criminal appeal, evidence law, Orissa
0  09 Jul, 1991
Listen in 01:50 mins | Read in 10:00 mins
EN
HI

Gagan Bihari Samal and Anr Vs. State of Orissa

  Supreme Court Of India Criminal Appeal /383/1991
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, the appellants forcibly took the victim, made her drink liquor, and sexually assaulted her. After escaping and reporting the incident, a case was registered under Sections ...

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 6

PETITIONER:

GAGAN BIHARI SAMAL AND ANR.

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

STATE OF ORISSA

DATE OF JUDGMENT09/07/1991

BENCH:

RAY, B.C. (J)

BENCH:

RAY, B.C. (J)

AGRAWAL, S.C. (J)

CITATION:

1991 SCR (2) 839 1991 SCC (3) 562

JT 1991 (3) 63 1991 SCALE (2)89

ACT:

Constitution of India: Article 136-Special leave

petition-Concurrent findings of facts-Re-appraisal of

evidence-Whether could be considered.

Indian Penal Code, 1860: S.376-Rape-Trial-

Uncontroverted testimony of victim-Making out the offence

against the accused persons-Conviction and sentence awarded

by trial court-Maintained by appellate court and High Court

in revision-Validity of-Corroboration not the sine qua non

for conviction.

Evidence Act, 1872: S. 114A-Evidence-Victim girl

subjected to sexual assault forcibly-Protest and struggle by

victim-Absence of consent-Presumption of.

Criminal Procedure Code, 1973: S. 401-Revisional

jurisdiction-High Court-Whether could reappraise evidence.

HEADNOTE:

The appellants forcibly took P.W. 2 to a lonely place

on 19.3.1983, made her to drink liquor and committed sexual

assault on her. Thereafter they left her in a truck. While

the said truck was unloading materials near a village, the

victim stealthily left the truck and concealed herself near

a fence. P.W. 7 rescued her and took her to the house of

P.W. 8, one of her distant relative, from where her father

P.W. 1 took her back and lodged the report at the police

station. A case under ss. 363 and 376 read with s.

341.I.P.C. was registered against both the appellants.

After completion of the investigation, a charge sheet was

submitted and the appellants were tried for the aforesaid

offences.

The appellants denied the prosecution allegations and

pleaded that they were falsely implicated because of refusal

by one of them to marry the girl and previous enmity with

the other. The Assistant Sessions Judge rejected the

defence pleas, and found that the appellants committed rape

on the victim without her consent, and relying on s. 114A of

the Evidence Act, convicted the appellants under s.

376(2)(g), I.P.C. and sentenced each of them to rigorous

imprisonment for three

840

years. Since the victim was more than 16 years of age, the

appellants were acquitted of the charge under s. 363, I.P.C.

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 6

On dismissal of their appeal against the conviction and

sentence by the Addl. Session Judge, the appellants filed a

revision application before the High Court.

The High Court duly considered and appraised the

evidence and held that the appellants committed rape on PW 2

forcibly without her consent. Ultimately the appellants

came in appeal by special leave to this Court.

Dismissing the appeal, this Court,

HELD: 1. In cases of rape, generally it is difficult to

find any corroborative witnesses except the victim of the

rape. However, corroboration is not the sine que non for a

conviction in a rape case. In the Indian setting, refusal

to act on the testimony of a victim of sexual assault in the

absence of corroboration as a rule, is adding insult to

injury. [843D-F]

Bharwada Bhoginbhai Hirjibhai v. State of Gujarat, AIR

1983 SC 753 and Rameshwar v. The State of Rajasthan, [1952]

SCR 377, relied on.

2. In the instant case, the victim girl clearly stated

in her evidence that she had been taken to a solitary house

in the hills by appellant no. 1 where she was made to drink

liquor and thereafter she was undressed and forcibly

subjected to sexual intercourse by both the accused-

appellants one after the other. Her uncontroverted

testimony was accepted by all the courts and they

concurrently found that she had been raped without her

consent. [844F-G]

3. Apart from the legal presumption that flows from the

provisions of s. 114A of the Evidence Act, it is clearly

evident in the instant case, that the victim girl protested

and struggled while she was subjected to sexual assault

forcibly by the accused persons and this clearly evinces

absence of consent on her part in such sexual intercourse.

[844H; 845A]

4. The High Court rightly held that it cannot be

expected to re-appraise the evidence as a court of appeal

while exercising its revisional power under s. 401 Cr. P.C.

[845E-F]

841

State of Orissa v. Nakula Sahu and Ors., AIR 1979 SC

663, relied on.

5. This Court hearing an appeal by special leave cannot

consider and re-appraise the evidence once again in the face

of concurrent findings of facts arrived at by all the courts

below. [845F]

JUDGMENT:

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal appeal No.

383 of 1991.

From the Judgment and Order dated 17.7.1990 of the

Orissa High Court in Crl. Rev. No. 382 of 1986.

Janaranjan Das for the Appellants.

A.K. Panda for the Respondent.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

RAY, J. Special leave granted. Arguments heard.

This appeal by special leave is directed against the

judgment and order dated July 17, 1990 passed by the High

Court of Orissa in Criminal Revision No. 382 of 1986

dismissing the revision and affirming the concurrent

findings of the courts below. The prosecution case in

short is that on 19th March, 1983 at about 7.p.m. while the

victim girl Srimanthini Samal (P.W. 2) was going to the

house of Rama Samal, for study, the appellant Gagan informed

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 6

her that the other appellant Prafulla and others had tied

her tutor Rabi Babu in a nearby mango grove and her father

was present there. Having believed the version of the

appellant Gagan, her agnatic uncle, she accompanied him and

ultimately the appellants forcibly took her to a lonely

house in hills where she was made to sit on a chair and the

appellant Gagan forcibly thrushed in her mouth a liquor

bottle and she was made to drink the liquor. Thereafter

both the appellants after having undressed her committed

sexual assault on her. Then she was brought to expression

highway from where she was bodily lifted to a truck standing

there and left her in the truck. While the said truck was

unloading materials near village Kurujanga, the victim girl

stealthily left the truck and concealed her presence near a

fence. Subsequently, one Purusottam Mohanty rescued her and

brought her to his house and then she was left to the house

of one Niranjan Rout (P.W. 8), who was distantly related to

her and took shelter till her father took her back on being

842

informed. On the information lodged by her father (P.W. 1)

in the police station of Badachana a case under sections 363

and 376 read with section 34 of the I.P.C. was registered

against the accused appellants and after investigation the

I.O. sent the victim girl as well as the appellants for

medical examination and after completion of the

investigation a charge sheet was submitted against the

appellants to stand their trial. The pleas of the

appellants were a total denial of the prosecution case. The

appellant Prafulla took the plea the there was a marriage

proposal of the victim girl with him but when it was

disclosed that she had illicit relationship with her tutor

Rabi, he refused to marry her for which this false case was

foisted against him. The plea of the other appellant Gagan

as suggested to the informant, was that due to his previous

enmity he was falsely implicated with the alleged crime.

The appellants were committed to the Court of Sessions.

The learned Assistant Sessions Judge after considering the

evidences on record rejected the defence pleas, and found

that the accused appellants committed rape on the victim

girl without her consent relying on the provisions of

Section 114(A) of the Evidence Act, and convicted them under

section 376(2)(g) I.P.C. and sentenced each of the accused

appellants to rigorous imprisonment for three years

considering the young age of the appellants. The Assistant

Sessions Judge, however, acquitted the appellants from the

charge under section 366 I.P.C. as the victim girl was more

than 16 years of age at the time of occurrence.

Against this judgment and order of conviction the

appellants filed an appeal being Criminal Appeal No. 153 of

1984 in the Court of First Additional Sessions Judge,

Cuttack. The Additional Sessions Judge considered the pleas

of the appellants as well as duly scrutinized and appraised

the evidences on record and found that the accused

appellants committed rape on the victim girl without her

consent and affirmed the conviction and sentence imposed by

the Trial Court dismissing the appeal.

The appellants thereafter filed a Revision Case being

Criminal Revision No. 382 of 1986 in the High Court of

Orissa at Cuttack against the said judgment and order passed

by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Cuttack. The High

Court duly considered and appraised the evidences of all the

9 P. Ws. including the deposition of the victim girl

Srimanthni Samal (P.W. 2), the evidence of her father (P.W.

1) as well as the evidence of her mother (P.W. 3) and the

evidences of the two Doctors (P.W. 4) and P.W. (5) and held

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 6

that the accused persons committed rap on P.W. 2 forcibly

without her con-

843

sent. It has been further found from the reliable evidences

of P.Ws. 1 and 3 that as soon as P.W. 2 met her mother, P.W.

3, P.W. 2 told her mother about both the accused persons

committing rape on her in a solitary house and also about

the accused persons taking her away to the highway and

keeping her in a truck, and corroborate the version of P.W.

2 regarding the occurrence of rape committed n her by both

the accused persons. It has been further observed that even

though the P.Ws. 7 and 8 became hostile still then their

evidences can be safely relied on as the same fully

corroborates the version of P.W. 2 that on the relevant

night the she, with the help of P.W. 7 had taken shelter in

the house of P.W. 8 P.W. 6 who the driver of the truck No.

ORG-4839 also stated in his evidence that the accused

persons and two others took the victim girl and left her in

the truck. P.W. 6 further admitted that as he stopped the

truck at village Ambura for unloading the boulders, the girl

had stealthily left his truck and inspite of his searching

her, he could not trace her. This fully supports the

version of P.W. 2 that she left the truck and concealed

herself near a fence in darkness. The learned Judge,

therefore, held "Hence, on a careful scrutiny of the

evidences of the hostile witnesses P.Ws. 6 and 8 it is seen

that even they corroborate the evidence of the victim gild,

P.W. 2 on material aspects of the prosecution case."

