As per case facts, the plaintiff, Onkar Singh, filed a suit for permanent injunction against the Municipal Council, Hoshiarpur, to stop the construction of a Rehri market and parking on ... his claimed land. Both lower courts dismissed the suit, citing the plaintiff's failure to establish the land's identity and the Municipal Council's encroachment. The High Court, noting the dispute over land identity and location, ordered a fresh demarcation. The question arose whether the lower courts' findings on property identity and defendant's non-encroachment could be sustained given the new demarcation and the defendant's previous admissions of controlling the site and charging Tehbazari. Finally, the High Court determined that the demarcation confirmed the Rehri market on the plaintiff's land, and the Municipal Corporation could not evade responsibility after previously asserting control. The High Court partly allowed the appeal, directing the Municipal Corporation to remove the Rehri market encroachment within six months and restore possession to the plaintiff, while also suggesting exploring alternative sites for Rehri owners.