As per the case facts the appellant was convicted of murder by the Sessions Judge a decision upheld by the High Court The appeal to the Supreme Court challenged this ... conviction and sentence The question arose whether the High Court correctly upheld the murder conviction and if the case should have been considered as culpable homicide not amounting to murder Finally the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal upholding the conviction and sentence under Section of the Indian Penal Code The Court found no grounds to overturn the consistent findings of the lower courts rejecting the argument for a lesser charge as the circumstances did not meet the exceptions for culpable homicide