In cases of rape, generally it is difficult to find any

corroborative witnesses except the victim of the rape. It

has been observed by this Court in Bharwada Bhoginbhai

Hirjibhai v. State of Gujarat, AIR 1983 SC 753 as follows:

"Corroboration is not the sine qua non for a

conviction in a rape case. In the Indian setting,

refusal to act on the testimony of a victim of

sexual assault inthe absence of corroboration as a

rule, is adding insult to injury. Why should the

evidence of the girl or the woman who complains of

rape or sexual molestation be viewed with the aid

of spectacles fitted with lenses tinged with

doubt, disbelief or suspicion? To do so is to

justify the charge of male chauvinism in a male

dominated society.

A girl or a woman in the tradition bound non-

permissive society of India would be extremely

reluctant even to admit that only incident which is

likely to reflect on her chastity had ever

occurred. She would be conscious of the danger of

being ostracized by the society or being looked

down by the society including by her own family

members,

844

relatives, friends, and neighbours. She would face

the risk of losing the love and respect of her own

husband and near relatives, and of her matrimonial

home and happiness being shattered. If she is

unmarried, she would apprehend that it would be

difficult to secure an alliance with a suitable

match from a respectable or an acceptable family.

In view of these and similar factors, the victims

and their relatives are not too keen to bring the

culprit to book. And when in the face of these

factors the crime is brought to light there is a

built-in assurance that the charge is genuine

rather than fabricated."

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 5 of 6

The above observation has been made by this Court relying on

the earlier observations made by this Court in Rameshwar v.

The State of Rajasthan, [1982] SCR 377 with regard to

corroboration of girl's testimony and version. Vivian Bose,

J, who spoke for the Court observed as follows:

"The rule, which according to the case has hardened

into one of law, is not that corroboration is

essential before there can be a conviction but that

the necessity of corroboration, as a matter of

prudence, except where the circumstances make it

safe to dispense with it, must be present to the

mind of the judge, ...................The only rule

of law is that this rule of prudence must be

present to the mind of the judge or the jury as the

case may be and be understood and appreciated by

him or them. There is no rule of practice that

there must, in very case, be corroboration before a

conviction can be allowed to stand."

In the instant appeal as had been stated hereinbefore

that P.W. 2, the victim girl has clearly stated in her

evidence that she had been taken to a solitary house in the

hills by the appellant no. 1 Gagan Bihari Samal and there

she was made to drink liquor and thereafter she was

undressed and forcibly subjected to sexual intercourse by

both the accused appellants one after the other. He

uncontroverted testimony has been accepted by all the courts

and the courts concurrently found that she was raped without

her consent. It has been tried to be contended on behalf of

the appellants that the amended section 114(A) was brought

into the Evidence Act after the commission of the offence

for which the appellants were charged and as such no

assumption can be made on the basis of this provision. This

submission is of no avail in as much as it is clearly

evident that the victim girl protested and

845

struggled while she was subjected to sexual assault forcibly

by the accused persons and this clearly evinces absence of

consent on part of the victim girl in such sexual

intercourse apart from the legal presumption that follows

from the provisions of Section 114(A) of the Evidence Act.

The learned counsel on behalf of the appellants further

tried to argue on the basis of some minor discrepancies in

the evidences of P.W. 2 that the prosecution case was a

false one and it has been foisted on the appellants due to

enmity and also due to accused Prafulla, one of the

appellants, having disagreed to marry the victim girl. The

courts below have clearly found that the defence case was

not at all sub-stantiated by any cogent evidence. So this

contention is not at all tenable.

It is apropos to mention here the observation made by

this Court in the case of State of Orissa v. Nakula Sahu and

Ors., AIR 1979 SC 663 which are set-out herein:

"Although the revisional power of the High Court

under Section 439 read with section 435 is as wide

as the power of Court of appeal under Sec. 423 of

the Code, it is now well settled that normally the

jurisdiction of the High Court under Section 439 is

to be exercised only in exceptional cases when

there is a glaring defect in the procedure or there

is a manifest error on a point of law which has

consequently resulted in flagrant miscarriage of

justice. Inspite of the wide language of Section

435, the High Court is not excepted to act under

Section 435 or Section 439 as if it is hearing an

appeal."

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 6 of 6

The High Court of Orissa referred to the said observation

and rightly held that the High Court cannot be expected to

re-appraise the evidence as a court of appeal. This Court

hearing an appeal by special leave cannot consider and re-

appraise the evidences once again in the face of concurrent

findings of facts arrived at by all the courts below.

For the reasons aforesaid we dismiss the appeal and

uphold the conviction and sentence as found by the High

Court.

R.P. Appeal dismissed.

846

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter