0  13 Mar, 1989
Listen in 01:32 mins | Read in 19:00 mins
EN
HI

A.B.C. Laminart Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. Vs. A.P. Agencies, Salem

  Supreme Court Of India Civil Appeal /2682/1982
Link copied!

Case Background

As per case facts, the first appellant, a manufacturer, and its sister concern, entered into an agreement with the Respondent, a partnership firm, to supply metallic yarn. A dispute arose ...

Bench

Applied Acts & Sections

No Acts & Articles mentioned in this case

Hello! How can I help you? 😊
Disclaimer: We do not store your data.
Document Text Version

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 18

PETITIONER:

A.B.C. LAMINART PVT. LTD. & ANR.

Vs.

RESPONDENT:

A.P. AGENCIES, SALEM

DATE OF JUDGMENT13/03/1989

BENCH:

SAIKIA, K.N. (J)

BENCH:

SAIKIA, K.N. (J)

OZA, G.L. (J)

CITATION:

1989 AIR 1239 1989 SCR (2) 1

1989 SCC (2) 163 JT 1989 (2) 38

1989 SCALE (1)633

CITATOR INFO :

RF 1992 SC1124 (4,9)

ACT:

Sections 23 & 28---Indian Contract Act--Parties

to

contract agree to submit dispute to the jurisdiction of

a

particular court--Interpretation of clauses of such co

n-

tract-Ouster clause II--Interpretation and constructi

on

of--In particular:

Section 9--Civil Procedure Code-Civil court--Jurisdi

c-

tion-Ouster of--Interpretation of clauses of contract.

Statutory Interpretation 'Ouster clause '--Construction of

.

Words and Phrases 'Ex dolo malo non orit

ur

actio'--'expressio unus est exclusio alterius'--meaning of

.

HEADNOTE:

The first appellant is a manufacturer and supplier

of

metallic yarn under the name and style "Raplon Mettal

ic

Yarn" having its registered office at Udyognagar, Mohamad

a-

bad, Gujarat within the jurisdiction of the civil court

at

Kaira. The second appellant is the sister concern of t

he

first appellant.

The Respondent is a registered partnership firm doi

ng

business in metallic yarn and other allied products

at

Salem. The first appellant entered into an agreement wi

th

the Respondent on 2.10.74 whereunder the appellants were

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 2 of 18

to

supply 5000 bobbins of Ruplon Metallic Yarn to the Respon

d-

ent at the rate of Rs.35 per bobbin as stipulated in t

he

terms of the agreement. Under clause (11) of the agreeme

nt

it was provided that any dispute arising out of this sa

le

shall be subject to Kaira jurisdiction. Dispute havi

ng

arisen out of this contract, the Respondent filed a su

it

against the appellants in the court of Subordinate Judge

at

Salem for the recovery of Rs.1,63,240 being the balance

of

the advance in the hands of the appellants and also for

a

sum of Rs.2,40,000 towards damages. The appellants int

er

alia took preliminary objection that the Subordinate Jud

ge

at Salem had no jurisdiction to entertain the Suit as t

he

parties by express contract had agreed to confer exclusi

ve

jurisdiction in regard to ali disputes arising out of t

he

contract on the civil court at Kaira. The trial court uphe

ld

the prelimi-

2

nary objection and found that it had, in view of clause (1

1)

of the contract, no jurisdiction to entertain the' suit.

It

accordingly returned the plaint for presentation before t

he

proper court.

The Respondent appealed to the High Court against t

he

order of the .Subordinate Judge. The High Court allowed t

he

appeal, set aside the Judgment of the trial court, with

a

direction to take the plaint on file and dispose of the su

it

on merits and on other issues.

Hence this appeal by the appellants. Dismissing t

he

appeal, this Court,

HELD: That an agreement to oust absolutely the jurisdi

c-

tion of the court will be unlawful and void being again

st

the public policy, Ex-dolo malo non oritur actio. [6G]

The jurisdiction of the court in the matter of a co

n-

tract will depend on the situs of the contract, and t

he

cause of action arising through connecting factors. [7B-C]

So long as the parties to a contract do not oust t

he

jurisdiction of all the courts which would otherwise ha

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 3 of 18

ve

jurisdiction to decide the cause of action under the law,

it

cannot be said that the parties have by their contra

ct

ousted the jurisdiction ofthe court. [8G]

Where the parties to a contract agreed to submit t

he

disputes arising from it to a particular jurisdiction whi

ch

would otherwise also be a proper jurisdiction under the la

w,

their agreement to the extent they agreed not to submit

to

other jurisdictions cannot be said to be void as again

st

public policy. If on the other hand the jurisdiction th

ey

agree to submit to would not otherwise be proper, jurisdi

c-

tion to decide disputes arising out of the contract it mu

st

be declared void being against public policy. [8H; 9A-B]

Where there may be two or more competent courts whi

ch

can entertain a suit consequent upon a part of the cause

of

action having arisen there-within if the parties to t

he

contract agreed to vest jurisdiction on one such court

to

try the dispute which might arise as between themselves t

he

agreement would be valid. If such a contract is clea

r,

unambiguous and explicit and not vague, it is not hit

by

sections 23 & 28 of the Contract Act. This cannot be unde

r-

stood as parties contracting against the Statute. Mercanti

le

Law and Practice permit such agreements. [11B-C]

3

Where such an ouster clause occurs, it is pertinent

to

see whether there is ouster of jurisdiction of other court

s.

When the clause is clear, unambiguous and specific accept

ed

notions of contract would bind the parties and unless t

he

absence of ad idem can be shown the other courts shou

ld

avoid exercising jurisdiction. As regards construction

of

the ouster clause, when words like 'alone', 'only' 'excl

u-

sive', and the like have been used, there may be no diff

i-

culty. Even without such words in appropriate cases t

he

maxim "expressio unius est exclusio alterius'-expression

of

one is the exclusion of another may be applied. What is

an

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 4 of 18

appropriate case shall depend on the facts of the case.

In

such a case mention of one thing may imply exclusion

of

another. Where certain jurisdiction is specified in t

he

contract, an intention to exclude all others from its oper

a-

tion may in such cases be inferred. It has therefore to

be

properly construed. [12E-G]

" S. Manuel Raj & Co. v .J. Muni Lal & Co., AIR 19

63

Gujarat 148; Sri Rajendra Mills v. Hal Hassan, AIR 1970 Ca

l.

342; Hakam Singh v. M/s. Gammon (India) Ltd., [1971] 3 S

CR

314; Nanak Chand v. T.T. Elect. Supply Co., AIR 1975 M

ad

103; Naziruddin v. V.A. Annamalai & Ors., [1978] 2, MLJ 25

4;

Snehal Kumar Sarabhai v. E.T. Orgn., AIR 1975 Gujarat 72 a

nd

Salem Chemical Industries v. Bird & Co., AIR 1979 Mad. 1

6,

referred to.

JUDGMENT:

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION.: Civil Appeal No. 2682

of

1982

From the Judgment and Order dated 4.11.1980 of t

he

Madras High Court in C.M.A. No. 218 of 1978

Pinaki Mishra, Shishir Sharma and P.H. Parekh for the Appe

l-

lants.

S.S. Javeli, B.R. Agarwala and R.B. Hathikhanavala f

or

the Respondent.

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

K.N. SAIKIA, J. This is an appeal by special leave fr

om

the judgment and order of the High Court at Madras dated 4

th

November, 1980 in C.M.A. No. 218 of 1978 allowing the appe

al

and setting aside the judgment of the Subordinate Judge

at

Salem in original suit No 302 of 1975 on the prelimina

ry

question of jurisdiction.

4

The first appellant is a manufacturer and supplier

of

metallic yarn under the name and style 'Rupalon Metall

ic

Yarn' having its registered office at Udyognagar, Mohamad

a-

bad, Gujarat within the jurisdiction of the Civil Court

of

Kaira. The second appellant is a sister concern of the fir

st

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 5 of 18

appellant doing business with it. The respondent is a regi

s-

tered partnership firm doing business in metallic yarn a

nd

other allied products at Salem.

The first petitioner entered into an agreement with t

he

respondent on 2.10.1974 whereunder the appellants were

to

supply 5000 bobbins of Rupalon Metallic Yarn to the respon

d-

ent at the rate of Rs.35 per bobbin as stipulated in diffe

r-

ent clauses of the agreement. Clause 11 of the agreeme

nt

provided as follows:

"Any dispute arising out of this sale shall be subject

to

Kaira jurisdiction."

Disputes having arisen out of the contract the responde

nt

filed a suit, being original suit No. 302 of 1975, again

st

the appellants in the Court of Subordinate Judge at Sal

em

for the recovery of a sum of Rs. 1,63,240 claiming to be t

he

balance of the advance remaining in the hands of the appe

l-

lants and also a sum of Rs.2.40,000 towards damages. T

he

appellants took a number of defences and also took a preli

m-

inary objection that the Subordinate Judge at Salem had

no

jurisdiction to entertain the suit as parties by expre

ss

contract had agreed to confer exclusive jurisdiction

in

regard to all disputes arising out of the contract on t

he

civil Court at Kaira.

The Trial Court, inter alia, framed issue No. 2 as follows

:

"Issue No. 2. Has the court no jurisdiction to entertain

or

try this suit?"

The learned Court treating it as a preliminary issue in i

ts

judgment dated 18.4.1978 found that it had no jurisdicti

on

to entertain the suit in view of Clause 11 and according

ly

it returned the Plaint for presentation in the proper cour

t.

The respondent appealed therefrom, in C.M.A. No. 218

of

1978, to the High Court of Madras which by the impugn

ed

Judgment and Order dated 4.11.1980 allowed the appea

l,

setting aside the judgment of the Trial Court with a dire

c-

tion to take the plaint on file and dispose of the suit

on

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 6 of 18

merits on other issues. Hence this appeal.

5

Mr. Pinaki Misra, the learned counsel for the appe

l-

lants, submits that Clause 11 of the agreement having pr

o-

vided that any dispute arising out of this sale shall

be

subject to Kaira jurisdiction, the parties are bound by

it

and the suit could therefore have been filed only with

in

Kaira jurisdiction and not at Salem, and as such, the Hi

gh

Court committed error of law in setting aside the Tri

al

Court judgment and in directing the Court as Salem to ente

r-

tain the suit. Mr. S.S. Javali, the learned counsel for t

he

respondent, submits that what is being called Clause 11

of

the agreement was only one of the general terms and cond

i-

tions of the sale and not a clause in the agreement, a

nd

that even if it was construed as a clause in the agreeme

nt

itself it was not exclusive so as to take away all jurisdi

c-

tions except that of Kaira.

The first question to be decided, therefore, is wheth

er

Clause 11 as aforesaid formed part of.the agreement. M

r.

Javali submits that Ext. B-1 is an order of confirmation N

o.

68/59 dated 2.10.1974 from the Sales Executive for the fir

st

appellant to the respondent acknowledging the receipt

of

their order and registering the same subject to the ter

ms

and conditions 'overleaf'. The general terms and conditio

ns

printed overleaf included the aforesaid Clause 11. We a

re

unable to agree. Admittedly the parties have transacted t

he

business on inter alia basis of Clause 11. There is, ther

e-

fore, no escape from the conclusion that Clause 11 form

ed

part of the agreement and the parties would be bound by

it

so long as they would be bound by the contract itself. It

is

not open to the respondent to deny existence of Clause 1

1.

The submission of Mr. Javali has, therefore, to be rejecte

d.

The next question is whether Clause 11 is valid, and

if

so, What would be its effect? As Clause 11 formed part

of

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 7 of 18

the agreement it would be valid only if the parties cou

ld

have validly agreed to it. It is common knowledge that t

he

law of contract only prescribes certain limiting principl

es

within which parties are free to make their own contract

s.

An agreement enforceable at law is a contract. An agreeme

nt

which purports to oust the jurisdiction of the Court abs

o-

lutely is contrary to public policy and hence void. Each

of

the citizens has the right to have his legal position dete

r-

mined by the ordinary Tribunal except, of course, in

a

contract (a) when there is an arbitration clause which

is

valid and binding under the law, and (b) when parties to

a

contract agree as to the jurisdiction to which disputes

in

respect of the contract shah be subject. "It has long be

en

established", say Cheshire and Fifoot, "that a contra

ct

which purports to destroy the right of one or both of t

he

parties to submit questions of law to the courts is contra

ry

to public policy and is void pro tanto". However, arbitr

a-

tion is a

6

statutory mode of settlement; and as a matter of commerci

al

law and practice parties to a contract may agree as to t

he

jurisdiction to which all or any disputes on or arising o

ut

of the contract shall be subject.

Section 28 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 provid

es

that every agreement by which any party thereto is restric

t-

ed absolutely from enforcing his fights under or in respe

ct

of any contract, by the usual legal proceedings in t

he

ordinary tribunal, or which limits the time within which

he

may thus enforce his fights, is void to that extent. This

is

subject to exceptions, namely, (1) contract to refer

to

arbitration and to abide by its award, (2) as a matter

of

commercial law and practice to submit disputes on or

in

respect of the contract to agreed proper jurisdiction a

nd

not other jurisdictions though proper. The . principle

of

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 8 of 18

Private International Law that the parties should be bou

nd

by the jurisdiction clause to which they have agreed unle

ss

there is some reason to contrary is being applied to munic

i-

pal contracts. In Lee v. Showmen's Guild, [1952] 1 All E.

R.

1175 at 1181 Lord Denning said:

"Parties cannot by contract oust the ordinary courts fr

om

their jurisdiction. They can, of course, agree to lea

ve

questions of law, as well as questions of fact, to t

he

decision of the domestic tribunal. They can, indeed, ma

ke

the tribunal the final arbiter on questions of fact, b

ut

they cannot make it the final arbiter on questions of la

w.

They cannot prevent its decisions being examined by t

he

courts. If parties should seek, by agreement, to take t

he

law out of the hands of the courts and put it into the han

ds

of a private tribunal, without any recourse at all to t

he

courts in cases of error of law, then the agreement is

to

that extent contrary to public policy and void."

Under section 23 of the Indian Contract Act the consi

d-

eration or object of an agreement is lawful, unless it

is

opposed to public policy. Every agreement of which t

he

object or consideration is unlawful is void. Hence there c

an

be no doubt that an agreement to oust absolutely the juri

s-

diction of the Court will be unlawful and void being again

st

the public policy. Ex dolo malo non oritur actio. If ther

e-

fore it is found in this case that Clause 11 has absolute

ly

ousted the jurisdiction of the Court it would be again

st

public policy. However, such will be the result only if

it

can be shown that the jurisdiction to which the parties ha

ve

agreed to submit had nothing to do with the contract. If

on

the other hand it is found that the jurisdiction agre

ed

would also be

7

a proper jurisdiction in the matter of the contract it cou

ld

not be said that it ousted the jurisdiction of the Cour

t.

This leads to the question in the facts of this case as

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 9 of 18

to

whether Kaira would be proper jurisdiction in the matter

of

this contract. It would also be relevant to examine if so

me

other courts than that of Kaira would also have had juri

s-

diction in the absence of Clause 11 and whether that wou

ld

amount to ouster of jurisdiction of those courts and wou

ld

thereby affect the validity of the clause.

The jurisdiction of the Court in matter of a contra

ct

will depend on the situs of the contract and the cause

of

action arising through connecting factors.

A cause of action means every fact, which, if traverse

d,

it would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove in order

to

support his right to a judgment of the Court. In oth

er

words, it is a bundle of facts which taken with the l

aw

applicable to them gives the plaintiff a fight to reli

ef

against the defendant. It must include some act done by t

he

defendant since in the absence of such an act no cause

of

action can possibly accrue. It is not limited to the actu

al

infringement of the fight sued on but includes all t

he

material facts on which it is founded. It does not compri

se

evidence necessary to prove such facts, but every fa

ct

necessary for the plaintiff to prove to enable him to obta

in

a decree. Everything which if not proved would give t

he

defendant a fight to immediate judgment must be part of t

he

cause of action. But it has no relation whatever to t

he

defence which may be set up by the defendant nor does

it

depend upon the character of the relief prayed for by t

he

plaintiff.

Under section 20(c) of the Code of Civil Procedu

re

subject to the limitation stated therebefore, every su

it

shall be instituted in a court within the local limits

of

whose jurisdiction the cause of action, wholly or in pa

rt

arises. It may be remembered that earlier section 7 of Act

7

of 1888 added Explanation III as under:

"Explanation III--In suits arising out of contract the cau

se

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 10 of 18

of action arises within the meaning of this section at a

ny

of the following places, namely:

(1) the place where the contract was made;

(2) the place where the contract was to be perform

ed

or performance thereof completed;

8

(3) the place where in performance of the contract a

ny

money to which the suit relates was expressly or implied

ly

payable."

The above Explanation III has not been omitted b

ut

nevertheless it may serve a guide. There must be a connec

t-

ing factor.

In the matter of a contract there may arise causes

of

action of various kinds. In a suit for damages for breach

of

contract the cause of action consists of the making of t

he

contract, and of its breach, so that the suit may be fil

ed

either at the place where the contract was made or at t

he

place where it should have been performed and the brea

ch

occurred. The making of the contract is part of the cause

of

action. A suit on a contract, therefore, can be filed at t

he

place where it was made. The determination of the pla

ce

where the contract was made is part of the Law of Contrac

t.

But making of an offer on a particular place does not fo

rm

cause of action in a suit for damages for breach of co

n-

tract. Ordinarily, acceptance of an offer and its intimati

on

result in a contract and hence a suit can be filed in

a

court within whose jurisdiction the acceptance was commun

i-

cated. The performance of a contract is part of cause

of

action and a suit in respect of the breach can always

be

filed at the place where the contract should have perform

ed

or its performance completed. If the contract is to

be

performed at the place where it is made, the suit on t

he

contract is to be filed there and nowhere else. In suits f

or

agency actions the cause of action arises at the place whe

re

the contract of agency was made or the place where actio

ns

are to be rendered and payment is to be made by the agen

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 11 of 18

t.

Part of cause of action arises where money is expressly

or

impliedly payable under a contract. In cases of repudiati

on

of a contract, the place where repudiation is received

is

the place where the suit would lie. If a contract is plead

ed

as part of the cause of action giving jurisdiction to t

he

Court where the suit is filed and that contract is found

to

be invalid, such part of cause of the action disappears T

he

above are some of the connecting factors.

So long as the parties to a contract do not oust t

he

jurisdiction of all the Courts which would otherwise ha

ve

jurisdiction to decide the cause of action under the law

it

cannot be said that the parties have by their contra

ct

ousted the jurisdiction of the Courts. If under the l

aw

several Courts would have jurisdiction and the parties ha

ve

agreed to submit to one of these jurisdictions and not

to

other or others of them it cannot be said that there

is

total ouster of jurisdiction. In other words, where t

he

parties to a contract agreed to submit the disputes

9

arising from it to a particular jurisdiction which wou

ld

otherwise also be a proper jurisdiction under the law the

ir

agreement to the extent they agreed not to submit to oth

er

jurisdictions cannot be said to be void as against publ

ic

policy. If on the other hand the jurisdiction they agreed

to

submit to would not otherwise be proper jurisdiction

to

decide disputes arising out of the contract it must

be

declared void being against public policy. Would this be t

he

position in the instant case?

In S. Manuel Raj & Co. v. J. Manilal & Co., AIR 19

63

Guj. 148 where one of the parties to the contract signed

an

order form printed by the other party containing the wor

ds

"subject to Madras jurisdiction" and sent the order form

to

the other party it was held that the party must be assum

ed

to have agreed that Madras was the place for settlement

of

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 12 of 18

the dispute and it was not open to that person who sign

ed

the order form of the opposite party containing the print

ed

words to show that printed words were not part of the co

n-

tract and that those words in the contract was to exclu

de

the jurisdiction of other Courts and to keep sole jurisdi

c-

tion to one Court. It was observed that the object of prin

t-

ing such words as "subject to Madras jurisdiction" in t

he

contract was to exclude the jurisdiction of other Courts a

nd

to give sole jurisdiction to one Court and it was in cons

o-

nance with the commercial practice in India. Similarly

in

Sri Rajendra Mills v. Haji Hassan, A.I.R. 1970 Cal. 3

42

where there was a contract between the plaintiff and defen

d-

ant No. 1 under which the parties agreed that all sui

ts

arising on or out of the contract, would be instituted

in

the Court at Salem, the Division Bench held that it was tr

ue

that the suit could have been instituted either at Salem

or

at Howrah under section 20(c) of the Code of Civil Proc

e-

dure, as the cause of action, admittedly arose in part

in

both the places and it was therefore a case where two Cour

ts

had concurrent jurisdiction and, in such a case, it was op

en

to the parties to make a choise restricting the Court

in

which the suit under or upon the contract could be institu

t-

ed. In other words, both the Courts having territori

al

jurisdiction, the parties by their agreement waived the

ir

right, to institute any action, as aforesaid except

at

Salem. It was observed that under those circumstances it w

as

not open to the plaintiff to object to the order for retu

rn

of the plaint for presentation to the Court at Salem as t

he

choice of forum in case of alternative forums lies with t

he

plaintiff and the plaintiff having debarred or preclud

ed

itself from going to any other Court except at Salem whi

ch

would be a proper Court as against the defendants it wou

ld

not be just to allow the plaintiff at the instance of a

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 13 of 18

ny

other party or under cover of its objection to institute t

he

suit except in-the Court at Salem.

10

In Hakam Singh v. M/s. Gammon (India) Ltd., [1971]

3

S.C.R. 3 14 where the appellant agreed to do certain co

n-

struction work for the respondent who had its princip

al

place of business at Bombay on the terms and conditions of

a

written tender. Clause 12 of the tender provided for arb

i-

tration in case of dispute. Clause 13 provided that notwit

h-

standing the place where the work under the contract was

to

be executed the contract shall be deemed to have been e

n-

tered into by the parties at Bombay, and the Court in Bomb

ay

alone shall have jurisdiction to adjudicate upon. On dispu

te

arising between the parties the appellant submitted a pet

i-

tion to the Court at Varanasi for an order under section

20

of the Arbitration Act, 1940 that the agreement be filed a

nd

an order of reference be made to an arbitrator or arbitr

a-

tors appointed by the Court. The respondent contended th

at

in view of the Clause 13 of the arbitration agreement on

ly

the Courts at Bombay had jurisdiction. The Trial Court al

so

held that the entire cause of action had arisen at Varana

si

and the parties could not by agreement confer jurisdicti

on

on the Courts at Bombay which they did not otherwise po

s-

sess. The High Court in re vision held that the Courts

at

Bombay had jurisdiction under the general law and hen

ce

could entertain the petition and that in view of Clause

13

of the arbitration agreement the petition could not

be

entertained at Varanasi and directed the petition to

be

returned for presentation to the proper Court. On appe

al

therefrom one of the questions that fell for considerati

on

of this Court was whether the Courts at Bombay alone h

ad

jurisdiction over the dispute.It was held that the Code

of

Civil Procedure in its entirety applied to proceedings und

er

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 14 of 18

the Arbitration Act by virtue of section 41 of that Act. T

he

jurisdiction of the Court under the Arbitration Act

to

entertain a proceeding for filing an award was according

ly

governed by the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedur

e.

By the terms of section 20(a) of the Code of Civil Procedu

re

read with explanation 11 thereto the respondent compa

ny

which had its principal place of business at Bombay w

as

liable to be sued at Bombay. 1t was held that it was n

ot

open to the parties to agreement to confer by their agre

e-

ment jurisdiction on a Court which did not possess under t

he

Code. But where two Courts or more have under the Code

of

Civil Procedure jurisdiction to try the suit or proceedi

ng

an agreement between the parties that the dispute betwe

en

them shall be tried in one of such Courts was not contra

ry

to public policy and such an agreement did not contrave

ne

section 28 of the Contract Act. Though this case arose o

ut

of an arbitration agreement there is no reason why the sa

me

rule should not apply to other agreements in so far

as

jurisdiction is concerned. Without referring to this dec

i-

sion a Division Bench of the Madras High Court in Nan

ak

Chand v. T.T. Elect Supply Co., A.I.R. 1975 Madras

11

103 observed that competency of a Court to try an acti

on

goes to the root of the matter and when such competency

is

not found, it has no jurisdiction at all to try the cas

e.

But objection based on jurisdiction is a matter which pa

r-

ties could waive and it is in this sense if such jurisdi

c-

tion is exercised by Courts it does not go to the core of

it

so as to make the resultant judgment a nullity. Thus it

is

now a settled principle that where there may be two or mo

re

competent Courts which can entertain a suit consequent up

on

a part of the cause of action having arisen therewithin,

if

the parties to the contract agreed to vest jurisdiction

in

one such court to try the dispute which might arise

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 15 of 18

as

between themselves the agreement would be valid. If such

a

contract is clear, unambiguous and explicit and not vague

it

is not hit by sections 23 and 28 of the Contract Act. Th

is

can not be understood as parties contracting against t

he

Statute. Mercantile Law and Practice permit such agreement

s.

In Nazirrudin v. V.A. Annamalai & Ors., [1978] 2 M.L.

J.

254 where the question was whether Rule 35 of U.P. Sta

te

Lottery Rules, 1969 confined the jurisdiction only to Lu

c-

know. The Rule said: "35. Legal jurisdiction in all matte

rs

concerning the State lottery shall be Lucknow." The so

le

question for consideration therefore was whether the abo

ve

Rule had the effect of vesting exclusive jurisdiction on

ly

in the Courts in Lucknow and thereby taking away the juri

s-

diction which the subordinate judge court at Veilore cou

ld

have if it was established that the lottery ticket w

as

stolen within the jurisdiction of that Court from the fir

st

respondent. Held, it was well established that the jurisdi

c-

tion of a Civil Court can be taken away only by an expre

ss

provision or by necessary implication and ousting of

a

jurisdiction of Civil Court should not and ought not

be

inferred from an ambiguous provision. In that particul

ar

case it was common case of the parties that Rule 35 did n

ot

expressly take away the jurisdiction of any other Court, a

nd

vest the exclusive jurisdiction only in the Courts at Lu

c-

know. A note of caution was sounded by M.P. Thakkar, J.

as

he then was, in Snehal Kumar Sarabhai v. E.T. Orgn., A.I.

R.

1975 Guj. 72 observing that the ouster clause could opera

te

as estoppel against the parties to the contract, but

it

could not tie the hands of the Court and denude it of t

he

powers to do justice. Ordinarily, it was observed: t

he

Courts would respect the agreement between the parties whi

ch

was borne out of the meeting of their minds out of conside

r-

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 16 of 18

ation of convenience, but the Courts were not obliged to

do

so in every case; and that a new approach to the questi

on

deserved to be made where the ouster clause was "calculat

ed

to operate as an engine of oppression and as a means

to

defeat the ends of justice." In such a case the free conse

nt

may be

12

wanting and injustice may be avoided.

When the Court has to decide the question of jurisdi

c-

tion pursuant to an ouster clause it is necessary to co

n-

strue the ousting expression or clause properly. Often t

he

stipulation is that the contract shall be deemed to ha

ve

been made at a particular place. This would provide t

he

connecting factor for jurisdiction to the Courts of th

at

place in the matter of any dispute on or arising out of th

at

contract. It would not, however, ipso facto take away juri

s-

diction of other Courts. Thus, in Salem Chemical Industri

es

v. Bird & Co., A.I.R. 1979 Madras 16 where the terms a

nd

conditions attached to the quotation contained an arbitr

a-

tion clause provided that: "any order placed against this

quotation shall be deemed to be a contract made in Calcut

ta

and any dispute arising therefrom shall be settled by

an

Arbitrator to be jointly appointed by us", it was held th

at

it merely fixed the situs of the contract at Calcutta and

it

did not mean to confer an exclusive jurisdiction on t

he

Court at Calcutta, and when a part of the cause of acti

on

had arisen at Salem, the Court there had also jurisdicti

on

to entertain the suit under section 20(c) of the Code

of

Civil Procedure.

From the foregoing decisions it can be reasonably d

e-

duced that where such an ouster clause occurs, it is pert

i-

nent to see whether there is ouster of jurisdiction of oth

er

Courts. When the clause is clear, unambiguous and specif

ic

accepted notions of contract would bind the parties a

nd

unless the absence of ad idem can be shown, the other Cour

ts

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 17 of 18

should avoid exercising jurisdiction. As regards constru

c-

tion of the ouster clause when words like 'alone', 'only

',

'exclusive' and the like have been used there may be

no

difficulty. Even without such words in appropriate cass

es

the maxim 'expressio unius est exclusio alterius'--expre

s-

sion of one is the exclusion of another may be applied. Wh

at

is an appropriate case shall depend on the facts of t

he

case. In such a case mention of one thing may imply excl

u-

sion of another. When certain jurisdiction is specified in

a

contract an intention to exclude all others from its oper

a-

tion may in such cases be inferred. It has therefore to

be

properly construed.

Coming to clause 11 we already found that this clau

se

was included in the general terms and conditions of sale a

nd

the order or confirmation No. 68/59 dated 2.10.1974 with t

he

general terms and conditions was sent from Udyognaga

r,

Mohmadabad, Gujarat to the respondent's address at 12 Sur

a-

mangalam Road Salem, Tamilnadu. The statement made in t

he

Special Leave Petition that Udyognagar, Mohamadabad, Gujar

at

is within the jurisdiction of the Civil Court of

13

Kaira has not been controverted. We have already seen th

at

making of the contract was a part of the cause of action a

nd

a suit on a contract therefore could be filed at the pla

ce

where it was made. Thus Kaira court would even otherwi

se

have had jurisdiction. The bobbins of metallic yarn we

re

delivered at the address of the respondent at Salem whic

h,

therefore, would provide the connecting factor for Court

at

Salem to have jurisdiction. If out of the two jurisdictio

ns

one was excluded by Clause 11 it would not absolutely ou

st

the jurisdiction of the Court and, therefore, would not

be

void against public policy and would not violate sections

23

and 28 of the Contract Act. The question then is whether

it

can be construed to have excluded the jurisdiction of t

he

http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 18 of 18

Court at Salem. In the clause 'any dispute arising out

of

this sale shall be subject to Kaira jurisdiction' ex fac

ie

we do not find exclusive words like 'exclusive', 'alone

',

'only' and the like. Can the maxim 'expressio unius e

st

exclusio alterius' be applied under the facts and circu

m-

stances of the case? The order of confirmation is of

no

assistance. The other general terms and conditions are al

so

not indicative of exclusion of other jurisdictions. Und

er

the facts and circumstances of the case we hold that whi

le

connecting factor with Kaira jurisdiction was ensured

by

fixing the situs of the contract within Kaira, other juri

s-

dictions having connecting factors were not clearly, una

m-

biguously and explicitly excluded. That being the positi

on

it could not be said that the jurisdiction of the Court

at

Salem which Court otherwise had jurisdiction under l

aw

through connecting factor of delivery of goods there at w

as

expressly excluded. We accordingly find no error or infirm

i-

ty in the impugned judgment of the High Court.

In the result, this appeal fails and is dismissed. W

e,

however, leave the parties to bear their own costs.

Y.L. Appeal dismissed.

14

Reference cases

Description

Legal Notes

Add a Note....

Advance Search Tool

💡 How to Get the Best Legal Answers:

1. Keep it simple: Frame your question in plain language.

2. Add scope: Tag @ a court, judge, year, or act section for accurate results.

3. Attach files: Upload a PDF only if you are using a private document.

🌍 Ask in your language: English • Hindi • Assamese • Bangla • Gujarati • Kannada • Malayalam • Marathi • Odia • Punjabi • Tamil • Telugu • Urdu


💡 New Advocate? Don’t worry! Working without senior support today? Turn on Client Advisory to get instant legal strategies, practical angles, and precedent-backed options for your client.

Add research context Type to filter