effect that it was the

duty of the Court in the interest of justice to interfere

even with the concurrent finding of facts because on the

record, High Court found that there was not a single factor

to come to the conclusion that the claim was mala fide or

was not bona fide as required by the statute, is entirely

baseless and not in accordance with the provisions of

Section 26 of said Act which confers revisional Jurisdiction

on the High Court. [738H-739B]

4. The claim of permanent tenancy by one of the partners has

been clearly and unequivocally made in the additional

written statement filed on behalf of the respondent. In

such circumstances, the provisions of Section 15(2) (vi) of

the said Act are applicable and an order of eviction can

very well be passed on this ground alone. [739F]

734

JUDGMENT:

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2279 of

1991.

From the Judgment and Order dated 27.9.1989 of the

Bombay High Court in C.R.A. No. 500 of 1985.

S.C. Birla for the Appellant.

V.N. Ganpule, S.V. Deshpande and Ms. Priya Gupta for

the Respondent.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

RAY, J. We have heard learned counsel for the parties

and we grant special leave.

This appeal on special leave is directed against the

judgment and order passed in Civil Revision Application No.

500 of 1985 by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay,

Aurangabad Bench allowing the Revision, setting aside the

judgment and decree passed by the District Judge in Rent

Appeal No. 5 of 1984 confirming and allowing the judgment

and order of the Additional Rent Controller, Aurangabad in

R.C. No. ARC/71/3.

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 7

The matrix of the case is as follows:

The appellant-landlord, Chandmal, S/o Sumermal Surana

as plaintiff filed a suit for eviction of the respondent-

defendent Firm Ram Chandra & Vishwanath, a commission agent

firm from his shop bearing Municipal No. 4-16-101 situated a

Mondha, Taluka, District Aurangabad (maharashtra) under

section 15(3)(a)(iii) of the Hyderabad House (Rent, Eviction

and Lease) Control Act, 1954 to be hereinafter to be

referred to as the said Act on the ground inter alia that

the respondent was the tenant of the said shop attached to

the said house of the appellant-landlord on the monthly rent

of Rs.50 per month and the tenancy commences from the Ist

day of every month according to the English calendar, that

the landlord-appellant required the suit shop for his own

personal use as he intended to start commission agency and

other business in the said shop, that he terminated the

tenancy of the respondency of the respondent by serving the

two notices dated 28.3.1969 and 8.12.1970 and that the

respondent did not vacate the suit premises, hence the suit

has been filed for eviction of the tenant-respondent from the

said premises. Shankarrao Marutirao Sonawane,

735

one of the partners of respondent firm filed his written

statement before the Additional Rent Controller accepting

the ownership of the appellant and tenancy of the respondent

at the rate of Rs. 50 per month. He, however, denied the

appellant's allegation that he required the suit premises

for his personal use. According to the respondent, the

appellant is a member of Hindu joint family comprising of

his father, Sumermal, his real brothers and appellant and as

one of the partners of registered firm runs a kirana of

commission agency shop under the name and style of M/s

Rajmal Sumermal Surana. It has been further submitted that

the appellant owns many houses and shops at Aurangabad and

also runs a very big shop at Bhaji Bazar, Aurangabad and is

not entitled to evict. In the additional written statement

it has been further stated that the appellant purchased the

house from Balkrishna and brothers, the firm Ramchandra and

Vishwanath is a partnership firm registered under the

Partnership Act, one of the partners of the firm Ramchandra

and Vishwanath is occupying the house as a permanent tenant

since Samwat 2002. It has also been contended that the

partners of the firm are not made parties to the eviction

proceedings and hence the suit was not tenable.

An additional issue was framed at the request of the

appellant which was to the following effect:

"Do defendant prove that he is permanent tenant and

his claim is bona fide."

The trial court considering the evidences adduced on

behalf of the defendant-respondent held that the defendant

failed to prove the claim of permanent tenancy of Ramchandra

Madhavrao since Samvat 2002 over the suit premises and that

the claim of permanent tenancy is not bona fide. This

issue was thus answered in the negative.

The Additional Rent Controller, therefore, held that

the appellant is entitled to evict the respondent from the

suit premises in view of the provisions of Section 15(2)

(vi) of the said Act and, therefore, Made an order directing

the tenant-respondent to hand over vacant and peaceful

possession of the said shop to the landlord-appellant within

a period of 30 days of the order though he negatived the

plea of bona fide requirement of suit premises for his own

occupation.

