0  08 Aug, 1988
Listen in mins | Read in 7:00 mins
EN
HI

Dilbagrai Punjabi Vs. Sharad Chandra

  Supreme Court Of India Civil Appeal /3387/1981
Link copied!

Case Background

Bench

Applied Acts & Sections

No Acts & Articles mentioned in this case

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 4

PETITIONER:

DILBAGRAI PUNJABI

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

SHARAD CHANDRA

DATE OF JUDGMENT08/08/1988

BENCH:

SHARMA, L.M. (J)

BENCH:

SHARMA, L.M. (J)

PATHAK, R.S. (CJ)

CITATION:

1988 AIR 1858 1988 SCR Supl. (2) 276

1988 SCC Supl. 710 JT 1988 (3) 308

1988 SCALE (2)523

ACT:

Civil Procedure Code. Section 100-Appeal-Subordinate

courts refuse to consider evidence having direct hearing on

disputed issue Error arising gives birth to a substantial

question of law-Whether High Court has jurisdiction to set

aside finding.

%

Madhya Pradesh Accommodation Control Act, 1961, Section

12(1) (f)-Suit for eviction of tenant for personal

necessity-Essential for plaintiff to prove ownership of

property-Partition deed by which ownership claimed not

produced-Effect of-Court under duty to examine other

relevant evidence on record.

HEADNOTE:

The respondent-plaintiff filed a suit under s. l2(l)(f)

of the Madhya Pradesh Accommodation Control Act, 196l, for

eviction of the appellant-tenant, on the ground of personal

necessity. The trial court rejected the plaintiffs claim

that he was the owner of the house in question.

On appeal, the Additional District.judge confirmed the

finding of the trial court on the ground that the plaintiff

did not produce the deed of partition, alleged to have been

executed by the parties and, under which the house in

question was said to have been allotted to him. In second

appeal, the High Court reversed the finding and decreed the

suit.

In the appeal to this Court, on behalf of the tenant it

was contended that it was essential for the plaintiff-

respondent to establish that he was the owner of the

premises, and that the concurrent finding of fact recorded

by first two courts was binding on the High Court under s.

100 of the Code of Civil Procedure and its reversal was

illegal.

Dismissing the appeal,

HELD: 1.1 The High Court's power to interfere with the

finding of fact reached by the first appellate court cannot

be denied if, when the lower appellate court decides an

issue of fact, a substantial question of law arises, even

PG NO 276

PG NO 277

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 4

though the High Court, while hearing the appeal under s. 100

of the Code of Civil Procedure, has no jurisdiction to re-

appraise the evidence and reverse the conclusion reached by

the first appellate court.[280C]

The court is under a duty to examine the entire relevant

evidence on record and if it refuses to consider important

evidence having direct B bearing on the disputed issue and

the error which arises is of a magnitude that it gives birth

to a substantial question of law, the High Court is fully

authorised to set aside the finding. [280D]

1.2 A perusal of the language of the clause (f) of s.

12(l) of the Madhya Pradesh Accommodation Control Act, 1961,

and comparison there of with that in the other clauses

clearly indicates that it is essential for the plaintiff who

claims that he requires the shop personally for starting a

business, to establish that he is the owner of the premises.

[278G-H]

In the instant case, though the partition deed under

which the D plaintiff claims exclusive title to the

property was not produced in court, the first appellate

court was under a duty to consider all the relevant evidence

led by the parties along with the circumstances. The Civil

Judge, who tried the suit as well as the Additional District

Judge, confirming the decision of the trial court, had

seriously erred in not considering the entire evidence on

record including the reply to the notice sent by the

plaintiff-respondent, wherein the tenant-appellant has

accepted the plaintiff's title and counter-foil receipts

signed by the appellant in which the plaintiff had been

described as the owner of the property. In the

circumstances, the High Court was fully justified in

reversing the finding of the courts below. [279E, F-G, 280A]

JUDGMENT:

CIVlL APPELLATE JURlSDlCTlON: Civil Appeal No. 3387 of

1981

From the Judgment and Order dated 20.8.1981 of the

Madhya Pradesh High Court in Second Appeal No. 33 of 1978.

S.N. Kacker, Sanjay Sareen and S.K. Gambhir for the

Appellant.

S.K. Jain for the Respondent.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

PG NO 278

SHARMA,J. The appellant is in possession of a shop in a

town in Madhya Pradesh as a tenant under the respondent who

filed a suit out of which the present appeal arises for his

eviction on the ground of personal necessity. The suit was

dismissed by the trial court and the first appellate court.

The High Court in second appeal has reversed the decision

and passed a decree.

2. The case is governed by the Madhya Pradesh

Accommodation Control Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as

the Act) and s. 12(1)(f) deals with the ground of landlord's

bona fide necessity with reference to buildings let out for

non-residential purposes, in the following words:

"12. Restriction on eviction of tenants-(l)

Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any

other law or contract, no suit shall be filed in any Civil

Court against a tenant for his eviction from any

accommodation except on one or more of the following grounds

only, namely :

(a) -----------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 4

(f) that the accommodation let for non-residential

purposes is required bona fide by the landlord for the

purpose of continuing or starting his business or that of

any of his major sons or unmarried daughters if he is the

owner thereof or for any person for whose benefit the

accommodation is held and that the land- lord or such person

has no other reasonably suitable non-residential

accommodation of his own in his occupation in the city or

town concerned ;

(g) .........................................

.........................................

3. The plaintiff claims that he requires the shop

personally for starting a business and it is rightly

contended by Mr. Kacker, learned counsel appearing for the

appellant, that it is essential for him to establish that he

is the owner of the premises. A perusal of the language of

the clause (f) and a comparison thereof with that in the

other clauses clearly leads to this conclusion. The issue in

the case is whether the plaintiff, respondent before us, has

been able to establish this condition.

PG NO 279

4. The defendant has been admittedly paying the rent to

the plaintiff who, therefore, is included in the expression

'landlord' as defined in the Act as a person receiving or

entitled to receive the rent whether on his own account or

on account of any other person. In the register of the

Municipal Corporation the property stands in the name of the

plaintiff's brother Hukum Chand Jain. On this ground the

trial court rejected the plaintiff's case that the shop

belongs to him. On appeal the Additional District Judge,

Gwalior confirmed the finding mainly on the ground that the

plaintiff did not produce the deed of partition which is

alleged to have been executed by the parties and under which

the house was claimed by the plaintiff to have been allotted

to him. The Court also held that since the plaintiff failed

to plead his ownership and further neglected to get his

plaint amended after his title was denied in the written

statement, he was not entitled to rely on any evidence in

support of his title. On the plaintiff filing a second

appeal, the Madhya Pradesh High Court reversed the finding

and decreed the suit.

5. Mr. Kacker strongly urged that the concurrent finding

of fact recorded by the first two courts was binding on the

High Court under s. 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure and

its reversal is illegal. We have gone through all the three

judgments and some of the documents placed before us by the

learned counsel for the parties and we find that the High

Court was fully justified in reversing the finding. The

first appellate court was not correct in assuming that the

plaintiff had failed to assert in the plaint his ownership

of the disputed shop. The necessary pleading is to be found

in paragraph 1 of the plaint, which of course was denied in

the written statement and the parties led their evidence on

this question at the trial. It is true that the partition

deed under which the plaintiff claims exclusive title to the

property was not produced in court, but the first appellate

court was under a duty to consider all the relevant evidence

led by the parties along with the circumstances.

Unfortunately neither the Civil Judge who tried the suit nor

the Additional District Judge confirming the decision of the

trial court adverted to important items of relevant evidence

which were considered and relied upon by the High Court. The

plaintiff, before filing the suit, sent a notice through his

counsel, to the appellant in which it was stated that the

shop in question belongs to him. In his reply sent through

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 4

an advocate the appellant, while denying the other

statements in the notice, accepted the plaintiff's title in

the following words :

"That it is admitted that my client is occupying the

shop situated at Dal Bazar belonging to your client. . . . "

PG NO 280

The plaintiff also produced counter foil receipts signed

by the tenant-appellant in which the plaintiff was described

as "the owner of property". It was not a case of an isolated

single receipt-quite a number of such documents were

produced in the trial court. The High Court was right in

pointing out that the courts below had seriously erred in

not considering the entire evidence on the record including

the aforesaid documents. It is true that the High Court

while hearing the appeal under s. 100 of the Code of Civil

Procedure has no jurisdiction to re-appraise the evidence

and reverse the conclusion reached by the first appellate

court, but at the same time its power to interfere with the

finding cannot be denied if when the lower appellate court

decides an issue of fact a substantial question of law

arises. The court is under a duty to examine the entire

relevant evidence on record and if it refuses to consider

important evidence having direct bearing on the disputed

issue and the error which arises is of a magnitude that it

gives birth to a substantial question of law, the High Court

is fully authorised to set aside the finding. This is the

situation in the present case. We, therefore, do not

discover any defect in the judgment of the High Court, and

the appeal is accordingly dismissed with costs.

N.P.V. Appeal dismissed.

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter