As per case facts, Flipkart Internet Private Ltd challenged the grant of Indian Patent Number 312437 to Voicemonk Inc. by the Joint Controller of Patents and Designs. The patent, relating ... to "SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR VIRTUAL AGENTS TO HELP CUSTOMERS AND BUSINESS", was opposed on grounds of lacking novelty and inventive step, among others. The Controller dismissed the post-grant opposition, leading to the current appeal to the High Court. The question arose whether the first respondent considered all relevant materials while rendering their findings. Finally, the High Court determined that the first respondent conducted a detailed analysis of the patent claims against cited prior art, concluding that the invention's unique characterized features and correlation modes were absent in the prior art. The court found no infirmity in the impugned order, dismissing the appeal.