The order was made on February 14, 1984. Against this

judgment and order, the tenant-respondent filed an appeal

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 7

being Rent Appeal No. 5 of 1984 under section 25 of the said

Act in the court of

736

District Judge at Aurangabad. The learned District Judge

confirmed the judgment and order of the Additional Rent

Controller holding that the landlord failed to prove that he

bona fide required the premises for personal use, for

starting new business. It was further held that so far as

the claim of permanent tenancy, there was no iota of

evidence to support the tenant-respondent's claim of

permanent tenancy. It also held that the tenant-respondent

has put forth the claim of permanent tenancy to defeat the

landlord-appellant's right to claim possession of the

premises and had there been any substance in the claim, the

tenant-respondent would have produced evidence in support of

it. Complete absence of evidence indicated that the claim

is fake and not put forth bona fide. The learned District

Judge, therefore, held that the tenant's claim of permanent

tenancy was not bona fide and so upheld the finding of the

Additional Rent Controller and granted three months' time to

the tenant-respondent to deliver possession of the suit

premises to the landlord-appellant.

The tenant-respondent feeling aggrieved filed an

application for Revision under Section 26 of the said Act in

the High Court at Bombay (Aurangabad Bench) being Civil

Revision Application No. 500 of 1985. The said Revision

Application was allowed by the learned Single Judge setting

aside the concurrent finding of the courts below holding

inter alia that in the reply of the tenant to the notices

sent by the landlord, there was no semblance of a claim for

permanent tenancy. It was further held that in the written

submission there was no whisper about the claim of permanent

tenancy. It is for the first time that in the additional

written statement filed on behalf of the tenant the claim of

permanent tenancy by one of the partners, Ramchandra

Madhavrao since Samwat 2002 was made. It has also been held

that during the trial, Shankarrao Marutirao Sonawane, one of

the partners of the respondent firm who has signed the

written statement has not uttered a word in his examination-

in-chief with regard to the question of permanent tenancy.

It was, therefore, held that in these circumstances "it is

the duty of the Court in the interest of justice to

interfere even with a concurrent finding of fact because on

the record, I find that there is not a single factor to come

to the conclusion that the claim was mala fide or was not

bona fide as is required by the statute."

The learned Single Judge, therefore, set aside the

judgments of the courts below and allowed the Revision

Application with costs throughout.

It is against this judgment and order, the instant

appeal on

737

special leave has been filed by the landlord. It is

convenient to set out hereinbelow the relevant provisions of

Section 15(2)(vi) of the said Act before proceeding to

consider whether the High Court was justified in setting

aside the judgment and order of the courts below:

Section 15(2)(vi):

A tenant shall not be evicted, whether in execution

of a decree or otherwise except in accordance with

the provisions of this section--

(vi) that the tenant has denied the title of the

landlord or claimed a right of permanent tenancy

and that such denial or claim was not bona fide the

Controller shall make an order directing the tenant

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 5 of 7

to put the landlord in possession of the house, and

if the Controller is not so satisfied he shall make

an order, rejecting, rejecting the application."

It is also pertinent to set out in this connection the

provisions of Section 26 of the said Act:

Section 26:

"Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or

any other law for the time being in force, an

application for revision shall lie to the High

Court from any final order passed on appeal by an

appellate authority on the following grounds:

(a) that the original or appellate authority

exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law,

or

(b) that the original or appellate authority failed

to exercise a jurisdiction so vested, or

(c) in following the procedure or passing the

order, the original or appellate authority acted

illegally or with material irregularity."

There is no dispute regarding the submission made in

para 9 of the additional written statement which is a part

of the same written statement, filed on behalf of the

respondent by one of its partners, Shankarrao Marutirao

Sonawane to the effect that one of the partners

738

of the said firm, Ramachandra Madhavrao is occupying the

house as a permanent tenant since Samvat 2002. Admittedly,

on the basis of this additional written statement, an

additional issue No. 1 was framed at the request of the

landlord-appellant whether the claim of permanent tenancy of

Ramchandra Madhavrao was bona fide. It is evident from the

provisions of Section 15(2)(vi) as set out hereinbefore that

if the tenant has claimed a right of permanent tenancy and

that such claim was not bona fide the Controller shall make

an order directing the tenant to put the landlord in

possession of the house. The Additional Rent Controller as

well as the District Judge considered carefully and minutely

the evidences adduced on behalf of the tenant-respondent and

found that claim of permanent tenancy was not bona fide.

Accordingly, the courts below held that the tenant-

respondent was liable to be evicted from the suit premises

on this ground alone and passed order for eviction from the

suit premises. The jurisdiction of the High Court in

revision against the order passed on appeal by the District

Judge is a limited one and it is almost pari materia with

the provisions of Section 115 of the Code Procedure. The

High Court while exercising the revisional jurisdiction can

interfere with the order passed on appeal by the appellate

authority only on three grounds i.e. (i) where the original

or appellate authority exercised a jurisdiction not vested

in it by law, or (ii) where the original or appellate

authority failed to exercise a jurisdiction so vested, or

(iii) where in following the procedure or passing the order,

the original or appellate authority acted illegally or with

material irregularity. It is evident from the averments

made in para 9 of the additional written statement that one

of the partners of the respondent firm, Ramchandra Madhavrao

occupied the said premises as a permanent tenant since

Samvat 2002. This claim of permanent tenancy was held to be

not bona fide by the original court as well as by the

appellate authority on a consideration and appraisement of

the evidences adduced on behalf of the tenant-respondent and

as such both the courts below passed order of eviction of

the tenant-respondent from the suit premises. These are

admittedly concurrent findings of fact arrived at by the

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 6 of 7

original and the appellate authority. Moreover, these

findings in any view of the matter whatsoever, cannot be

held to be either without jurisdiction nor it can amount to

a failure to exercise jurisdiction vested with them, nor it

can be held to be made by the original or appellate

authority illegally or with material irregularity.

The revisional jurisdiction of the High Court under

Section 26 of the said Act is confined strictly to the

jurisdictional error or illegal exercise of jurisdiction.

The finding of the High Court to the effect

739

that it was the duty of the Court in the interest of justice

to interfere even with the concurrent finding of facts

because on the records, High Court found that there was not

a single factor to come to the conclusion that the claim was

mala fide or was not bona fide as required by the statute,

is entirely baseless and not in accordance with the

provisions of Section 26 of the said Act which confers

revisional jurisdiction on the High Court. It is pertinent

to mention in this connection the decision in J. Pandu v. R.

Narsubai, [1987] 1 SCC 573. It is a case under the A.P.

Buildings (lease, Rent and Eviction) Act, 1960. Sub-section

2(vi) of Section 10 of A.P. Buildings (Lease, Rent and

Eviction) which is similar to Section 15(2)(vi) of the

Hyderabad Houses (Rent, Eviction and Lease) Control Act,

1954 sets out two grounds of eviction viz. (1) denial of

title of the landlord without bona fides and (2) claim of

permanent tenancy rights without bona fides. It was held

that "consequently, either denial of title or claim of

permanent tenancy without bona fides will itself be enough

to attract Section 10(2)(vi). The order of eviction on this

ground, has therefore, to be sustained. By reason of this

conclusion alone the appeal can be dismissed."

In the case of Majati Subbarao v. P.V.K.Krishna Rao

(deceased) by Lrs., [1989] 4 SCC 732 it has been observed

that the denial of title of the landlord by the tenant must

be made in clear and in unequivocal terms. It was further

observed that it is well settled that the court hearing a

suit or appeal can take into account events which are

subsequent to the filing of the suit in order to give

appropriate relief or mould the relief appropriately.

As we have stated hereinbefore that the claim of

permanent tenancy by one of the partners, Ramchandra

Madhavrao has been clearly and unequivocally made in the

additional written statement filed on behalf of the

respondent. In such circumstances, the provisions of

Section 15(2)(vi) of the said Act are applicable and an

order of eviction can very well be passed on this ground

alone.

In the premises aforesaid, the judgment and order

passed in revision by the High Court is contrary to law as

the High Court in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction

interfered with the concurrent finding of fact arrived at by

the original court as well as the appellate authority. The

High Court should not have reversed the same in excise of

its revisional jurisdiction under Section 26 of the said

Act. We, therefore, set aside the judgment and order of the

High Court and uphold the orders of the court below. The

respondent is given three

740

months' time to vacate the suit premises on filing the usual

undertaking that they will not induct anybody or transfer

the same to any other person and they will go on paying the

rent of the premises at the usual rate and will deliver

vacant and peaceful possession of the suit premises on or

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 7 of 7

before the expiry of the said period to the landlord-

appellant. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the

parties will bear their own costs.

V.P.R. Appeal allowed.

741

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter