As per the case facts, a writ petition was filed challenging the High Court's decision regarding judicial appointments. The petitioners sought to be inducted into judicial office, but candidates selected ... years ago were already serving. The High Court's previous decision was argued to be ultra vires certain rules. The question arose regarding the application of the doctrine of legitimate expectation in the context of judicial appointments and whether the High Court's decision was legally sound and consistent with fairness principles. Finally, the Supreme Court disposed of the petitions. While not directly answering the broader question referred to the Constitution Bench, the Court observed that unseating candidates who have been serving as judicial officers for several years would be contrary to public interest, as it would deprive the state of experienced judicial officers.